Crust Me, These 11 Indiana Cafés Serve Homemade Pies Worth The Trip

Indiana doesn’t get enough credit for its pie game, but trust me, this state is quietly serving up some of the best homemade slices in the Midwest. From flaky crusts to fillings that taste like they came straight from grandma’s kitchen, these cafés know how to do pie right.

Whether you’re craving something fruity, creamy, or downright decadent, these spots will make you want to plan a road trip immediately.

1. Gray Brothers Cafeteria, Mooresville

This place has been feeding hungry Hoosiers since 1972, and honestly, they’ve perfected the art of cafeteria comfort food. Gray Brothers Cafeteria is the kind of spot where the pie case sits right up front, tempting you before you even grab your tray.

Their coconut cream pie is legendary, piled high with fluffy meringue that could double as a cloud. But don’t sleep on the fruit pies either, especially the cherry, which tastes like summer bottled up in a crust.

The atmosphere is pure nostalgia, complete with wood paneling and booths that have seen decades of happy diners. You’ll leave with a full belly and probably a whole pie to go.

2. Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery, Danville

Where the smell of fresh bread hits you the second you walk in, you know you’re in for something special. Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery doesn’t just dabble in pies, they commit fully, baking them daily with a crust so buttery it practically melts on your tongue.

Their apple pie is a masterpiece, loaded with cinnamon and just the right amount of tartness. Pair it with a cup of their coffee, and you’ve got yourself a breakfast worth bragging about.

The café vibe is cozy without trying too hard, and the staff treats you like a regular, even if it’s your first visit. Grab a slice, or better yet, take home a whole one.

3. Chaperral Cafe, Shelbyville

Though it might not look like much from the outside, this little café packs a serious punch when it comes to pie. Chaperral Cafe serves up slices that are generous, delicious, and made with the kind of care you’d expect from a family recipe passed down through generations.

Their peanut butter pie is ridiculously good, rich and creamy without being too sweet. And if you’re feeling adventurous, try whatever seasonal flavor they’ve got going that day.

The café itself is unpretentious and friendly, the kind of place where locals gather and newcomers are welcomed with a smile. You’ll want to come back, probably more than once.

4. Grandma Vera’s Cafe & Bakery, West Terre Haute

Are you ready for pie that actually tastes like your grandma made it? Grandma Vera’s Cafe & Bakery lives up to its name in every possible way, serving homemade pies that are as comforting as a hug.

Their strawberry rhubarb pie is a standout, balancing sweet and tart in a way that feels like springtime on a fork. The crust is flaky, the filling is generous, and the portions are anything but stingy.

The café has that old-fashioned charm that makes you want to linger over your coffee and chat with the person at the next table. It’s the kind of place that reminds you why homemade will always beat store-bought.

5. Mrs. Wick’s Pies / Wicks’ Bakery & Cafe, Winchester

This iconic bakery has been churning out pies since 1944, and they’ve gotten really, really good at it. Mrs. Wick’s Pies is practically a household name in Indiana, known for their wide variety of flavors and consistently excellent quality.

Their sugar cream pie, Indiana’s unofficial state pie, is creamy, sweet, and utterly addictive. But they also do fruit pies, cream pies, and seasonal specialties that keep people coming back year after year.

The café attached to the bakery is charming and welcoming, perfect for enjoying a slice with a cup of coffee. It’s a must-visit for any serious pie lover traveling through the state.

6. FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale, Fortville / Fishers / Carmel

Did you think upscale dining meant sacrificing homemade pie? FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale proves that wrong with their scratch-made desserts that rival any grandma’s recipe. Their bourbon pecan pie is a showstopper, rich and nutty with a hint of sweetness that doesn’t overwhelm.

The crust is buttery perfection, and the filling is dense without being heavy. With locations in Fortville, Fishers, and Carmel, you’ve got options for where to indulge.

The restaurant itself has a rustic, farmhouse vibe that feels both modern and cozy. Whether you’re finishing off a hearty meal or just stopping by for dessert, their pie is absolutely worth it.

7. Pots & Pans Pie Co., Indianapolis

Hence the name, this place takes pie seriously, treating it like the art form it truly is. Pots & Pans Pie Co. is a small-batch bakery in Indianapolis that focuses on quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations.

Their salted caramel apple pie is out of this world, combining sweet, salty, and tart in every perfect bite. They also rotate seasonal flavors, so there’s always something new and exciting to try.

The bakery has a hip, modern feel, but the pies themselves are pure comfort. Whether you order a whole pie for a special occasion or just grab a slice to go, you’ll taste the difference that care and craftsmanship make.

8. Hostess House, Marion

However you feel about retro diners, this one will win you over with its pies alone. Hostess House has been a Marion staple for years, and their dessert menu is the stuff of local legend. The chocolate cream pie is dangerously good, with a silky filling that sits atop a crisp, buttery crust and gets topped with real whipped cream.

Their fruit pies rotate seasonally, so there’s always something new to try if you’re a repeat visitor. The diner vibe is authentic, complete with vinyl booths and friendly waitstaff who remember your order. It’s a slice of Americana served with, well, a slice of pie.

9. Lisa’s Pie Shop, Atlanta

When a place is called a pie shop, you know they’re not messing around. Lisa’s Pie Shop is a tiny jewel in the small town of Atlanta, and it’s worth the drive no matter where you’re coming from.

Their blueberry pie is bursting with flavor, made with real fruit and a crust that’s perfectly golden and flaky. Lisa herself often works behind the counter, and you can tell she pours her heart into every pie she makes.

The shop is cozy and unpretentious, the kind of spot where the pies do all the talking. Grab a slice to eat there or take a whole pie home, you won’t regret either choice.

10. The Flour Basket Bakery & Café, Rockville

Though Rockville is a small town, this bakery has a big reputation for its homemade pies. The Flour Basket Bakery & Café bakes everything fresh daily, and their pies are the kind that make you close your eyes and savor every bite.

Their peach pie is a summer favorite, loaded with juicy fruit and topped with a lattice crust that’s as pretty as it is delicious. The café is warm and welcoming, with a small-town charm that makes you feel right at home.

Stop in for breakfast or lunch, but whatever you do, save room for pie. It’s the kind of treat that turns a good day into a great one.

11. Auntie Em’s Coffee & Pie, Centerville

When you walk into a place called Auntie Em’s, you expect comfort, and this café delivers in spades. Auntie Em’s Coffee & Pie is a cozy spot in Centerville that pairs excellent coffee with homemade pies that taste like they came straight from a family kitchen.

Their lemon meringue pie is tangy and sweet, with a towering meringue that’s toasted to perfection. The café has a laid-back, friendly vibe, and the staff treats you like you’re part of the family.

It’s the perfect place to unwind with a slice and a cup of joe. You’ll leave feeling satisfied and probably already planning your next visit.