14 Beloved Georgia Cafés Where Every Slice Of Pie Comes With A Story
Georgia is home to some of the most delightful cafés where pie isn’t just dessert—it’s a tradition passed down through generations.
Every slice tells a story, whether it’s a family recipe from the 1950s or a modern twist on a Southern classic.
I’ve gathered a list of cafés across the state where you can enjoy incredible pie and hear the tales behind each delicious bite.
1. Southern Sweets Bakery
You’ll find comfort in every bite when you visit this family-owned bakery that’s been serving up homemade goodness for years.
Southern Sweets Bakery is located at 2050 Scenic Hwy N, Snellville, GA 30078, and it’s a place where traditional Southern baking meets heartfelt hospitality.
The pecan pie here is legendary, made from a recipe that’s been in the owner’s family for three generations.
Each morning, the bakers arrive early to prepare fresh crusts that are flaky and golden brown.
The filling is rich with locally sourced pecans and just the right amount of sweetness.
You can taste the love in every slice, and the staff will happily share stories about how the recipes came to be.
Many locals consider this their go-to spot for special occasions and everyday treats alike.
The cozy atmosphere makes you feel like you’re visiting a friend’s kitchen.
Whether you’re craving sweet potato pie or classic apple, you’ll leave with a full heart and a satisfied sweet tooth.
2. Pie Bar Atlanta
Walking into this modern café feels like stepping into a pie lover’s dream come true.
Pie Bar Atlanta is located at 1827 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30309, where creativity and classic flavors collide in the most delicious ways.
The menu features both traditional options and inventive combinations that will surprise your taste buds.
One of their signature offerings is the salted caramel chocolate pie, which has become a customer favorite since the café opened.
The owners wanted to create a space where people could gather over a slice and share their own stories.
The open kitchen lets you watch the bakers craft each pie with precision and care.
They also offer savory pies for lunch, making it a perfect spot for any time of day.
The bright, cheerful décor adds to the welcoming vibe.
I recommend trying their seasonal specials, which change based on what’s fresh and available locally.
3. Little Tart Bakeshop
Stepping through the door here feels like entering a European-style bakery tucked right in the heart of Atlanta.
Little Tart Bakeshop is located at 1140 Howell Mill Rd NW, Atlanta, GA 30318, where French-inspired techniques meet Southern ingredients.
The fruit pies are exceptional, especially when berries are in season.
The bakers use organic flour and butter to create crusts that are incredibly tender and flavorful.
You’ll find tarts, galettes, and traditional pies all displayed beautifully in vintage cake stands.
The blueberry pie features fruit from Georgia farms, giving it a fresh, bright taste.
The small, intimate space makes it feel like a hidden gem worth discovering.
They also serve excellent coffee and pastries if you want to linger a bit longer.
Each item is made with attention to detail and a commitment to quality ingredients, which you can taste in every bite.
4. The Pie Hole
Quirkiness and quality come together at this fun café that doesn’t take itself too seriously.
The Pie Hole is located at 3825 Clairmont Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30341, and it’s known for bold flavors and playful presentations.
Their Earl Grey pie is a unique twist that tea lovers absolutely adore.
The menu features both sweet and savory options, so you can enjoy pie for lunch or dessert.
The owners wanted to create a place where people could try unexpected flavor combinations.
The Mexican chocolate pie, with a hint of cinnamon and spice, is another popular choice.
Bright colors and fun artwork decorate the walls, giving the space a lively, welcoming energy.
They also offer vegan and gluten-free options, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice.
The staff is knowledgeable and happy to recommend pies based on your preferences, making each visit a personalized experience.
5. Savannah Coffee Roasters
Coffee and pie pair beautifully at this beloved Savannah spot that’s been a local favorite for years.
Savannah Coffee Roasters is located at 215 W Liberty St, Savannah, GA 31401, where the aroma of fresh-roasted beans mingles with the scent of baking pies.
Their key lime pie is tangy and refreshing, perfect alongside a strong cup of coffee.
The café roasts its own beans on-site, ensuring the freshest possible brew with every cup.
The pies are sourced from local bakers who use traditional Southern recipes.
You’ll often find students, artists, and tourists all sharing tables and conversation.
The relaxed atmosphere makes it easy to spend an afternoon here with a book or friends.
They also offer live music on weekends, adding to the vibrant community feel.
The peach pie, when available, showcases Georgia’s famous fruit at its finest.
6. Back in the Day Bakery
Nostalgia fills the air at this charming bakery that celebrates old-fashioned baking traditions.
Back in the Day Bakery is located at 2403 Bull St, Savannah, GA 31401, where vintage décor and classic recipes transport you to simpler times.
The lemon chess pie is a standout, with a bright citrus flavor that’s perfectly balanced.
The owners, a husband-and-wife team, opened the bakery to share their love of traditional Southern desserts.
Everything is made by hand using recipes passed down through their families.
The bakery has been featured in numerous magazines and cookbooks for its authentic approach.
You’ll notice the attention to detail in the flaky crusts and generous fillings.
The chocolate cream pie is another favorite, topped with real whipped cream.
The cozy seating area invites you to slow down and savor each bite while chatting with fellow pie enthusiasts.
7. Cafe Lily
Sophistication meets comfort at this elegant café known for its European-inspired menu and beautiful setting.
Cafe Lily is located at 308 W Ponce de Leon Ave, Decatur, GA 30030, where the dessert menu features seasonal fruit pies made with ingredients from local farms.
The strawberry rhubarb pie in spring is absolutely divine.
The café has a romantic ambiance with soft lighting and fresh flowers on every table.
The chef takes pride in creating pies that look as stunning as they taste.
You’ll find the presentation is always elegant, with each slice carefully plated.
They also offer a full lunch and dinner menu, making it a great spot for a complete meal.
The apple tart with caramel sauce is a year-round favorite that never disappoints.
Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends when locals flock here for special occasions.
8. The Chocolate Shoppe
Indulgence reaches new heights at this dessert haven where chocolate takes center stage in every creation.
The Chocolate Shoppe is located at 247 Buckhead Ave NE, Atlanta, GA 30305, and their chocolate silk pie is pure decadence.
The rich, velvety filling sits atop a chocolate cookie crust that adds the perfect crunch.
The shop has been satisfying sweet cravings since 1998, building a loyal following of chocolate lovers.
They use premium Belgian chocolate in their recipes, which makes a noticeable difference in taste.
The owners are passionate about their craft and love sharing the stories behind their signature items.
You’ll also find truffles, cakes, and other chocolate treats if you want to explore beyond pie.
The peanut butter chocolate pie is another crowd-pleaser that sells out quickly.
The friendly staff will wrap your purchase beautifully if you’re buying a gift for someone special.
9. Henri’s Bakery
Tradition runs deep at this family bakery that’s been serving the community for over 60 years.
Henri’s Bakery is located at 61 Irby Ave NW, Atlanta, GA 30305, where recipes haven’t changed because they were perfect from the start.
The coconut custard pie is a customer favorite that’s been on the menu since day one.
The bakery opens early each morning, filling the neighborhood with the irresistible smell of fresh baking.
Third-generation bakers now run the operation, maintaining the same high standards their grandparents established.
You’ll see regulars who have been coming here for decades, often bringing their own children and grandchildren.
The simple, no-frills approach lets the quality of the pies speak for itself.
The lemon meringue pie features mile-high meringue that’s perfectly browned.
Cash is preferred here, adding to the old-school charm that makes this place so special.
10. Alon’s Bakery
Excellence in baking is evident the moment you see the beautiful pastries and pies displayed here.
Alon’s Bakery is located at 1394 N Highland Ave NE, Atlanta, GA 30306, where French techniques and Southern flavors create something truly special.
The pecan tart with bourbon is a sophisticated take on a Georgia classic.
The founder trained in France before bringing his expertise back to Atlanta, and it shows in every detail.
The bakery uses European butter and organic ingredients whenever possible.
You’ll notice the crusts are exceptionally flaky and the fillings are never too sweet.
They also have a café area where you can enjoy your pie with a cappuccino or glass of wine.
The seasonal fruit galettes are works of art that taste even better than they look.
The knowledgeable staff can guide you through the options and help you discover new favorites.
11. Sweet Hut Bakery
Asian-inspired desserts get a Southern twist at this innovative bakery that’s always experimenting with new flavors.
Sweet Hut Bakery is located at 3770 Satellite Blvd, Duluth, GA 30096, where you’ll find unique creations like matcha cream pie and red bean tarts.
The fusion of cultures creates exciting taste experiences you won’t find anywhere else.
The bakery stays open late, making it a popular spot for night owls and students.
The bright, modern space features floor-to-ceiling windows and contemporary seating.
They offer both individual slices and whole pies, along with bubble tea and other beverages.
The mango pie is refreshing and tropical, perfect for Georgia’s warm weather.
You’ll appreciate the lighter, less sugary approach to dessert that lets the natural flavors shine.
The staff is multilingual and always happy to explain the different ingredients and flavor profiles.
12. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Freshness is the secret ingredient at this charming pie shop that bakes everything from scratch daily.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is located at 4279 Roswell Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30342, and it’s a destination for anyone who appreciates authentic Southern baking.
Their buttermilk pie is a must-try, with a custard-like filling that melts in your mouth.
The shop specializes in both full-size pies and individual servings, perfect for when you want just a little something sweet.
Each recipe has been tested and perfected to ensure consistent quality.
The friendly staff will greet you with a smile and help you choose from the day’s offerings.
They also take custom orders for birthdays, holidays, and other celebrations.
The coconut cream pie is another standout, topped with fluffy meringue that’s lightly toasted.
You’ll notice the difference that fresh ingredients and careful preparation make with every forkful.
13. Cake Hag
Whimsy and skill combine at this delightful bakery run by a pastry chef with serious talent.
Cake Hag is located at 353 Decatur St SE, Atlanta, GA 30312, where the name might be playful but the pies are seriously good.
The salted honey pie is an unexpected flavor combination that works beautifully.
The owner started the business from her home kitchen before opening this brick-and-mortar location.
She’s known for using local honey, seasonal fruits, and creative flavor pairings.
The small batch approach ensures everything is incredibly fresh.
You’ll find the menu changes regularly based on what ingredients are at their peak.
The bourbon chocolate pecan pie is a decadent option for special occasions.
The cozy shop has a welcoming vibe where customers often strike up conversations while waiting for their orders.
14. Bernhard’s German Bakery
European baking traditions thrive at this authentic German bakery that’s been a Stone Mountain fixture for years.
Bernhard’s German Bakery is located at 935 Main St, Stone Mountain, GA 30083, where you’ll find both German specialties and American-style pies.
The apple strudel is technically not a pie, but the apple crumb pie is a delicious alternative.
The baker learned his craft in Germany before immigrating to Georgia and opening this shop.
Traditional techniques and recipes ensure authentic flavors in every item.
You’ll taste the difference that comes from years of experience and dedication to the craft.
The bakery also offers German bread, pastries, and cookies if you want to explore beyond pie.
The cherry pie features tart cherries that aren’t overly sweetened, letting the fruit flavor shine through.
Arriving early is wise, as popular items sell out quickly on weekends.
