New York Seafood Buffets Locals Say Are Worth Every Dollar
New York City is famous for many things, but its seafood buffets might just be one of the best-kept secrets among locals.
When you’re craving fresh crab legs, succulent shrimp, or oysters on the half shell, these all-you-can-eat spots deliver incredible variety without breaking the bank.
From Midtown Manhattan to the outer boroughs, I’ve gathered the top seafood buffets that New Yorkers actually recommend to their friends and family. Get ready to discover where the freshest catches meet unbeatable value in the city that never sleeps.
1. Crab House NYC
When it comes to premium seafood experiences in Midtown Manhattan, few places match this spot’s reputation. Located on East 55th Street, this restaurant offers an all-you-can-eat buffet where every dish gets freshly prepared when you order it.
For $80 per person, you’ll enjoy jumbo crab legs, shrimp, mussels, and much more. If you’re feeling extra fancy, upgrade to the lobster buffet for $115 per person. The quality here speaks for itself, with over 2,000 positive reviews from satisfied diners.
What sets this place apart is the made-to-order approach rather than sitting under heat lamps. Your seafood arrives hot and perfectly cooked every single time.
2. Sea & Sky Feast Buffet
Flushing, Queens hides one of the most exciting seafood buffet experiences you’ll find anywhere in the city. This spot combines traditional buffet offerings with live cooking stations that bring theater to your meal.
Snow crab clusters and green-lipped mussels sit alongside custom-made sushi rolls prepared right before your eyes. The live seafood boil stations let you watch your dinner come together, adding a fun interactive element to the experience. Prices range from $30 to $50, making it incredibly affordable for the variety offered.
With nearly 500 reviews averaging four stars, locals clearly appreciate the value here. The extensive selection means everyone in your group will find something they love.
3. The Smith NoMad
Broadway hosts this beloved American restaurant that serves up a riverboat bounty-style seafood buffet unlike anything else in the neighborhood. The rustic tavern atmosphere immediately makes you feel comfortable and welcomed.
Fried oysters, clams casino, snow crab claws, and lobster mac and cheese headline the impressive spread. Each dish captures that classic American comfort food spirit while maintaining high quality standards. Over 6,000 reviews with a 4.4-star average prove this place consistently delivers.
Prices fall in the $30 to $50 range, which feels reasonable given the location and quality. The combination of great food and cozy ambiance makes this a favorite among locals who want a reliable seafood feast.
4. Lakruwana Restaurant
Staten Island surprises many visitors with its incredible cultural dining options, and this family-owned gem stands out. Bay Street hosts this authentic Sri Lankan restaurant where seafood meets traditional island spices in the most delicious ways.
Fragrant rice, coconut sambol, fiery curries, and crisp hoppers create a buffet experience you won’t find anywhere else in New York. The all-you-can-eat format lets you explore flavors that might be completely new to you. At just $20 to $30 per person, it’s one of the best bargains in the entire city.
With 1,039 reviews and a 4.5-star rating, locals clearly treasure this unique spot for its authentic approach to Sri Lankan cuisine.
5. Pier A Harbor House
Battery Park’s waterfront location gives this restaurant an unbeatable setting for enjoying fresh seafood with stunning harbor views. The historic building adds character that modern restaurants simply can’t replicate.
While not a traditional buffet, their oyster bar and seafood towers offer an all-you-can-enjoy experience during special events and happy hours. Fresh clams, oysters, shrimp, and crab arrive on ice, maintaining perfect temperature and freshness. The outdoor seating area lets you soak in the breeze while you feast.
Locals recommend coming during weekday happy hours when prices drop significantly. The combination of location, quality, and atmosphere makes every dollar spent here feel worthwhile, especially when the sun sets over the water.
6. Grand Central Oyster Bar
Grand Central Terminal houses one of New York’s most iconic seafood destinations, operating since 1913. The vaulted tile ceilings and vintage atmosphere transport you back to a different era of dining.
Their raw bar offers dozens of oyster varieties from both coasts, along with clams, shrimp, and other cold seafood selections. Though not a traditional buffet, the pan roasts and seafood platters provide generous portions that feel endless. Prices vary, but lunch specials offer excellent value for the quality and location.
Tourists flock here, but locals know the best times to visit for shorter waits. The combination of history, quality, and convenience makes this a special place worth every penny spent on fresh seafood.
7. Red Hook Lobster Pound
Brooklyn’s Red Hook neighborhood brings authentic Maine seafood culture to New York City through this beloved local spot. The casual atmosphere feels like visiting a coastal shack without leaving the city.
Their seafood boils offer all-you-can-eat options during special events, featuring lobsters, clams, mussels, corn, and potatoes cooked in traditional New England style. The famous lobster rolls alone make the trip worthwhile, packed generously with fresh meat. Prices stay reasonable, especially considering the quality of seafood flown in regularly from Maine.
Locals appreciate the no-frills approach that focuses entirely on food quality. When you want authentic New England seafood without pretension, this place delivers exactly what you’re craving every single time.
8. Randazzo’s Clam Bar
Sheepshead Bay in Brooklyn has long been synonymous with fresh seafood, and this family-run establishment exemplifies that tradition perfectly. Three generations have served locals here, maintaining recipes and quality standards that never waver.
Their Sunday seafood feasts function like informal buffets, with platters of clams, mussels, calamari, and fish arriving continuously at your table. The Italian-American preparations highlight the seafood rather than hiding it under heavy sauces. Portions are incredibly generous, and prices remain surprisingly affordable for the amount of food provided.
Regulars often call ahead for special occasions when the restaurant prepares even more elaborate spreads. The family atmosphere and consistent quality make this a neighborhood treasure that visitors should definitely experience.
9. City Island Lobster House
City Island feels like a New England fishing village tucked into the Bronx, and this restaurant captures that coastal spirit beautifully. The waterfront location provides peaceful views that help you forget you’re still in New York City.
Weekend brunches feature seafood buffet spreads with everything from smoked fish to fresh shellfish and made-to-order omelets with lobster. The lobster tanks near the entrance guarantee freshness, and you can even pick your own. Prices are moderate, especially given the waterfront setting and generous portions provided.
Locals treat this place like their personal escape from city life. The combination of fresh air, water views, and excellent seafood creates an experience that justifies the trip to this unique neighborhood every time.
10. Flex Mussels
Multiple locations across Manhattan make this restaurant incredibly convenient for seafood lovers throughout the city. The name tells you their specialty, but they offer so much more than just mussels.
Their all-you-can-eat mussel nights let you sample different preparation styles, from Thai coconut curry to classic white wine garlic. Fresh oysters, clams, and other shellfish round out the offerings. The modern, upscale atmosphere feels special without being stuffy or intimidating to casual diners.
Prices hover around $40 to $60 depending on location and what you order. Locals appreciate the consistent quality across all locations and the creative flavor combinations. When you want reliably excellent seafood in a contemporary setting, this restaurant always delivers satisfaction.
11. Brooklyn Crab
Red Hook boasts another seafood gem that combines dining with entertainment in the most unexpected ways. Three levels of dining space include a rooftop bar with mini golf, making this a destination rather than just a meal.
Their crab feasts serve as informal buffets where buckets of steamed crabs, shrimp, clams, and corn arrive at your table covered in Old Bay seasoning. The casual, messy eating experience feels liberating and fun. Prices are reasonable for the amount of seafood and the unique atmosphere provided.
Summer weekends get crowded, but locals know weekday evenings offer the same great food with shorter waits. The waterfront views and playful vibe make this spot perfect for groups celebrating special occasions together.
12. Aquagrill
SoHo dining reaches new heights at this elegant seafood restaurant that has served discerning customers for over two decades. The sophisticated atmosphere attracts both locals and visitors seeking refined seafood experiences.
Their raw bar features up to 25 oyster varieties daily, along with clams, shrimp, and other pristine shellfish. Weekend brunch includes seafood buffet elements with smoked fish platters and made-to-order dishes. Prices reflect the upscale neighborhood, but the quality justifies every dollar spent here.
Locals celebrate special occasions at this restaurant because the service and food never disappoint. The extensive wine list pairs perfectly with seafood selections. When you want to impress someone or treat yourself, this spot delivers an unforgettable dining experience.
13. Lure Fishbar
SoHo’s Mercer Street hosts this trendy seafood restaurant designed to resemble a luxury yacht’s interior. The nautical theme feels authentic rather than gimmicky, creating an immersive dining environment.
Their seafood plateaus serve multiple people with towering arrangements of oysters, clams, shrimp, crab, and lobster on ice. The sushi bar adds Asian-inspired options to the menu. Prices land in the $50 to $70 range per person, which matches the upscale neighborhood and quality ingredients used.
Locals recommend the happy hour specials when seafood prices drop significantly. The energetic atmosphere and consistently fresh seafood make this a reliable choice. Whether you’re on a date or out with friends, the vibe here always feels exciting and special.
14. Seamore’s
Sustainability meets delicious seafood at this growing chain with locations in several Manhattan neighborhoods. The commitment to responsible sourcing appeals to environmentally conscious diners who refuse to compromise on taste.
Their build-your-own seafood bowls and platters let you create personalized feasts with various fish, shellfish, and preparation styles. Weekend specials sometimes include all-you-can-eat oyster promotions. Prices stay moderate, typically $30 to $45 per person, making sustainable choices accessible to more people.
Locals love knowing exactly where their seafood comes from and how it was caught. The casual, beachy atmosphere feels relaxed and welcoming. When you want to eat well while supporting responsible fishing practices, this restaurant makes it easy and enjoyable every visit.
15. Mermaid Inn
East Village locals treasure this cozy seafood spot that brings New England coastal charm to downtown Manhattan. The intimate dining room feels like discovering a hidden gem in your own neighborhood.
Their famous oyster happy hour offers dollar oysters and discounted seafood platters, creating an affordable all-you-can-eat experience for shellfish lovers. The lobster rolls, fish tacos, and daily catches round out the menu beautifully. Prices during regular hours range from $35 to $55, but happy hour provides incredible value.
Multiple locations now exist, but the original East Village spot maintains special character that regulars adore. The friendly service and consistently delicious food create a welcoming atmosphere. When you want neighborhood charm with excellent seafood, this place never lets you down.
