All-You-Can-Eat Buffets In Ohio That Locals Say Are Always Worth It

Ohio has some amazing all-you-can-eat buffets that locals absolutely love. Whether you’re craving comfort food, international flavors, or fresh seafood, these spots deliver quality and variety without breaking the bank.

I’ve rounded up the best buffets across the state that keep people coming back for more.

1. Der Dutchman in Plain City

Comfort food lovers will find heaven here with authentic Amish cooking that tastes like grandma made it. Homemade noodles, fried chicken, and fresh-baked bread are just the beginning of what you’ll discover.

I always recommend trying the mashed potatoes and gravy alongside their famous broasted chicken. The dessert bar features pies that locals drive hours to enjoy, especially the peanut butter cream.

2. Hibachi Grill Supreme Buffet in Columbus

Walking into this place feels like stepping into a food wonderland with over 200 items to choose from. Fresh sushi rolls sit next to steaming hibachi dishes, giving you endless combinations to try.

You can watch chefs prepare custom stir-fry right before your eyes at the Mongolian grill station. The seafood selection includes crab legs on weekends, which always creates a buzz among regulars.

3. Golden Corral in Multiple Ohio Locations

This national chain has perfected the art of variety with something for even the pickiest eaters in your group. Carved meats, rotisserie chicken, and pot roast satisfy hearty appetites every single time.

Kids go crazy for the chocolate fountain and unlimited soft-serve ice cream options available. I find their breakfast buffet particularly impressive with made-to-order omelets and fresh waffles keeping everyone happy.

4. Ponderosa Steakhouse in Various Ohio Cities

Steak lovers appreciate being able to order a grilled piece of meat while enjoying unlimited buffet sides. Hot wings, macaroni and cheese, and their famous Texas toast create the ultimate comfort meal experience.

Their salad bar goes beyond basic lettuce with fresh vegetables and toppings galore for customization. Weekend visits often mean prime rib specials that disappear quickly among knowledgeable locals.

5. Shady Maple Smorgasbord Style at Dutch Valley Restaurant in Sugarcreek

Authentic Pennsylvania Dutch recipes shine at this Amish country gem tucked away in charming Sugarcreek. Chicken and noodles prepared the old-fashioned way bring people back week after week without fail.

Seasonal vegetables come straight from local farms, ensuring peak freshness in every bite you take. Their ham loaf and sweet corn fritters represent traditional dishes you simply cannot find anywhere else around.

6. China Buffet in Dayton

Locals praise the consistently fresh food and cleanliness that makes every visit feel welcoming and comfortable. Bourbon chicken and honey chicken compete for the title of most popular dish among regular customers.

Their sushi selection impresses considering the affordable price point they maintain throughout the week. Families appreciate the kid-friendly options like chicken nuggets sitting alongside more adventurous international choices.

7. Olive Garden’s Never Ending Pasta Bowl Promotion

Although technically not a traditional buffet, this limited-time promotion delivers unlimited pasta combinations worth mentioning. Choose your pasta, sauce, and toppings while enjoying those famous unlimited breadsticks everyone craves.

I recommend trying different sauce combinations throughout your meal to maximize the experience fully. The promotion runs seasonally, so locals mark their calendars and plan visits accordingly every single year.

8. Pizza Ranch in Multiple Ohio Locations

Pizza and chicken might seem like an odd combination, but this Midwestern chain makes it work beautifully. Crispy fried chicken rivals any dedicated chicken restaurant while pizzas rotate with creative toppings constantly.

Their dessert pizza with cinnamon and icing creates the perfect sweet treat after savory dishes. Families love the relaxed atmosphere where kids can be kids without worrying about fancy dining rules.

9. Yoder’s Kitchen in Millersburg

Located in the heart of Amish Country, this family-owned spot serves up authentic home-cooked meals that taste like grandma made them herself. Locals rave about the fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and noodles that are rolled fresh daily.

The buffet features rotating seasonal dishes alongside classic comfort foods that never disappoint. You’ll find everything from tender pot roast to creamy mac and cheese, plus homemade pies that are absolutely legendary.

What makes this place special is the genuine hospitality and the fact that recipes have been passed down through generations. Prices are reasonable, portions are generous, and the atmosphere feels warm and welcoming every single time you visit.

10. The Spread Eagle Tavern in Hanoverton

Step back in time at Ohio’s oldest continuously operating tavern, where Sunday brunch buffets have become a beloved tradition since 1837. The historic setting adds charm to every meal, with original architecture and period furnishings creating an unforgettable atmosphere.

Their seasonal buffets showcase locally sourced ingredients transformed into elevated comfort dishes. Expect carved roasts, fresh salads, decadent desserts, and signature items like their famous sticky buns that regulars plan their visits around.

While slightly pricier than typical buffets, the experience justifies every penny with exceptional food quality and unique ambiance. Reservations are strongly recommended, especially for weekend brunches when both tourists and locals fill the historic dining rooms to capacity.