16 Florida Italian Sub Shops That Have Mastered The Classic Sandwich

Florida’s Italian sub scene is a delicious journey through layers of cured meats, melted cheese, and perfectly baked bread.

From family-run delis to bustling markets, shops across the Sunshine State have turned this simple sandwich into an art form.

I’ve rounded up the best spots where you can sink your teeth into authentic Italian subs that’ll make you feel like you’re dining in a New York deli.

1. Franky’s Deli Warehouse

Your taste buds are about to experience something special at this Hialeah gem that locals can’t stop talking about.

You’ll find it at 2596 W 84th St, Hialeah, FL 33016, serving up what many call the best Italian sub in South Florida.

The Famous Italian comes loaded with ham, capicola, salami, and provolone, all grilled until the cheese melts perfectly into every bite.

Old-school vibes fill the space, reminding you of authentic East Coast delis where quality matters more than fancy decorations.

Portions here are generous enough to share, though you probably won’t want to.

The 4.9-star rating from 920 reviews speaks volumes about consistency.

2. Mazzaro’s Italian Market

Walking into this St. Petersburg institution feels like stepping into an Italian grandmother’s kitchen, surrounded by imported goods and incredible aromas.

Located at 2909 22nd Ave N, St. Petersburg, FL 33713, this market has been feeding hungry customers for decades.

Their signature sub combines ham, Genoa salami, capicola, and mortadella with fresh vegetables and house dressing.

Beyond subs, the muffalettas here have earned legendary status among sandwich lovers throughout Tampa Bay.

With 8,851 reviews averaging 4.8 stars, you’re joining thousands of satisfied customers.

Browse the shelves for imported pasta and olive oil while waiting for your order.

3. Giordano’s

Four generations of family tradition go into every sandwich at this Kissimmee establishment that’s been around since 1974.

You can visit them at 7866 WIrlo Bronson Memorial Hgwy, Kissimmee, FL 34747, where they’ve perfected recipes passed down through the years.

Fresh bread arrives daily, providing the perfect foundation for imported Italian meats and cheeses that taste like they came straight from Italy.

The commitment to quality ingredients sets this spot apart from chain restaurants nearby.

Families visiting Orlando theme parks often make this a regular stop for authentic Italian flavors.

Each bite reminds you why traditional methods still beat modern shortcuts.

4. Joseph’s Classic Market

Upscale doesn’t have to mean pretentious, and this Boca Raton market proves it with every Classic Italian sub they make.

Find them at 6000 Glades Rd UNIT1380, Boca Raton, FL 33431, tucked inside a gourmet grocery setting.

Imported ham, capocollo, Genoa salami, pepperoni, and sharp provolone get dressed with olive oil and balsamic vinegar for sophisticated flavor.

The attention to detail extends beyond the sandwich to the entire shopping experience.

You can grab specialty Italian ingredients while you’re there, making it a one-stop destination.

With 1,055 reviews and a 4.5-star rating, quality speaks louder than fancy marketing.

5. The Original Rinaldi’s Deli and Cafe

Hot subs take center stage at this Stuart deli where melted cheese and warm meats create comfort food perfection.

You’ll discover them at 3610 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34997, serving up sandwiches that warm your soul.

The Steak Pizzaiola combines tender steak with mozzarella and marinara sauce for an Italian twist on classic flavors.

Their Philly Cheese Steak features shaved ribeye, melted mozzarella, and grilled onions that fill the air with irresistible aromas.

Each sandwich gets made to order, ensuring everything arrives at your table piping hot.

The 4.5-star rating from 412 reviews reflects consistent quality that keeps customers returning.

6. Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop

Sometimes you crave a straightforward Italian sub without any fuss, and this North Miami Beach location delivers exactly that.

Visit them at 1678 NE Miami Gardens Dr, North Miami Beach, FL 33179, for sandwiches made with pride.

Italian cold cuts layer perfectly with lettuce, tomato, pickles, peppers, and oil on a fresh roll.

The simplicity lets quality ingredients shine through without unnecessary complications.

Consistent preparation means you know what to expect every single visit.

With 256 reviews averaging 4.5 stars, this spot has built a loyal following.

Quick service makes it perfect for lunch breaks or pre-beach snacks.

7. Mickey’s Subs

High-quality ingredients transform simple sandwiches into memorable meals at this Tampa favorite that’s earned an impressive reputation.

Located at 5230 Bridge St, Tampa, FL 33611, this restaurant focuses on freshness above all else.

Their Italian sub showcases premium meats and cheeses that taste noticeably better than average.

The roast beef sub with horseradish offers a delicious alternative when you want something different.

Attention to detail shows in every aspect, from bread selection to vegetable freshness.

An outstanding 4.9-star rating from 614 reviews puts this spot among Tampa’s elite sandwich destinations.

You’ll understand the hype after your first bite.

8. Bella’s Italian Cafe

Cafe charm combines with deli excellence at this spot where Italian subs are treated like culinary art.

Fresh mozzarella and imported provolone provide cheese options that elevate standard sandwiches.

Their Italian sub balances flavors carefully, ensuring no single ingredient overpowers the others.

Homemade focaccia bread offers an alternative to traditional sub rolls for adventurous eaters.

The cozy atmosphere invites you to sit and savor rather than rush through your meal.

You’ll notice small touches that show genuine care, from garnishes to presentation.

This is where locals bring out-of-town guests to showcase Florida’s Italian food scene.

9. Sal’s Italian Deli

No-nonsense Italian subs served with New York attitude make this deli a refreshing change from overly polite establishments.

The staff knows their sandwiches are good and they’re not shy about it.

Generous meat portions mean you’re getting your money’s worth with every order.

Their Italian sub comes dressed the traditional way unless you specify otherwise.

Sharp provolone adds a tangy bite that cuts through the richness of cured meats.

You might wait during lunch rush, but the line moves quickly once you see how efficiently they work.

This is where you go when you want authentic deli experience, not watered-down versions.

10. Carmine’s Subs & More

Creative variations on classic Italian subs keep regulars coming back to see what’s new on the menu.

Traditional options satisfy purists while specialty combinations tempt adventurous eaters.

Their signature Italian includes a secret seasoning blend that customers try unsuccessfully to identify.

Fresh vegetables get delivered multiple times weekly, ensuring crisp lettuce and firm tomatoes.

The owner often works the counter, greeting customers by name and remembering their usual orders.

You can customize almost anything, making it perfect for picky eaters or those with dietary restrictions.

The friendly service feels more like visiting a neighbor than a commercial transaction.

11. Tony’s Italian Deli & Subs

Old-world recipes transported to Florida create authentic flavors that remind Italian-Americans of their heritage.

Mortadella features prominently here, unlike many places that skip this traditional Italian cold cut.

Their Italian sub follows recipes Tony learned from his grandfather in Sicily decades ago.

Imported ingredients cost more but the difference in taste justifies every penny.

You’ll find Italian sodas and imported chips to complete your authentic deli experience.

The walls display photos of Italy, creating atmosphere that enhances your meal.

Regular customers often linger, turning quick lunches into social gatherings over incredible sandwiches.

12. Trattoria Lombardi’s Restaurant

Family recipes spanning three generations ensure consistency and authentic flavor at this beloved establishment.

Their Italian sub recipe hasn’t changed in thirty years because perfection doesn’t need improvement.

Capicola gets sliced paper-thin, allowing the spicy, cured pork to melt on your tongue.

House-made giardiniera adds a pickled vegetable kick that brightens rich meats.

The restaurant atmosphere means you can enjoy your sub at a real table with proper service.

Kids menu options make this family-friendly while adults appreciate the authentic Italian preparations.

You’re not just buying a sandwich here, you’re joining a tradition.

13. Dante’s Tavern

Artisan bread baked on-site elevates these Italian subs beyond what you’ll find at typical sandwich shops.

The bread-to-filling ratio achieves perfect balance, neither overwhelming nor insufficient.

Their Italian sub features sopressata alongside more common meats, adding complex, wine-infused flavors.

Fresh basil leaves tucked between layers provide aromatic bursts with certain bites.

You can watch sandwich artists assemble your order with practiced precision through the open kitchen.

The menu changes seasonally, incorporating fresh ingredients when they’re at peak flavor.

This is where food enthusiasts go when they want sandwiches that push boundaries while respecting tradition.

14. Vincenzo’s Sub Station

Speed and quality rarely coexist, but this sub station manages both during even the busiest lunch rushes.

Pre-sliced meats might sound like a shortcut, but they slice fresh every morning before opening.

Their Italian sub assembly line moves like choreographed dance, yet nothing feels rushed or sloppy.

Oil and vinegar get applied with precision, ensuring even distribution without soggy bread.

The grab-and-go setup works perfectly for people with limited lunch breaks.

Despite quick service, flavor never suffers, proving efficiency doesn’t require sacrificing quality.

You’ll be amazed how fast you can get an incredible Italian sub here.

15. Rossi’s Market & Deli

This combination market and deli lets you shop for Italian groceries while your sub gets prepared fresh.

Imported olive oils and vinegars line the shelves, including the same ones they use on sandwiches.

Their Italian sub comes on seeded rolls that add nutty flavor and interesting texture.

The deli case displays beautiful cuts of prosciutto, capicola, and other Italian specialties.

You can request any meat from the case on your sub, creating custom combinations.

Fresh pasta made in-house sits nearby, tempting you to plan tonight’s dinner.

Shopping and eating combine seamlessly at this neighborhood gem that serves the community well.

16. Angelo’s Sub & Pizza

Pizza expertise translates surprisingly well to submarine sandwiches at this dual-concept restaurant.

The same quality ingredients that top their pizzas fill their Italian subs with equal care.

Their Italian sub benefits from pizza-making knowledge, particularly in balancing flavors and textures.

You can order half a sub with a slice of pizza for the ultimate Italian-American lunch.

The aroma of baking pizza dough fills the air, enhancing your appetite before your sub arrives.

Lunch specials combine subs with sides at prices that won’t break your budget.

Whether you choose pizza or subs, you’re getting food made by people who understand Italian cuisine deeply.