Ohio Pizza Spots That Will Make You Want To Travel Hours For A Slice
Ohio has become a pizza lover’s paradise with incredible spots serving everything from deep-dish masterpieces to thin-crust wonders.
You’ll find family-run shops that have perfected their recipes over decades alongside trendy newcomers pushing creative boundaries.
Whether you crave classic toppings or wild flavor combinations, these pizzerias deliver unforgettable experiences worth any road trip.
Get ready to discover the best pizza destinations across the Buckeye State that will have you planning your next slice adventure.
1. Angelo’s Pizza
Family recipes passed down through generations create something truly special at this beloved spot.
You’ll find this gem at 13715 Madison Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107, where it has been serving customers since 1981.
The deep-dish pizza here features a crispy bottom and chewy interior that sets it apart from typical pies.
Homemade ingredients get paired with a secret sweet-tangy sauce that keeps people coming back year after year.
Every bite delivers layers of flavor thanks to the careful attention paid to each component.
The atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, making you feel like part of the family from the moment you walk in.
2. Mikey’s Late Night Slice
Late-night cravings meet their match with these enormous New York-style slices available until 3 AM.
This spot operates at 1030 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, having grown from humble food truck beginnings.
Each slice is big enough to fold in half, just like authentic New York pizza should be.
Creative toppings like Spicy Ass Pepperoni and Unicorn Sauce show the playful spirit behind the menu.
The massive portions mean one slice might be enough for your entire meal.
College students and night owls alike gather here when hunger strikes after midnight, creating a fun social scene.
3. Dewey’s Pizza
Creative combinations elevate pizza to an art form at this beloved regional chain.
Multiple locations serve customers throughout Cincinnati and Dayton, with several addresses across both cities.
The Edgar Allan Poe pizza stands out with its blend of olive oil, mozzarella, fontina, mushrooms, roasted garlic, kalamata olives, and fresh herbs.
An artisan approach means every ingredient gets carefully selected for quality and flavor.
The crust strikes a perfect balance between crispy edges and a soft center that holds toppings beautifully.
You can taste the difference that fresh herbs and premium cheeses make in every single bite.
4. Old Scratch Pizza & Beer
Wood-fired ovens create the perfect blistered crust that pizza purists dream about.
Located at 1 Blind Ln, Dayton, OH 45402, this spot specializes in authentic Neapolitan-style pies.
The Angry Beekeeper pizza combines sopressata, hot honey, and mozzarella for a sweet-spicy flavor explosion.
High temperatures in the wood oven cook pizzas quickly, creating those signature charred spots on the crust.
Beer pairings complement each pizza perfectly, with knowledgeable staff ready to make recommendations.
The casual atmosphere invites you to relax and savor every bite while enjoying good company and cold drinks.
5. Citizen Pie
Authentic Neapolitan techniques bring Italian pizza tradition straight to Cleveland’s dining scene.
You can visit them at 15710 Waterloo Rd, Cleveland, OH 44110, where wood-fired magic happens daily.
The blistered crust showcases those characteristic leopard spots that signal perfect Neapolitan pizza.
Fresh toppings get sourced carefully to maintain authenticity and deliver genuine Italian flavors.
Each pizza cooks in just minutes at extremely high temperatures, locking in moisture and creating incredible texture.
The simple menu focuses on doing a few things exceptionally well rather than offering endless options that compromise quality.
6. Marion’s Piazza
Since 1965, this Dayton institution has been perfecting its distinctive square-cut thin-crust pizza.
The original location sits at 1320 W Dorothy Ln, Dayton, OH 45409, though several locations now serve the area.
Thin crust gets cut into squares rather than triangles, creating a unique eating experience.
National recognition has come their way thanks to consistent quality and dedication to their original recipe.
The crispy crust provides a satisfying crunch with every bite without being too heavy or filling.
Generations of families have made this spot part of their regular dining rotation, creating lasting memories over pizza.
7. Rubino’s Pizza
Old-school charm meets cracker-thin crust at this establishment that opened way back in 1954.
Find this classic spot at 2643 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209, where time seems to have stood pleasantly still.
The crunchy, cracker-thin crust delivers a completely different texture than thick or chewy pizza styles.
Retro decor and classic atmosphere transport you back to simpler times when pizza shops were neighborhood gathering places.
You’ll appreciate how the thin crust lets toppings shine without overwhelming your palate with bread.
This style has remained popular for decades because sometimes less really is more when it comes to crust thickness.
8. Adriatico’s Pizza
College students and locals alike have made this spot a Columbus tradition for generations.
Located at 2161 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, it sits right in the heart of the Ohio State University area.
Their thick-crust pizza comes loaded with toppings and cut into satisfying square pieces.
The generous portions make it perfect for sharing with friends after a game or during late-night study sessions.
A casual, no-frills atmosphere lets the pizza take center stage without pretension or fuss.
You’ll understand why students keep coming back even years after graduation to relive their favorite pizza memories.
9. Harvest Pizzeria
Farm-fresh ingredients transform pizza into a celebration of local agriculture and seasonal flavors.
You’ll discover this gem at 123 22nd St NW, Canton, OH 44709, where the menu changes with the seasons.
Seasonal vegetables and locally sourced ingredients ensure maximum freshness and flavor in every pie.
The commitment to sustainability shows in both the ingredient sourcing and the restaurant’s eco-friendly practices.
Each pizza tells a story about the farms and producers who supplied the toppings.
You can feel good about supporting local agriculture while enjoying some of the most flavorful pizza you’ve ever tasted.
10. Iacono’s Pizza
Traditional Italian recipes have been preserved and perfected at this family-run establishment for years.
This beloved spot operates at 7887 Mentor Ave, Mentor, OH 44060, serving the community with pride.
Homemade sauce provides the foundation for pizzas that taste like they came straight from an Italian grandmother’s kitchen.
Fresh mozzarella gets used generously, creating that perfect cheese pull everyone loves to see.
The family atmosphere makes you feel welcome whether you’re dining in or taking pizza home.
You’ll taste the difference that comes from recipes developed over generations rather than corporate test kitchens.
11. Tommy’s Pizza
Generous toppings and family-friendly atmosphere have made this spot a Columbus staple since 1975.
The main location sits at 1350 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212, though other locations serve the area.
Thick layers of cheese blanket every pizza, creating that satisfying stretch when you pull away a slice.
The menu offers something for everyone, from simple cheese pizzas to fully loaded specialty combinations.
Reasonable prices make it easy to feed the whole family without breaking your budget.
You’ll find the casual environment perfect for bringing kids or gathering with a group of friends.
12. Yellow Brick Pizza
Creative flavor combinations push pizza boundaries while respecting traditional techniques at this modern spot.
Located at 2545 Lorain Ave, Cleveland, OH 44113, it brings innovation to the Ohio Market neighborhood.
Stone-fired crusts provide the perfect base for adventurous topping combinations you won’t find elsewhere.
Each specialty pizza gets designed with careful thought about how flavors work together.
The modern, hip atmosphere attracts food lovers looking for something beyond standard pepperoni and cheese.
You’ll appreciate how they balance creativity with quality, never sacrificing taste for the sake of being different.
13. Giammarco’s
New York-style pizza has found a home in Akron thanks to this authentic spot.
You can grab a slice at 1837 Buchholzer Blvd, Akron, OH 44310, where they’ve perfected the foldable slice.
Large, thin slices beg to be folded in half for the proper New York eating experience.
The crust achieves that ideal balance of crispy bottom and soft interior that defines great New York pizza.
By-the-slice options make it easy to try different varieties or grab a quick lunch.
You don’t need to travel to New York City when this spot delivers authentic flavors right here in Ohio.
14. Flying Pizza
Small-town charm meets exceptional pizza at this Oberlin favorite that locals guard like a secret.
This cozy spot operates at 6 S Main St, Oberlin, OH 44074, serving both college students and town residents.
Fresh ingredients get combined in creative ways that honor both tradition and innovation.
The intimate setting makes every visit feel personal rather than like just another transaction.
Specialty pizzas showcase seasonal ingredients and thoughtful flavor pairings that change regularly.
You’ll discover why small-town pizzerias often outshine big-city chains when passion drives every pie that comes out of the oven.
