Must-Try Seafood Restaurants Across Pennsylvania Offering Endless Plates Of Flavor
Pennsylvania might not have an ocean coastline, but that doesn’t stop it from serving some of the freshest and most delicious seafood you’ll ever taste. From historic oyster houses to cozy lakeside spots, the state is packed with restaurants that bring coastal flavors right to your table.
Whether you’re craving buttery lobster rolls, perfectly steamed clams, or crispy fried fish, I’ve rounded up the absolute best places to satisfy your seafood cravings across Pennsylvania.
1. Youell’s Oyster House – Allentown
Did you know that some restaurants have been serving seafood for over a century? Youell’s Oyster House opened its doors way back in 1895, making it one of Pennsylvania’s oldest seafood spots. Walking into this place feels like stepping back in time, with its classic atmosphere and commitment to quality that hasn’t changed in generations.
What makes this restaurant truly special is its daily-changing oyster selection from both the East and West coasts. You’ll find signature dishes like oysters Rockefeller, which are baked with herbs and butter until golden. The broiled seafood combos are massive and perfect for sharing with family or friends.
If you’re new to oysters, the friendly staff will help you pick the perfect variety to match your taste preferences.
2. Marblehead Chowder House – Pocono Lake
It’s hard to believe you’re in Pennsylvania when you step inside this charming red barn-style building. Marblehead Chowder House brings authentic New England flavors straight to the Pocono Mountains, and locals absolutely love it. The rustic atmosphere makes every meal feel like a special coastal getaway without the long drive.
Their award-winning clam chowder is thick, creamy, and loaded with tender clam pieces that melt in your mouth. The lobster rolls are stuffed generously with fresh lobster meat and served on buttery toasted buns. You’ll also find other New England favorites like fish and chips and seafood platters.
When summer arrives, grab a seat on the outdoor patio and enjoy mountain views while savoring your seafood feast.
3. Henry’s Salt of the Sea – Bensalem
Since 1975, this family-owned gem has been serving portions so big you’ll probably need a takeout box. Henry’s Salt of the Sea has that nostalgic, homey feel that reminds you of Sunday dinners at grandma’s house. The walls are decorated with nautical memorabilia that tells stories of decades past.
Their signature crab imperial is absolutely legendary, featuring lump crab meat baked with a rich, creamy sauce that’s perfectly seasoned. Every dish comes with sides that could be meals on their own. The staff treats you like family, remembering regular customers and making newcomers feel instantly welcome.
If you’re celebrating a birthday or special occasion, this is the perfect place to gather everyone for a memorable seafood feast.
4. Smuggler’s Cove – Lake Harmony
Imagine eating fresh seafood while surrounded by beautiful mountain scenery and a lighthouse-themed restaurant. Smuggler’s Cove in Lake Harmony offers exactly that unique combination. The Poconos location gives you stunning views that change with every season, making each visit feel brand new.
Their famous seafood pot is an absolute showstopper, arriving at your table overflowing with lobster, crab, shrimp, clams, and mussels. It’s cooked in a flavorful broth that you’ll want to soak up with crusty bread. The portions are huge, so bring your appetite or plan to share.
When the weather’s nice, the outdoor seating lets you breathe in fresh mountain air while cracking open crab legs and enjoying lakeside views.
5. Anastasi Seafood – Philadelphia
How often do you find Italian cuisine perfectly blended with fresh seafood in one incredible restaurant? Anastasi Seafood sits right in Philadelphia’s historic Italian Market, where generations of families have shopped for fresh ingredients. The restaurant carries on that tradition by combining Old World Italian recipes with the freshest catches available.
Their grilled octopus is tender and charred to perfection, served with olive oil and lemon that brings out its natural flavors. The seafood risotto is creamy and packed with shrimp, scallops, and mussels. Every dish reflects the Italian passion for simple ingredients prepared with skill and love.
After your meal, take a stroll through the market to experience one of Philadelphia’s most vibrant and historic neighborhoods.
6. Pearl’s Oyster Bar – Philadelphia
Are you ready to taste some of the freshest oysters in Pennsylvania? Pearl’s Oyster Bar is tucked inside Reading Terminal Market, one of America’s oldest and largest public markets. The bustling atmosphere around you adds excitement to every meal, with vendors selling everything from fresh produce to handmade crafts.
Their oyster selection changes based on what’s freshest, and each one is shucked right in front of you. The seafood chowder is rich and warming, perfect for chilly Philadelphia days. Fish tacos are surprisingly light yet packed with flavor, topped with crispy cabbage and tangy sauce.
Since it’s located in the market, you can easily grab dessert or coffee from nearby vendors after finishing your seafood meal.
7. Clam Tavern – Essington
Don’t let the simple exterior fool you because this unassuming tavern has been serving exceptional seafood since 1962. Clam Tavern proves that you don’t need fancy decorations when your food speaks for itself. Locals have been keeping this place busy for over six decades, and once you taste the food, you’ll understand why.
The fried clam strips are crispy on the outside and tender inside, never greasy or overcooked. What many people don’t know is there’s a secret off-menu seafood combo that includes amazing deviled clams. The portions are generous, and prices remain surprisingly affordable despite the high quality.
It’s the kind of neighborhood spot where everyone knows each other, and you’ll leave feeling like a regular even on your first visit.
8. Yardley Inn – Yardley
There’s something magical about eating fresh seafood while watching the Delaware River flow past your table. Yardley Inn combines historic charm with stunning waterfront views that make every meal feel romantic and special. The building itself has stood alongside the river for generations, welcoming travelers and locals alike.
Soft-shell crabs are prepared perfectly here, lightly fried so the entire crab is crispy and edible. The seafood pot pie is comfort food at its finest, with chunks of fish, shrimp, and scallops swimming in creamy sauce under a flaky golden crust. The riverside location means you might spot boats passing by while you eat.
If you’re planning a date night or anniversary dinner, request a window seat to maximize those gorgeous river views.
9. The Lobster Pot – Harrisburg
When you walk past the live lobster tanks at the entrance, you know you’re in for authentic seafood. The Lobster Pot brings coastal New England dining straight to Pennsylvania’s capital city. The casual atmosphere makes it perfect for families, date nights, or just treating yourself to something special after a long week.
Their lobster is cooked to perfection, whether you order it steamed with butter or in a creamy lobster bisque. The crab cakes are made with real lump crab meat and minimal filler, so every bite tastes like the ocean. They also offer landlubber options for anyone in your group who isn’t a seafood fan.
The staff is knowledgeable about preparing methods and can guide you through the menu if you’re unsure what to order.
10. Captain’s Catch – Pittsburgh
Pittsburgh might be famous for steel and pierogies, but Captain’s Catch proves the city knows seafood too. This modern restaurant focuses on sustainable fishing practices and bringing the freshest catches to western Pennsylvania. The sleek interior feels upscale without being stuffy or pretentious.
Their daily fresh catch board shows exactly what arrived that morning, and the chef will prepare it however you like. Grilled fish is seasoned simply to let natural flavors shine through. The raw bar offers oysters, clams, and shrimp cocktail that taste like they came straight from the ocean.
If you’re health-conscious, you’ll appreciate that many dishes are grilled or baked rather than fried, giving you lighter options without sacrificing flavor or satisfaction.
11. The Wharf – Erie
Being right on Lake Erie gives this restaurant a major advantage when it comes to freshness. The Wharf specializes in both ocean seafood and fresh lake fish, offering a unique menu you won’t find elsewhere in Pennsylvania. Watching the sunset over the water while eating dinner creates memories that last long after the meal ends.
Their Lake Erie perch is lightly breaded and fried until golden, with delicate white meat that flakes apart perfectly. You’ll also find traditional favorites like shrimp scampi and clam linguine. The outdoor deck is the place to be during summer months.
Local fishermen sometimes deliver their catch directly to the restaurant, ensuring everything on your plate is as fresh as possible.
12. Dockside Willies – Wrightsville
If you love eating outdoors with water views, Dockside Willies is your new favorite spot. Located right on the Susquehanna River, this casual restaurant has a laid-back vibe that makes everyone feel relaxed. Boaters often pull up to the dock, tie off, and walk straight in for lunch or dinner.
The fried seafood platters are massive, featuring shrimp, scallops, fish, and clams all cooked to crispy perfection. Their crab pretzel is a unique twist on traditional crab dip, served hot with soft pretzel pieces for dipping. Cold beer and frozen drinks complement the seafood perfectly.
During summer weekends, live music adds to the fun atmosphere, making it feel like a mini vacation without leaving Pennsylvania.
13. The Seafood Shack – Lancaster
Though Lancaster is famous for Amish country and farmland, The Seafood Shack brings coastal flavors to this agricultural heartland. The casual, picnic-style atmosphere encourages you to roll up your sleeves and dig into messy, delicious seafood. Brown paper covers the tables, and mallets are provided for cracking shells.
Their seafood boils come out in huge pots filled with shrimp, sausage, corn, and potatoes all seasoned with spicy Cajun flavors. Steamed crabs by the dozen are perfect for groups who want to spend hours talking and eating together. The casual vibe means kids are welcome and messes are expected.
It’s refreshing to find a place where you can truly relax and enjoy your meal without worrying about fancy table manners or dress codes.
14. Pier 34 – Bethlehem
Bethlehem’s industrial history inspired the modern, industrial-chic design of Pier 34. This contemporary seafood restaurant brings a fresh, innovative approach to classic dishes while respecting traditional flavors. The open kitchen lets you watch chefs work their magic, adding entertainment to your dining experience.
Their raw bar selection is impressive, featuring oysters from different regions so you can compare flavors and textures. Modern twists on classics include miso-glazed cod and seafood pasta with unexpected ingredient combinations. The craft cocktail menu pairs beautifully with seafood, featuring creative drinks you won’t find anywhere else.
Whether you’re celebrating something special or just want an elevated dining experience, Pier 34 delivers sophistication without pretension in every dish they serve.
