11 New Jersey Catfish Shacks Where Locals Gather For Weekend Feasts

New Jersey might not be the first place that comes to mind when thinking about catfish, but the Garden State has quietly become home to some incredible spots serving up this Southern comfort classic.

From Jersey City to the shore towns, locals know exactly where to find crispy, golden catfish on weekends. These humble shacks and neighborhood joints offer the kind of authentic flavors that keep people coming back for more.

1. Mathews Food And Drink

Southern hospitality meets Jersey City charm at this beloved neighborhood gathering spot. The menu celebrates bold, comforting flavors with dishes that transport diners straight to the heart of the South.

Hot Honey Chicken and Shrimp Corn Fritters share the spotlight alongside other soul-warming classics. Weekend crowds fill the space, drawn by the welcoming vibe and generous portions that make every visit feel special.

2. Krewe Of McGinley Square

Big Easy energy flows through every corner of this New Orleans-inspired gem. Blackened catfish steals the show here, seasoned with a spice blend that delivers heat and depth in every bite.

The tender, flaky texture pairs beautifully with traditional sides. Locals appreciate the authentic approach to Creole cooking, making this a weekend destination for those craving Louisiana flavors without leaving New Jersey.

3. Scale Fish Market

Fresh catches and expert seasoning define this neighborhood treasure. The catfish arrives perfectly prepared, with a flavor profile that consistently earns top ratings from Jersey City seafood lovers.

Simple preparation lets the quality shine through. Regulars swing by on Saturdays to pick up their favorites, knowing exactly what to expect: honest, delicious seafood without any fuss or pretense.

4. The Chippery

Crispy coatings and hearty portions have earned this spot a loyal following. The signature catfish arrives with a satisfying crunch that gives way to moist, flavorful fish underneath.

Generous servings mean nobody leaves hungry. Families and friends gather around tables on weekend afternoons, sharing baskets of perfectly fried seafood that hits all the right comfort food notes every single time.

5. Ambassador Fish And Chicken

Authentic Southern-style seafood keeps locals lining up at this no-frills favorite. The catfish comes seasoned with a blend that balances spice and savory notes, delivering flavors reminiscent of down-home cooking.

Quick service and reasonable prices make it ideal for casual weekend meals. Whether dining in or taking out, customers know they can count on consistently flavorful catfish that satisfies those soul food cravings.

6. Central Fish Market

Variety meets simplicity at this easygoing seafood spot. Among the rotating selection of fresh catches, the catfish stands out for its careful preparation and straightforward approach.

The casual setting encourages relaxed weekend dining. Locals appreciate the unpretentious atmosphere where good seafood takes center stage, proving that sometimes the best meals come from the most unassuming places in the neighborhood.

7. Off The Hook

Dock-to-table freshness defines this shore town destination. Located right in Viking Village, the catfish arrives with the kind of freshness only waterfront locations can truly deliver.

Salt air and scenic views enhance every meal. Weekend visitors enjoy watching boats come in while savoring seafood that tastes like it was swimming just hours earlier, making the trip to Barnegat Light absolutely worthwhile.

8. Pinky Shrimp’s Seafood Co.

Beach town energy meets seafood excellence at this vibrant gathering spot. Picnic tables and a lively atmosphere create the perfect backdrop for enjoying catfish alongside other coastal favorites.

Takeout options make beach picnics easy. Families load up on seafood before heading to the sand, while others linger at the tables, soaking up the relaxed Beach Haven vibe that makes shore weekends feel special.

9. Corinne’s Place

The aromas drifting from the kitchen hint at the generations of tradition behind every dish. Slow-cooked favorites like smothered turkey wings and buttery collard greens reflect the deep roots of Southern cooking, each plate prepared with unmistakable care.

Regulars return for the warmth that fills the dining room as much as the food itself. Meals here feel unhurried and familiar, inviting guests to settle in and savor flavors that taste like they were passed down through family hands.

10. Just Fish Bar & Grill

Fresh catch arrives daily, ready to be transformed into golden fried platters and hearty seafood dinners that keep locals coming back. Crisp perch and flaky whiting remain crowd favorites, seasoned with the kind of confidence that comes from years of perfecting the craft.

The energy feels lively yet relaxed, the kind of place where conversation flows easily while baskets of seafood disappear just as quickly. Each visit feels like a reminder that simple, well-prepared fish never goes out of style.

11. Paula’s Soul Food Cafe

Comfort starts the moment you walk in, carried by the scent of cornbread, simmering gravy, and fried chicken fresh from the skillet. The menu celebrates soul food traditions with sincerity, from tender oxtails to creamy mac and cheese that pulls at the heart as much as the palate.

Seafood dishes shine too, especially the whiting and shrimp plates, seasoned boldly and cooked with a practiced hand.