We Rounded Up 10 Amish And Mennonite Markets In Kentucky, And Here Are The Favorites
Picture a Kentucky country road with a horse and buggy clopping along ahead of you. You slow down, roll down the window, and suddenly life feels a little less rushed.
Then you spot a simple sign promising fresh bread and homemade jam. Your car seems to turn into the gravel lot all by itself.
Inside, the shelves are lined with treats that taste like they came from a grandmother’s kitchen. There are fruit pies, sticky cinnamon rolls, and cheese you’ll want to hide from the rest of the family.
You’ll find bulk spices and baking supplies at prices that make your grocery store look a little silly. Nobody is rushing you, and nobody is trying to upsell you.
It’s just good food made by people who take pride in their work. You might come for one loaf and leave with a full trunk.
Trust us, nobody waiting at home will complain.
1. Shellma’s Country Market, Gravel Switch
Gravel Switch might be the most fun town name in Kentucky to say out loud, and it comes with cinnamon rolls. Shellma’s Country Market sits right on US-68, so it’s an easy pull-off on a country drive.
You might know it by its old name, Family Food Market LLC. The sign changed, but it remains an Amish-style market stocked with groceries and homemade goodies.
The bakery side is where your willpower gets tested. Pies and cinnamon rolls headline the sweet stuff, so plan on a box for the ride home.
Hungry right now instead of later? Prepared foods are on hand, including sandwiches that make a solid lunch without any fuss.
Label readers will like the organic products on the shelves. It’s a fun mix of old-fashioned market charm and modern grocery choices.
Here’s a nice surprise for a country market: free Wi-Fi. So yes, you can post your pie photo before you even leave the lot.
Parking is free, with a lot and street spaces available. Most folks treat it as a quick visit, which makes it perfect for a road trip snack stop.
Doors open Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 5 PM. Sundays are closed, so don’t plan your weekend pie run for the wrong day.
A little tip: grab a sandwich for now and a pie for later. Future you will be very grateful around dinnertime.
Address: 5581 US-68, Gravel Switch, KY 40328
2. Farmstead Market, Pleasureville
Any town named Pleasureville is making a big promise, and this little market helps keep it. Farmstead Market brings Amish-style groceries to Castle Highway in a quiet corner of the state.
Country ham is one of the specialty goods here, and that’s about as Kentucky as a grocery list gets. Slip some into your cart and your next biscuit will thank you.
Fried pies sit on the specialty list too. They’re handheld treats, which makes them dangerously easy to eat in the car before you reach the highway.
Lunch comes from the deli counter, where sandwiches are made to order. You pick what goes on it, and nobody judges extra cheese.
Produce is another strong point at this stop. Grab some fresh picks while you’re there, because a just-picked vegetable beats a tired one every time.
Timing matters if you like elbow room. Saturday afternoon tends to be the busiest stretch, while Tuesday morning is usually calmer.
Mondays and Sundays are closed. Tuesday through Friday runs from 8 AM to 5 PM, and Saturday wraps up at 4 PM.
A restroom is available, which matters on long country drives. Most visits are quick, so you can shop and get back on the road fast.
Pro move? Buy one fried pie to eat now and one to share later.
Sharing is optional, honestly.
Address: 10712 Castle Hwy, Pleasureville, KY 40057
3. Highland Amish Produce Market, Holland
This Holland is in Kentucky, and its claim to fame is a little more delicious than tulips. Highland Amish Produce Market sits on Highland Church Road in Allen County farm country.
The name says it plainly, and the market sticks to the plan. Seasonal produce is the main event, so the selection shifts with the calendar.
That change keeps repeat trips interesting. A spring visit and a late summer visit can feel like two different markets.
Homemade baked goods round out the shelves. Hand pies are a highlight, and they’re easy to tuck into a bag for later.
Expect a friendly welcome when you come through the door. It’s the type of stop where a quick errand can turn into a pleasant chat.
Want a calm shopping trip? Weekdays tend to be quieter, while Saturday morning into the afternoon draws the biggest crowd.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 8 AM to 5 PM. Sundays are closed, as you’d expect in Amish country.
There’s a restroom on site, which is handy out in the countryside. Plan on a quick visit, though your cooler might push for a longer one.
Pair this stop with other Allen County Amish markets for a full day of shopping. The area is packed with country stores worth a look.
My advice is simple: shop the produce first, then reward yourself with a hand pie. Vegetables before dessert counts as balance, right?
Address: 5494 Highland Church Rd, Holland, KY 42153
4. Habegger’s Amish Market, Scottsville
Pickled quail eggs are on the shelves here, which tells you this market doesn’t play it safe. Habegger’s Amish Market sits on Perrytown Road in Scottsville, deep in Allen County’s Amish country.
Start at the deli, where sandwiches come stacked with freshly sliced meats and cheeses. Breads like sourdough and honey wheat often serve as the base.
The bakery case is a whole other adventure. Look for breads, pies, cinnamon buns, and fried pies, plus treats like cinnamon bread and strawberry loaf.
Bulk foods fill plenty of shelf space, and the seasoning selection is a big draw. Home cooks can restock the spice rack in one easy stop.
Then come the jars. Jams, jellies, BBQ sauces, and pumpkin butter make easy gifts, if you can bear to give them away.
Spring and summer bring seasonal flowers and vegetables. There’s also a picnic area and a play area for kids, so lunch can happen right on site.
The family behind the market has roots in the Amish Order from Pennsylvania. They carried those traditions with them to Kentucky.
Hours are Monday through Saturday, 8 AM to 4 PM, with Sundays closed. Saturdays get busy, so weekday mornings are the calmer choice.
Free on-site parking makes the stop simple. Just leave trunk space for the bread.
Address: 415 Perrytown Rd, Scottsville, KY 42164
5. Dutch Kuntry Bulk Foods & Deli, Pembroke
Soft-serve ice cream at a bulk food store feels like a prize for doing your grocery shopping. Dutch Kuntry Bulk Foods & Deli hands out that prize in Pembroke, in Kentucky’s Mennonite countryside.
The story starts in 1999, when it opened as a small bulk food store. Over time, it grew to add a deli and a fresh meat market.
That meat counter is a big deal. Chicken, beef, and pork are all available, so dinner plans can come together on the spot.
The deli makes sandwiches to order. Pair one with soft-serve and you’ve got lunch and dessert handled in one stop.
Bulk foods remain the backbone of the store. You’ll also find traditional groceries, baked goods, and homestyle jams and preserves.
Health-minded shoppers get their own corner. Herbs, vitamins, and supplements share the store with fresh produce.
There’s a wide range of Amish and Mennonite items to browse. Give yourself a few extra minutes, because the aisles reward curiosity.
Weekday hours run 8 AM to 6 PM, and Saturday closes at 5 PM. Sundays are closed, and Saturday daytime brings the biggest crowd.
Parking is free, with a lot and street spaces. Weekday evenings are usually quieter if you want a relaxed browse.
Address: 225 Vaughns Grove Fairview Rd, Pembroke, KY 42266
6. Lavern’s Country Market, Liberty
Canning season has a headquarters in Liberty, and it’s stocked with supplies and herbs. Lavern’s Country Market sits on South Fork Creek Road in a lovely Mennonite community in Casey County.
Home canners, this is your happy place. Canning supplies and plenty of herbs make it easy to plan a full weekend of putting up food.
Produce and plants are big draws here. Better yet, their prices are friendly to your budget.
Flowers join the lineup too. Pick up a few for the porch while you’re grabbing vegetables for supper.
Bulk products and groceries fill out the shelves. Jams, jellies, candies, and fudge cover the sweet side of things.
Meats and cheeses are available as well. That means you can build a picnic without making a second stop.
Friday is the late day, with doors open until 6 PM. Monday through Thursday and Saturday run 8 AM to 5 PM, and Sundays are closed.
Saturday daytime is the busiest window. Weekday mornings tend to be calmer for a slow browse.
South Fork Creek Road has more country stores nearby. That makes this market a great first stop on a Liberty shopping loop.
Bring a sturdy box for your haul. Jars and potted plants don’t love rolling around a back seat.
Address: 52 S Fork Creek Rd, Liberty, KY 42539
7. Detweiler Country Store, Cub Run
It’s been described as an Amish strip mall, and the nickname fits like a well-made drawer. Detweiler Country Store sits in Cub Run, not far from Munfordville.
Furniture is a showstopper here. Amish-made tables, chairs, and storage pieces use dovetailing and mortise-and-tenon joinery, the old-school way of building things to last.
Sweet tooth? Old-fashioned candies line up beside homemade jams and jellies.
It’s a nostalgia trip with a sugar rush.
The bulk food selection runs large. Stock up on pantry staples while you’re browsing the rest of the store.
Head to the deli for freshly prepared sandwiches and fresh meats. Hand-dipped ice cream makes a fine follow-up.
Plant lovers get a greenhouse on site. That’s right, you can buy a sandwich, a rocking-chair-worthy table, and tomato starts in one trip.
Homemade baskets and crafts add to the mix. Household products and gifts fill in the gaps.
Hours run Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 5 PM. Saturday closes at 4 PM, and Sundays are closed.
Saturday daytime brings the crowds, while weekday mornings are calmer. A free parking lot makes the stop simple, even if you’re hauling furniture.
Measure your car before you fall in love with a dining table. Ask me how I know that’s smart advice.
Actually, just trust me.
Address: 12825 Priceville Rd, Cub Run, KY 42729
8. The Country Barn Garden & Farm Market, Elkton
Few garden centers let you buy a shrub and a banana split in the same visit. The Country Barn Garden & Farm Market pulls it off on Britmart Road in Elkton.
The plant selection is massive. Bedding plants, hanging baskets, specialty flowers, herbs, perennials, flowering shrubs, and trees cover a lot of ground.
Hungry gardeners can head to the Country Boy Café. It serves coffee, espresso drinks, sandwiches, pizzas, and homemade meals.
Save room for the ice cream. It’s made in-house and hand-dipped, with 12 flavors plus toppings and banana splits.
The market side leans fresh and flavorful. Look for garden-grown produce, heirloom tomatoes, hot peppers, and pepper jellies.
Inside, the shelves hold Walnut Creek Amish goods and jarred salsas. Fresh-baked pies, homemade candies, cheeses, breads, and cookies join them.
Short on dinner ideas? Take-and-bake pizzas solve that problem fast.
Workers in Amish attire add a nice touch. Gifts and home decor round out the shopping.
Weekday hours run 8:30 AM to 6 PM, and Saturday ends at 4 PM. Sundays are closed, and Saturdays draw the biggest crowds in this corner of Kentucky.
Free parking is available in a lot and on the street. Bring a wagon-sized trunk if spring planting is on your mind.
Address: 112 Britmart Rd, Elkton, KY 42220
9. Country Pantry, Guthrie
Spice racks everywhere should be nervous, because this store sells seasonings in serious quantities. Country Pantry is an Amish-owned grocery in Guthrie, near the Tennessee line.
Bulk foods are the heart of the place. The selection is wide, so it’s a smart stop for anyone who likes a well-stocked pantry.
Seasonings and spices get special attention. You can buy large amounts at prices that beat many big stores.
That makes it a dream for home cooks. Holiday baking, chili season, and backyard rubs all get easier with a full spice cabinet.
Specialty items add some fun to the trip. Browse slowly, because the unique finds are part of the charm.
Timing helps here. Friday afternoon and Saturday daytime are the busiest, while weekday mornings stay calmer.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM. Sundays are closed, so plan your pantry run accordingly.
A restroom is available for travelers. Most visits are quick, unless the spice aisle captures you.
Before you go, peek at your kitchen and make a list. Knowing what you’re low on will keep you from buying three bags of the same thing.
Then again, extra cinnamon never hurt anybody. Your future pancakes would probably agree with that plan.
Address: 9115 Guthrie Rd #8641, Guthrie, KY 42234
10. Yoder’s Dinner Bell Market, Flemingsburg
A store named after the dinner bell had better feed you well, and this one takes the job seriously. Yoder’s Dinner Bell Market sits on Maysville Road in Flemingsburg, up in northeastern Kentucky.
Specialty deli sandwiches are the headliners. Grab one for lunch, then wander the aisles while you eat.
Fresh baked goods sit close by. They make an easy add-on when your sandwich needs a sweet sidekick.
The shelves cover a lot of ground for an Amish-style convenience store. Canned foods, dried foods, and kitchen essentials stand ready for pantry restocks.
Canners will spot plenty of supplies. Pair them with the fruits and vegetables on hand and your summer project is set.
Meats and candy are part of the lineup too. So yes, you can shop for supper and a treat in one pass.
Here’s a fun bonus: homemade ice cream shows up at times. If it’s there when you visit, consider it a sign from the dinner bell.
Weekday hours run 8:30 AM to 5 PM. Saturday runs 9 AM to 4 PM, and Sundays are closed.
Friday afternoon and Saturday tend to be busiest. A restroom is available, and quick visits are the norm.
Bring a cooler for the meats and maybe that ice cream. Ringing the dinner bell at home is entirely up to you.
Address: 1532 Maysville Rd, Flemingsburg, KY 41041
