North Carolina Just Named Its Best Cheese, And One Small Farm Took The Biggest Prize

featured image de6325caeff8 1716f2100693 - Decor Hint

A goat cheese with a blue streak just beat every dairy product in the 2026 statewide competition. Not just its category. The whole thing.

The same small farm walked away with four more top awards that year. Those included a tapenade chevre, a plain chevre, and something called skyr.

I love that one family farm stacked up that many wins.

The cheese starts with about 100 Alpine and Saanen goats. Their barn even has a nickname, the Goat Hilton.

Guard llamas keep watch over the herd, which feels like a security detail fit for celebrities.

I believe the best part is that you can actually go there. You can sleep in the farmhouse, eat the cheese at breakfast, and help with milking.

How many award winners in North Carolina let you meet the goats behind the trophy?

The Cheese That Beat Everything In The State

The Cheese That Beat Everything In The State
Image Credit: Hubertl, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. Via Wikimedia Commons.

Celebrity Dairy took home the biggest honor at the 2026 Got to Be NC Dairy Competition. Its Blue Streak Chevre was named Best of North Carolina, Overall Top Product.

That title means it outshone every entry in the contest. Cheese, yogurt, milk, all of it.

Not bad for a farm run by one family and a lot of goats.

Blue Streak also won Best Aged Goat Cheese that same year. So it pulled off a double win, which feels a little greedy in the best way.

The name hints at the blue line that runs through it.

The farm makes its cheeses with traditional French farmstead methods. The milk comes from its own herd and gets pasteurized before cheesemaking begins.

That farm-to-cheese path keeps everything close to home.

Aged goat cheese is a bit of a specialty here. It takes patience, since aging can’t be rushed.

Fresh chevre is ready fast, but aged styles need time to build flavor.

If you love trying the top pick at any contest, start here. It is the cheese that put a small Chatham County farm on the statewide stage.

Pretty hard to argue with a trophy like that.

Four More Trophies Joined The Party In 2026

Four More Trophies Joined The Party In 2026
© Celebrity Dairy

One big win would have been enough for most farms. Celebrity Dairy decided to collect a whole shelf of them instead.

The 2026 contest handed the farm four category awards on top of the grand prize.

Tapenade chevre won Best Flavored Cheese. Tapenade is usually an olive-based spread, so this cheese brings a savory, salty twist.

It sounds like a snack board shortcut.

Pure Chevre won Best Fresh Chevre Plain. Plain cheese can be the hardest to get right, since nothing hides the flavor.

Winning there says a lot about the milk itself.

Then there’s Tykk Skyr, which won Best Specialty Cultured Product. Skyr is a thick cultured dairy food with Icelandic roots.

Seeing it on a North Carolina goat farm is a fun surprise.

The streak didn’t start in 2026 either. The farm’s fresh chevre and a soft, spreadable cheese also won awards in the 2025 competition.

Back-to-back recognition shows this isn’t a lucky one-year bump.

For shoppers, that list works like a tasting map. Start with the plain chevre, then try the tapenade.

Save the skyr for breakfast and see which one becomes your favorite.

A Milk Intolerance Started This Whole Cheesy Story

A Milk Intolerance Started This Whole Cheesy Story
Image Credit: Hubertl, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. Via Wikimedia Commons.

Sometimes a big idea begins with a small problem. Fleming Pfann had trouble digesting cow’s milk, but discovered she could enjoy goat’s milk without the same problem.

That discovery helped launch the cheesemaking side of the farm.

Brit and Fleming Pfann bought the land in 1987. The dairy received its license in 1991.

That’s more than three decades of goats, milk, and cheese.

Fleming ran the dairy and cheesemaking for about 25 years. She later shifted to managing the inn.

Brit now oversees the dairy and cheesemaking side of things.

I like that the farm grew from a real personal need. It wasn’t built around a trend or a marketing plan.

It came from figuring out what worked for their own family table.

Here’s a fun detail about the name. The goats were named after starlets from old Hollywood, which explains why the place is called Celebrity Dairy.

Somewhere out there, a goat carries a movie-star name with total confidence.

The farm also practices low-impact, sustainable agriculture. It works with the NC Ag Extension Service on small family farm conservation.

That long view helps explain how a small operation stayed strong this long.

The farm sits at 144 Celebrity Dairy Way, Siler City, NC 27344. It’s a peaceful spot in central North Carolina.

That rural setting is part of the appeal.

The Goats Live In A Barn Called The Goat Hilton

The Goats Live In A Barn Called The Goat Hilton
© Celebrity Dairy

Not every barn gets a hotel nickname. At this farm, the goat barn is known as the Goat Hilton.

Honestly, the residents probably earned it after all those awards.

Around 100 goats live on the property. They’re Alpine and Saanen breeds, both well known as dairy goats.

Their milk is the starting point for every cheese the farm makes.

The herd has some serious security, too. Llamas live on the farm as guardians, watching out for predators.

Don’t take it personally if one gives you a long stare.

Other animals round out the cast. Free-range chickens lay eggs for the farm, and barn cats live outdoors on the property.

It’s a busy, lively farmyard with plenty to watch.

Inn guests can observe goat milking or even pitch in. That’s a rare chance to see how cheese really begins.

Most of us only meet goat cheese in a grocery store cooler.

Kids and adults both tend to love animal time, so plan for it. Wear shoes you don’t mind getting a little dusty.

A working farm is not the place for your fanciest sneakers.

Baby Goat Season Might Be The Cutest Time To Go

Baby Goat Season Might Be The Cutest Time To Go
© Celebrity Dairy

Bottle-feeding a baby goat is about as charming as farm chores get. During kidding season, inn guests may get the chance to help.

That’s when the herd welcomes its newest members.

Kidding season is simply the time when goats give birth. On a dairy farm, it’s a big deal.

New kids mean the herd keeps growing and the milk keeps flowing.

The farm also hosts open barn events. These give visitors a chance to come see the animals up close.

Checking the farm’s event schedule before you go is a smart move.

Families with curious kids should keep this in mind. A visit can teach where food actually comes from.

That lesson sticks better when a goat is nibbling your sleeve.

Farm tours are part of the lineup, too. They offer a closer look at how a working dairy runs.

You’ll likely leave knowing more about goats than you ever expected.

Plan around the season if baby goats are your main goal. Timing matters on a farm, since animals follow nature’s calendar, not ours.

A little planning can turn a nice trip into a memorable one.

You Can Sleep Right Next Door To The Herd

You Can Sleep Right Next Door To The Herd
© Celebrity Dairy

The Inn at Celebrity Dairy lets you trade a hotel lobby for a pasture view. It’s a bed and breakfast built right on the working farm.

There are seven guest rooms in all.

The building has a neat backstory. A modern Greek Revival farmhouse was added onto an original log cabin from the 1800s. Old and new sit side by side.

Five rooms on the first and second floors have private bathrooms. Two attic rooms on the third floor share a bathroom.

That’s handy to know when you’re booking with friends or family.

Accessibility gets attention here, too. Wheelchair-accessible rooms and common areas are available on the main floor.

That makes the farm stay possible for more travelers.

Comfort comes in every season. Radiant floor heating warms the farmhouse and atrium, and full air-conditioning handles summer. A fireplace adds coziness on cooler days.

The inn also hosts weddings and other events through the year. So the space does double duty as a celebration spot.

Still, its best trick might be waking up a short walk from the goats who made breakfast possible.

Breakfast Here Comes With Bragging Rights

Breakfast Here Comes With Bragging Rights
© Celebrity Dairy

Award-winning cheese at breakfast sounds like a flex. At this inn, it’s simply part of the morning.

Every guest gets a complimentary breakfast featuring the dairy’s own chevre.

The plate leans heavily on the farm itself. Fresh eggs come from the free-range chickens on the property.

Homemade preserves and baked goods round things out.

Weekend and weekday breakfasts work a bit differently. Weekend guests get a full farm breakfast. Weekday guests receive a grab-and-go breakfast instead.

That difference matters if you love a slow morning at the table. Book a weekend stay for the full sit-down version.

Weekday visitors still get farm flavors, just in a quicker format.

The farm grows micro greens too. Those tiny greens add one more homegrown piece to the operation.

It shows how much of the menu can start right outside.

I can’t imagine a better way to taste the farm’s cheese for the first time. You eat it steps from where the milk was collected.

Grocery store chevre might feel a little ordinary afterward, so consider yourself warned.

Gelato, Fudge, And Soap All Come From Goat Milk

Gelato, Fudge, And Soap All Come From Goat Milk
© Celebrity Dairy

Cheese gets the trophies, but the goat milk doesn’t stop there. Celebrity Dairy also turns it into gelato.

Goat milk gelato is a fun twist on a classic frozen treat.

Fudge is on the list, too. The farm makes goat’s milk fudge, which sounds like a dessert worth packing for the ride home.

Sweet tooth, meet your new hobby.

Then there’s the non-edible star. Cud-Zu Soaps are goat’s milk soaps made by the farm.

The name alone deserves a small round of applause.

These extras make shopping more interesting. You can grab something for the fridge, the dessert plate, and the bathroom shelf.

That’s a pretty wide range for one herd of goats.

Gifts are an easy win here. A bar of farm soap or a box of fudge makes a thoughtful present.

It also gives friends a reason to ask where you found it.

Bring a cooler if you plan to buy cheese or gelato. Soft dairy products like to stay cold.

Your car ride home will go much better with a chill pack involved.

Trails, Ponds, And Monthly Dinners Fill Out The Visit

Trails, Ponds, And Monthly Dinners Fill Out The Visit
© Celebrity Dairy

A farm this size gives you room to roam. The property covers roughly 300 acres in rural Chatham County.

Rustic hiking trails wind through woodlands, around ponds, and across streams.

Those trails are a nice way to stretch your legs after breakfast. They also show off the land beyond the barn.

Bring sturdy shoes, since rustic means exactly that.

Food lovers should look at the event calendar. Celebrity Dairy hosts third-Sunday dinners, plus open barn days and farm tours.

Planning around one of those adds a special touch.

Can’t make the drive soon? The cheese travels to Triangle farmers markets like Carrboro, Durham, and Cary Downtown.

You can also find it at select Whole Foods and Weaver Street Market stores.

The farm focuses on local sales because the cheese is delicate. That makes it feel like a true North Carolina treasure.

So go taste the state’s top cheese close to where it began, and say hi to the goats for me.

More to Explore