11 North Dakota Pizza Spots Worth Every Bite

North Dakota might not be the first place you think of when craving pizza, but I promise you’ll be surprised by what this state has to offer. From wood-fired pies to creative toppings that celebrate local flavors, pizza lovers can find some truly amazing spots across the Peace Garden State.

Whether you’re a resident looking for your next favorite slice or just passing through, these pizza places will make your taste buds dance with joy.

1. Fireflour Pizza – Bismarck

Authenticity matters when you’re talking about real Neapolitan pizza. Fireflour takes this seriously, using a wood-fired oven that reaches temperatures hot enough to create those signature charred bubbles on the crust.

Every pizza here cooks in just 90 seconds, which means you get that perfect balance of smoky flavor and tender dough. I appreciate how they keep the menu focused on quality rather than overwhelming you with a hundred options. The Margherita pizza showcases their skill with simple ingredients done right.

The casual vibe encourages you to relax and savor each bite slowly. If you’ve never tried authentic Neapolitan-style pizza before, this spot will be your delicious introduction to what pizza was meant to taste like.

2. Pirogue Grille – Bismarck

Sometimes you want pizza that feels a little more sophisticated without losing that comfort food appeal. Pirogue Grille nails this balance with their creative flatbread pizzas that taste as good as they look on the plate.

Their menu changes seasonally, which means you’ll always find something new and exciting to try. I’ve enjoyed everything from their BBQ chicken flatbread to more adventurous combinations featuring roasted vegetables and artisan cheeses. The crust is thin and crispy, letting the toppings shine through.

The restaurant itself has a refined atmosphere that makes it ideal for special occasions or business lunches. You’ll leave feeling satisfied but not overly stuffed, which is the perfect way to end a meal.

3. Blackbird Woodfire – Fargo

There’s something magical about watching flames dance around your pizza as it cooks in a wood-fired oven. Blackbird Woodfire brings that experience right to downtown Fargo with style and substance.

Their commitment to using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients shows in every bite you take. The dough ferments for days, developing complex flavors that make even a simple cheese pizza taste extraordinary. I’m always impressed by how they balance innovative toppings without making things too complicated or weird.

The open kitchen design lets you watch the pizza makers work their craft, which adds to the whole experience. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for dinner, this spot delivers consistently excellent pizza every single time.

4. Duane’s House of Pizza – Minot

Old-school pizza joints have a charm that modern places sometimes can’t replicate. Duane’s has been a Minot institution for decades, serving up pies that remind you why pizza became America’s favorite food.

Their secret lies in consistency and not trying to reinvent the wheel with every order. The sauce has a slight sweetness that complements the savory toppings perfectly, and the cheese blend melts into golden perfection. I find myself craving their classic pepperoni pizza whenever I’m in the area.

The staff treats regulars like family, and newcomers quickly feel welcomed into the fold. It’s the kind of place where generations have celebrated birthdays, game wins, and Friday nights together over steaming hot pizza.

5. Tavern 65 Grill & Bar – Dickinson

Game day calls for serious pizza, and Tavern 65 delivers exactly what you need when hunger strikes hard. Their pizzas are built for sharing with friends while cheering on your favorite team.

What I appreciate most is how they load up the toppings without making the pizza soggy or overwhelming. The crust holds up beautifully even under the weight of multiple meats and vegetables. Their specialty pizzas showcase creative combinations, but you can also build your own masterpiece from their extensive topping list.

The bar atmosphere adds energy to your meal, making it feel like an event rather than just dinner. Cold drinks and hot pizza make for an unbeatable combination when you’re looking for casual fun.

6. Mezzaluna – Fargo

Upscale dining doesn’t mean you have to skip the pizza, especially when it’s done with Italian finesse. Mezzaluna brings authentic Italian cooking techniques to Fargo, and their pizza reflects years of culinary tradition.

The thin crust crackles when you bite into it, giving way to fresh mozzarella and imported ingredients that transport your taste buds straight to Italy. I’m always tempted by their prosciutto and arugula pizza, which balances salty and peppery flavors beautifully. Each pizza is sized perfectly for one person as an entree.

The elegant atmosphere makes this spot ideal for date nights or celebrating special occasions. You’ll pay a bit more here, but the quality and experience justify every dollar spent.

7. Pounds Restaurant – Grand Forks

Some restaurants have been around so long they become part of the community’s story. Pounds has been serving hungry customers since way back, and their pizza recipe has stood the test of time beautifully.

What makes their pizza stand out is the generous portions and homemade sauce that tastes like your Italian grandmother made it. The cheese stretches for days, and the crust has that satisfying crunch on the outside while staying soft inside. You can tell they don’t cut corners with ingredients.

Families gather here on weekends, and the noise level tells you everyone’s having a great time. Their medium pizza could easily feed three hungry people, so come with an appetite or plan to take leftovers home.

8. Pizza Ranch – Multiple Locations

Buffets bring out the kid in all of us, letting you sample different flavors without committing to just one choice. Pizza Ranch operates several locations across North Dakota, making it easy to find one near you.

Their buffet includes numerous pizza varieties along with fried chicken, which is a unique combination that works surprisingly well. I enjoy being able to try a slice of taco pizza, then switch to classic pepperoni, and finish with dessert pizza all in one meal. The crust leans toward thicker and breadier, which fills you up quickly.

Families love this place because there’s something for everyone, and the prices won’t break the bank. It’s casual, friendly, and perfect for those nights when everyone wants something different.

9. Rhombus Guys Pizza – Fargo

Walking into this place feels like coming home after a long day. The smell of fresh-baked dough hits you immediately, and you know something special is about to happen.

Rhombus Guys has mastered the art of combining classic pizza traditions with bold, unexpected flavors. Their menu features everything from traditional pepperoni to adventurous combinations like Thai chicken that’ll make you rethink what pizza can be. Each pie comes out with a perfectly crispy crust that has just the right amount of chew.

I love how they source local ingredients whenever possible, giving each bite a taste of North Dakota pride. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it perfect for family dinners or casual dates.

10. Toasted Frog – Grand Forks

Contemporary American cuisine meets pizza craftsmanship at this popular Grand Forks destination. Toasted Frog has built a reputation for taking familiar foods and elevating them with unexpected twists and high-quality ingredients.

Their flatbread pizzas feature inventive topping combinations that change with the seasons and chef’s inspiration. I’ve tried versions with everything from fig jam to Korean BBQ influences, and each one teaches me something new about what pizza can become. The presentation is always Instagram-worthy without sacrificing flavor.

The energetic atmosphere and creative cocktails make this more than just a meal – it’s an experience. If you’re feeling adventurous and want to expand your pizza horizons, this spot will definitely deliver.

11. Spicy Pie Pizza – Fargo

Late-night cravings demand a hero, and Spicy Pie answers that call with huge slices of New York-style pizza. Their slices are almost comically large, folding in half the way proper NY pizza should.

The beauty here is simplicity done right – thin crust with just enough chew, tangy sauce, and quality cheese that doesn’t get greasy. I love that you can grab a slice or two without committing to a whole pie, making it perfect for solo dining or quick bites. Their by-the-slice model means the pizza is constantly fresh from the oven.

The casual, no-frills atmosphere fits the vibe perfectly. Whether you’re a college student studying late or just someone who appreciates honest, delicious pizza, this place hits the spot every time.