10 Minnesota Pie Shops Where Pie Is Worth Preordering

featured image 7048fa031230 71ea709197cb - Decor Hint

One Minnesota pie shop near Lake Superior has been making homestyle pies since 1956.

That means grandparents and grandkids may have argued over the same flavors. I find that oddly moving.

Some of the best pie bakers in the state want you to plan ahead. One even requires an appointment, like pie is a dentist visit with frosting.

Think of this as your pie calendar. Pick a shop, place your order, and claim a slice before anyone else does.

Planning dessert days early sounds bossy, but it beats staring at an empty pie case with a sad fork.

1. Hot Hands Pie & Biscuit

Hot Hands Pie & Biscuit
© Hot Hands Pie & Biscuit

Biscuits get top billing on the sign, but pie quietly steals plenty of the show here. This St. Paul spot on Snelling Avenue serves both sweet and savory pies alongside a full breakfast menu.

The bakery opened in 2019 and puts its own spin on familiar comfort food.

Seasonal dessert choices have included banana cream, pecan chess, and sweet potato pies, while the pastry counter changes with the calendar. For a gathering, whole pies can be reserved ahead, especially around major holidays.

Savory fans aren’t left out either. Chicken pot pie and vegetable-filled versions share attention with buttery biscuits and warm breakfast plates.

The shop also offers bake-at-home frozen pot pies, handy when you want fresh pastry without doing all the preparation yourself.

You’ll find it at 272 Snelling Ave S, Suite 100, St. Paul. It’s a daytime cafe rather than an evening dessert destination, with service Tuesday through Saturday from 8 AM to 3 PM and Sunday from 9 AM to 2 PM. Mondays are closed.

Can’t settle on a slice? Look at the counter before choosing breakfast. A biscuit sandwich followed by a little pie turns an ordinary morning into something worth anticipating.

When you need a whole pie for a celebration, ordering ahead is the easiest way to get the flavor you have in mind.

2. Dave The Pie Guy

Dave The Pie Guy
© Dave the Pie Guy

When a baker puts “Pie Guy” right in the business name, you know where his priorities sit. Dave the Pie Guy runs a small Minneapolis shop on Grand Avenue South devoted to homemade pies.

The storefront at 3544 Grand Ave S, Minneapolis, has the feel of a neighborhood bakery rather than a large production facility.

You can buy pie by the slice or arrange an entire pie for a family dinner, party, or weekend gathering. There’s seating for anyone who wants to enjoy dessert without taking a box home.

Fruit fillings and creamy classics both appear in the assortment. Strawberry rhubarb, banana cream, pecan, French silk, and apple pies have been among the shop’s offerings.

Choosing between a tangy fruit pie and a silky chocolate filling is a perfectly reasonable reason to linger.

The bakery also serves simple savory food, making it possible to stop for a casual bite before dessert.

For special occasions, arrange a whole pie in advance and make sure the order has been confirmed. That matters especially during busy holiday weeks, when availability can change quickly.

Regular hours are typically noon to 6 PM, Tuesday through Sunday, with Mondays off. It’s an easy afternoon errand to build into your Minneapolis plans.

3. Heather’s Pies

Heather’s Pies
© Heather’s Pies

An appointment for pie might sound fancy, but it fits this place perfectly. Heather’s Pies in Minneapolis works by custom order, which makes preordering the whole point.

Each pie is baked from scratch for its recipient rather than waiting in a display case.

The bakery uses butter-rich crusts and organic fruit when available, with decorative latticework and patterned pastry tops making some creations especially elaborate.

Fruit choices include blueberry, peach, strawberry rhubarb, cherry, and mixed berries.

Key lime, Southern pecan, and seasonal combinations broaden the menu, while slab pies serve larger groups. A personalized message can even be worked into a pastry top for a celebration.

The business operates from 4108 Salem Ave S, Minneapolis, with pickup arranged around the order.

Its usual collection window is Tuesday through Friday from noon to 5 PM and Saturday from 10 AM to noon. It isn’t a traditional sit-down cafe, so arrange your visit before setting out.

Custom pies require at least 24 hours of notice, and personalized deliveries may need longer.

Gluten-free sweet and savory pies can be requested, although the bakery isn’t a dairy-free operation. Pocket pies and unbaked crusts are other options for home bakers.

For a birthday or dinner party, this is the sort of dessert you can plan the table around. The finished crust can carry the greeting, leaving the cake candles to somebody else.

4. Vikings & Goddesses Pie Company

Vikings & Goddesses Pie Company
© Vikings & Goddesses Pie Company

Pie from a walk-up window feels a little like ordering ice cream in summer, except the treat survives the drive. Vikings & Goddesses Pie Company runs that kind of window in St. Paul’s Merriam Park neighborhood.

The woman-owned bakery began in 2019, combining traditional pastry technique with ingredients from small farms and regional suppliers.

Its mission includes using surplus produce, which can become the filling of a seasonal pie instead of going unused.

The customer window is at 2036 Marshall Ave, St. Paul. It’s a pickup-focused bakery, with no indoor dining room.

Alongside whole pies, the selection includes croissants, danishes, frozen pie crusts, and other pastries. Flavors change, but apple, pecan, pumpkin, sweet corn custard, and key lime have appeared on seasonal menus.

Here’s the important part. For regular pickup Tuesday through Friday or Sunday, orders generally must be submitted by 8 AM the preceding day.

Tuesday and Wednesday morning pickups use a narrower collection window, while Thursday, Friday, and Sunday follow storefront hours. Special holiday pickup arrangements can differ.

The bakery also supplies Twin Cities cafes and sells at Mill City Farmers Market. A gluten-free key lime option is listed, although anyone with strict dietary needs should check preparation details.

Sweet corn custard pie is a particularly fun Minnesota twist. Reserve one when it’s available, then take your box somewhere comfortable for the first slice.

5. The Cheese & Pie Mongers

The Cheese & Pie Mongers
© The Cheese & Pie Mongers

Cheese and pie under one roof sounds like a dare, yet it works beautifully. The Cheese & Pie Mongers sits on a rural road near Lake Crystal in southern Minnesota.

Operating since 2014, the specialty shop makes crusts from scratch using recipes inspired by home baking.

The bakery occupies the Welsh Heritage Farms apple-orchard property, so the surroundings feel more like a countryside outing than a downtown pastry shop.

Freshly baked pies share space with take-and-bake and frozen varieties.

Classic apple, French apple with a crumb topping, banana cream, coconut cream, and seasonal fruit combinations are among the choices. Apple cider doughnuts provide an extra reason to stop during orchard season.

The cheese selection brings in varieties from regional makers. Pantry items such as honey and jam make it easy to assemble a small gift or take home something savory alongside dessert.

The shop’s address is 20758 528th Ave, Lake Crystal. Regular hours run Wednesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 5 PM; the doors are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. Holiday schedules may differ.

Because particular flavors may need baking or restocking, arrange your preferred whole pie before making the drive. The menu is extensive, but that doesn’t mean every filling is ready in the case every afternoon.

6. Sara’s Bakery – Featuring Tipsy Pies

Sara's Bakery - Featuring Tipsy Pies
© Sara’s Bakery – featuring Tipsy Pies

Hand pies are the pocket-sized heroes of the pastry world. In Stillwater, Sara’s Bake Shop specializes in sweet and savory hand pies plus fresh pastries.

The storefront carries a much larger assortment than its portable treats suggest.

Banana cream pie, caramel apple hand pies, blueberry lemon bread, and doughnuts appear on its menu. Frozen pies offer an option for guests who would rather finish the baking at home.

You can find the bakery at 1790 Washington Ave S, Stillwater. It’s a useful stop for anyone arranging treats for a gathering, but also for those who simply want a pastry with morning coffee.

A retail counter offers fresh sweets, grab-and-go choices, and occasional weekly specials.

Whole pies, hand pies, and tarts can be ordered ahead, with convenient pickup options. The bakery also caters celebrations.

If you need a particular filling or several boxes, make arrangements before the event rather than depending on the day’s display.

Store hours are 9 AM to 6 PM weekdays and 9 AM to 5 PM weekends. Those weekend hours help with Saturday pickups. A few extra minutes at the counter are useful for seeing what’s freshly baked.

Stillwater already makes a pleasant day trip along the St. Croix River. Ending it with a box of pastry feels like the sort of small plan that ends up becoming a tradition.

7. Betty’s Pies

Betty's Pies
© Betty’s Pies

With roots dating to 1956, this North Shore bakery has been turning road trips into pie trips. Betty’s Pies sits along Highway 61 in Two Harbors near Lake Superior.

The business began as a roadside food stand before expanding into a cafe known for pastries. The original operation grew around pies baked for travelers heading farther up the lakeshore, and the tradition continues decades later.

The flavors cover both fruit and cream fillings. Raspberry rhubarb, blueberry, apple caramel, coconut cream, and chocolate selections have all been part of the range.

Whole pies are available alongside individual slices, so you can enjoy one at a table and bring another along for the journey.

Breakfast and lunch add another reason to pull off the highway. The cafe serves familiar comfort dishes, while its dessert case provides a tempting conclusion before you return to the scenic road.

The address is 1633 MN-61, Two Harbors. If you’re set on a particular pie, arrange the order before your visit. The bakery also offers nationwide shipping, useful for sending North Shore flavors farther away.

Opening hours change seasonally and are updated through the business’s social channels rather than a fixed weekly schedule on its main site.

8. Rustic Inn Cafe

Rustic Inn Cafe
© Rustic Inn Cafe

A rustic North Shore dining room makes a fitting home for pies made from scratch.

Rustic Inn Cafe sits along Highway 61 near Castle Danger, just up the shore from Two Harbors.

The caramel apple pecan pie is a house specialty. Raspberry rhubarb, French apple, and raspberry cream pies have also appeared among the options. If you’re choosing between cream and fruit, maybe just choose both.

The cafe serves full meals as well as desserts, with breakfast dishes that include a walleye cake Benedict. Lunch and dinner menus bring a variety of home-style cooking into the rustic dining room, where windows brighten the interior.

For a quicker stop, ask about a pie prepared for takeout. You can place orders through the restaurant, and its online shipping program offers pies that are baked to order and frozen for transport.

Shipped orders require at least 48 hours of notice, with dispatch scheduled early in the week.

There’s a gift shop to explore, and the North Shore scenery is close enough to tempt you back onto the road. The cafe is open year-round, including beyond the summer season.

You’ll reach it at 2773 MN-61, Two Harbors. Before setting out, look over its available pie flavors and arrange a whole one if you know what you’d like. That way the only difficult decision left is whether to save dessert for later.

9. The Park Cafe

The Park Cafe
© The Park Cafe

Braham has a big claim to fame as Minnesota’s pie capital. The Park Cafe on Main Street helps the town live up to that sweet nickname.

The cafe has been serving homestyle meals since 1946, although Braham’s reputation as a stopping place for pie reaches back even farther.

In 1990, the state’s governor formally recognized the community as the Homemade Pie Capital of Minnesota after enjoying a slice at this very cafe.

That history is still part of the dining room. You can find the commemorative proclamation and order freshly baked pie along with breakfast, lunch, or a daily special.

Pancakes, eggs, burgers, and other familiar cafe plates keep the menu grounded in simple cooking.

You’ll find the restaurant at 124 Main St S, Braham, a short drive from Highway 65. Its daytime schedule generally runs from 7 AM until 2 PM, making this an outing for breakfast or lunch rather than late evening dessert.

Whole pies require planning. The cafe asks for 24 hours’ notice to prepare an order fresh. Slices may be available for spontaneous stops, but an entire pie for a holiday table deserves advance arrangements.

Braham celebrates its baking identity with Pie Day on the first Friday in August. Between the annual tradition and the old cafe, this is a town that takes pastry seriously, just as it should.

10. Pieway To Heaven

Pieway To Heaven
© Pieway To Heaven

With a name this punny, the pies have to back it up. Pieway To Heaven is a custom home-based bakery in Eden Prairie.

Its specialty is whole pies and portable pie bites, with all-butter pastry forming the foundation. Those treats work for gatherings where everyone wants a taste without cutting an entire pie into slices.

The assortment includes salted caramel apple, pecan, mixed berry, and a playful Blueyberry pie.

Lemon bar mini pies and other seasonal flavors also appear in the ordering selection. Some products are made without gluten, although availability depends on the specific recipe.

Because this is a home bakery rather than a walk-in cafe, arrangements matter. Order in advance, choose an available collection date, and follow the instructions provided before pickup.

Collection information arrives separately, so wait for confirmation before visiting.

The business lists 6820 W 175th Ave, Eden Prairie, as its address. Confirm the precise pickup arrangements when ordering instead of treating it like an ordinary storefront with a public pie counter.

For celebrations, combining several full-sized flavors with bite-sized pastries can create a dessert spread that invites everyone to sample something different. Save some for breakfast, too.

Here’s a fun ending to this pie tour. Sometimes the road to dessert really does lead to the suburbs, where the calendar is as important as the rolling pin.

More to Explore