We Ranked The 9 Best Amish Markets In Kentucky And Here Are The Results

An Amish-run store in rural Kentucky sells fresh cinnamon rolls in one building and crossbows in another, right on the same property. I had to read that twice, and then I wanted directions.

Another stop sells strawberry cheesecake fudge in the same building as discounted salvage groceries. A third added house-made pizza to its scratch bakery and country breakfast menu, which feels like a delicious plot twist.

Most of these markets close on Sundays, so planning ahead really matters. The rest of the week, you can load up on bulk spices, deli sandwiches stacked on homemade bread, local honey, and fried pies that rarely survive the long ride home.

I ranked nine favorites across Kentucky, weighing bakeries, delis, produce, and pure surprise factor. Some are quick snack stops and others could swallow a whole Saturday, so which one gets your first visit?

1. Habegger’s Amish Market

Cinnamon buns are the headliner at this Scottsville stop, and honestly, they’ve earned top billing. The market sits in Allen County’s Amish Country, founded by a family with Amish roots in Pennsylvania.

Hungry right now? Head to the deli counter, where sandwiches are made to order with fresh-sliced meats and cheeses on bread baked in-house.

That homemade bread matters more than you might think at first bite. A great sandwich starts at the bottom, and here the bottom gets some serious love.

Once lunch is handled, the shelves start calling your name. You’ll spot jams, jellies, pumpkin butter, specialty spreads, and even pickled quail eggs for the adventurous eater in your crew.

Home bakers can stock up on bulk flour, sugar, and spices without a trip to a big-box store. Amish-made meats, cheeses, and homemade butter round out the cooler, along with pies, cookies, and fudge.

Seasonal flowers and locally sourced vegetables show up too, depending on the time of year. It’s the kind of place where a quick stop turns into a full cart.

Traveling with kids? A small playground outside gives them room to burn off energy while you eat on the outdoor patio.

Just skip Sunday, because the doors stay closed. Plan your Kentucky road trip around that, and you’re set.

Address: 415 Perrytown Rd, Scottsville, Kentucky

2. Detweiler’s Country Store

Few grocery runs end with a fishing rod, a bag of old-fashioned candy, and a solid wood dresser. In Cub Run, that combo is completely normal.

Detweiler’s Country Store is an Amish-owned and operated complex with three operations on one property. You get a grocery, a general merchandise store, and an outdoor outfitter, so bring a list or bring patience.

Start in the grocery, where the deli builds sandwiches to order with quality meats and cheeses. The bakery keeps things sweet with pies, breads, cookies, and cinnamon rolls.

Bulk food fans, consider this your personal playground in Hart County. Spices, baking goods, dried goods, jams, jellies, honey, and old-fashioned candies fill the shelves.

Next door, the general merchandise building shows off handcrafted solid wood furniture. Home goods, gifts, and fabrics fill in the rest, which makes it handy for quilters and gift shoppers alike.

Then comes the curveball. The Crazy Bear Trading Post stocks hunting, fishing, and camping gear, including fishing rods, crossbows, and ammunition.

During the growing season, a greenhouse adds plants, succulents, and hanging baskets to the mix. Your porch might thank you before your pantry does.

Hours run Monday through Saturday, with Sundays off. Give yourself extra time here, because three stores rarely fit into a ten-minute visit, no matter how fast you shop.

Address: 12825 Priceville Rd, Cub Run, Kentucky

3. R&S Salvage Grocery

Salvage grocery sounds like bargain bins, and yes, R&S still has discounted items. The twist is that the bakery case might steal the show from the deals.

This Amish-owned and operated spot in Horse Cave started out as a simple salvage grocery. Over time, it grew into a local favorite for baked goods, deli sandwiches, and hand-dipped ice cream.

Let’s talk fudge, because the flavors get a little wild. Peanut butter chocolate and strawberry cheesecake are on the list, and choosing just one feels unfair.

Handmade Amish donuts and glazed fried pies sit alongside breads, cakes, cookies, and cinnamon rolls. Sourdough bread is here too, and it pulls double duty at the deli.

Yep, some deli sandwiches come on that homemade sourdough. The meats are sliced to order, so your lunch is about as fresh as it gets.

Wander past the counters and the store keeps surprising you. There’s a wellness supplement section, a pet corner, and shelves of candy and odd little finds.

Practical shoppers can grab bulk pantry staples, frozen foods, and jarred goods like jams, jellies, and pickled items. Bring a cooler if you’re driving far, since ice cream and frozen treats don’t love long trips.

R&S is open Monday through Saturday and closed on Sundays. Go hungry, but also go with a budget, because those bargains add up fast.

Address: 235 Irvin Cemetery Rd, Horse Cave, Kentucky

4. Farmwald’s Dutch Bakery & Deli

Breakfast, lunch, dessert, and souvenir shopping can happen in one Horse Cave parking spot. Farmwald’s packs a restaurant, scratch bakery, and country store under one roof.

Joe and Laura Farmwald opened this Amish-owned business in 2019. It also provides jobs for people in their community, which makes your donut feel extra wholesome.

Morning people should eye the Amish Farmer’s Breakfast. It brings biscuits and gravy, pancakes, sausage, bacon, hashbrowns, and scrambled eggs, so maybe skip the snack beforehand.

Later in the day, the ribeye sandwich, pulled pork sliders, and burgers take over. House-made pizza joined the lineup in 2024, proving an Amish kitchen can still surprise you.

Now for the bakery, which might be the real reason you came. Fresh donuts, fruit and cream pies, fried hand pies, cookies, cakes, cinnamon rolls, and whoopie pies fill the cases.

Then there’s the pretzel bar with soft pretzels. Honestly, that phrase deserves its own billboard on the interstate.

Browse the country store for Amish-made goods, handcrafted gifts, jams, jellies, and honey. You might even spot handcrafted rocking chairs, though fitting one in the trunk is your puzzle to solve.

Getting here is easy off I-65 at Exit 58, near Kentucky Down Under Adventure Zoo. Hours vary Monday through Saturday, and the doors stay closed on Sundays.

Address: 3720 L&N Turnpike Rd, Horse Cave, Kentucky

5. Meadow Creek Amish Market

Sweet cherries in Kentucky? At Meadow Creek Amish Market, they show up on the seasonal produce list, and that alone deserves a road trip to Campbellsville.

This Taylor County market puts its focus on locally grown fruits and vegetables. If your idea of shopping is filling a bag with stuff that still smells like the garden, you’ll fit right in.

The seasonal lineup is impressively long. Expect options like head lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, zucchini, garlic, squash, bell peppers, jalapeños, onions, Irish potatoes, and green beans.

Summer fruit gets its own fan club here. Cantaloupe, watermelon, peaches, and nectarines appear when the weather cooperates.

Produce isn’t the only draw, though. Farm-raised pork, beef, and lamb are available, along with farm-fresh eggs for your weekend breakfast.

Sweet spreads round things out nicely. Look for honey, apple butter, pumpkin butter, and freezer jam, which is basically summer saved in a jar.

A money-smart tip for qualifying shoppers is worth remembering. The market accepts Farmers Market Produce vouchers, so check whether you’re eligible before you go.

Timing matters, since hours are shorter than a big supermarket’s. It’s open Tuesday through Friday from 11 AM to 5 PM and Saturday from 10 AM to 5 PM, closed Sundays and Mondays.

Address: 2184 E Meadow Creek Rd, Campbellsville, Kentucky

6. Vegetable Man’s Country Market

Small town, big tomatoes. Junction City’s Vegetable Man’s Country Market keeps things simple, and simple can be delicious.

This family-owned and operated market specializes in quality local Amish products. The main event is fresh, locally grown produce, often picked daily during the season.

Picked daily is a big deal if you’ve ever bought a sad, pale supermarket tomato. Here, garden-fresh tomatoes are part of the regular summer lineup.

Sweet corn is another star when it’s in season. Grab a few extra ears, because somebody at home will ask why you didn’t.

Watermelons and homegrown cantaloupe make the drive home a little heavier. Ripe peaches join the party too, which is great news for anyone planning a cobbler.

It isn’t strictly fruits and veggies, either. Ground beef is on the list, so you could build a whole cookout menu in one stop.

Heads up, since a few other Amish Country Markets exist outside Kentucky with bigger menus. This Henry Street spot is known mainly for produce and local Amish goods, so don’t expect an ice cream counter.

Hours aren’t widely published, so check before making a special trip. Pack a cooler and a few sturdy bags too, since melons and corn take up space fast.

Address: 136 Henry St, Junction City, Kentucky

7. The Country Barn Garden & Farm Market

Cherokee Purple tomatoes and espresso drinks in the same stop? The Country Barn Garden and Farm Market in Elkton makes that pairing work.

The family-owned business sits in the Fairview community, central to a Mennonite and Amish population. It’s a garden center, farm market, and café rolled into one.

Plant lovers can browse annuals, perennials, shrubs, vegetables, herbs, hanging baskets, houseplants, and trees. Renovations unveiled in spring 2024 expanded the greenhouse and selling area, so there’s more room to wander.

The farm market sells fresh produce year-round, with a focus on local Kentucky-grown and heirloom vegetables. Besides Cherokee Purple tomatoes, look for hot peppers, strawberries, peaches, and apples.

Pantry goodies include local honey, jams, jellies, dip mixes, teas, and homemade baked goods. Dip mixes are a sneaky great party contribution, by the way.

Shopping works up an appetite, and the Country Boy Café has answers. Pizza, subs, salads, sandwiches, bakery items, coffee, espresso drinks, and ice cream are on the menu, with online ordering available.

Seasons change the scenery here in a fun way. Fall brings mums, pumpkins, and gourds, while Christmas rolls in with wreaths, decor, and poinsettias.

The Country Barn runs Monday through Saturday on seasonal hours and closes Sundays. Check the calendar before you go so your mum shopping lines up with mum season.

Address: 112 Britmart Rd, Elkton, Kentucky

8. Pleasant Valley Bulk Foods

Carports and cheeseballs aren’t usually sold by the same people. At Pleasant Valley Bulk Foods in Princeton, they are, and somehow it makes total sense.

This family-owned store has served Western Kentucky since 2016. It mixes bulk groceries, fresh food, and outdoor living gear out in quiet countryside.

Bulk shelves cover flour, sugar, spices, mixes, beans, and nuts. Locally sourced milk, fresh eggs, and butter fill the cooler, with seasonal produce like sweet corn, strawberries, and peaches.

The deli makes sandwiches to order, including chicken salad and an open-faced roast beef. Cheeses and meats are sliced fresh daily, and the staff will put together deli, fruit, and veggie trays for gatherings.

Got a sweet tooth? The bakery turns out breads, sweet rolls, cakes, pies, cookies, and flavorful cheeseballs, made fresh daily.

The café is a whole separate reason to visit. It handles breakfast sandwiches, hot plate lunches with smoked brisket or pulled pork, homemade soups, and cheeseburgers.

Drinks get attention too, with smoothies, frappes, and handcrafted lattes on the menu. Your road trip coffee upgrade just found a home.

Before you leave, peek at books, home décor, and health and beauty products. Outdoor furniture, hunting blinds, metal carports, and playsets prove this place thinks big.

It’s open Monday through Saturday and closed on Sundays. Bring a cooler and maybe a truck, just in case.

Address: 5630 Pleasant Valley Rd, Princeton, Kentucky

9. Sunny Valley Country Store

Jam cake, pumpkin donuts, and old-fashioned ointments share one roof in Liberty. Sunny Valley Country Store is a key part of the South Fork Amish and Mennonite community in Casey County.

The store specializes in bulk foods, spices, meats, cheeses, and organic foods. Stock up on seasonings here, and your kitchen cabinet will look very impressive.

Over at the deli, sandwiches are made to order. Pair one with something from the bakery and lunch is officially solved.

Speaking of the bakery, the local baked goods get plenty of attention. Jam cake, pumpkin donuts, fried pies, and angel food cakes are among the treats.

Deal hunters, pay attention to the neighbor. The Sunny Valley Salvage Food Market on the same property offers close-dated and recently expired groceries, alongside fresh local produce.

Check dates as you shop, and you can stretch your grocery budget nicely. It’s a smart pairing with the bakery, since savings leave room for dessert.

The wellness corner feels like a throwback in the best way. Vitamins, herbs, old-fashioned ointments, and herbal teas share space with local honey and handmade items.

Sunny Valley is open Monday through Saturday and closed on Sundays. Make it the last stop on your Kentucky Amish market tour, and end the day with something sweet in hand.

Address: 2767 S Fork Creek Rd, Liberty, Kentucky