11 Connecticut Bakeries And Pie Shops Serving Holiday Pies Worth Saving Room For
There’s always that moment after a big holiday dinner when someone asks if anybody wants pie.
Suddenly, everyone who claimed to be completely full finds a little extra room.
Across Connecticut, bakeries and pie shops are preparing holiday favorites that make dessert one of the season’s biggest pleasures.
And a good pie can easily become the part of the meal people remember most.
Some families stick with the same flavors every year, while others enjoy bringing something unexpected to the table.
Buying from a local bakery also means leaving the complicated pastry work to someone who knows what they’re doing.
That’s particularly appealing when the oven is already busy with dinner.
The only real challenge might be deciding how many pies are enough.
1. Bishop’s Orchards Farm Market

Some families pass down recipes, and this one passed down an entire orchard. Bishop’s Orchards has been farmed by the same Guilford family since 1871.
That long history shows up in the farm market. You’ll find a bakery counter stocked with pies alongside fresh fruit and local groceries.
Apple pie feels like the natural pick here. After all, the apples grow on land the family has worked for more than 150 years.
Holiday shopping at a farm market has a sneaky bonus. You can grab your pie, then fill your basket with produce and pantry items for the rest of the meal.
The orchard also offers pick-your-own fruit during the growing season. Visiting in summer or fall gives you a fun preview of the fruit that ends up in the bakery.
For the big holidays, think ahead instead of hoping for luck. Farm bakeries get busy fast in late November and December, and popular pies can disappear.
I love the idea of serving a dessert with this much local farm history behind it. It turns a simple slice into a small story you can share at the table.
Address: 1355 Boston Post Rd, Guilford, CT 06437
2. Rogers Orchards

Two hundred years is a long time to keep an apple farm running. Rogers Orchards in Southington traces its roots back to 1809, and the family is still at it.
The farm store is the place to head for holiday treats. Along with apples and seasonal produce, it sells baked goods made with the fruit the farm is known for.
Apple pie is the obvious star at an orchard like this. Honestly, buying apple pie from a farm with this much apple history just feels right.
Southington sits right in the middle of the state, which makes the drive easy from many directions. That helps when you need to fit a pie run between grocery trips.
Here’s a smart move for the holidays. Pick up a bag of fresh apples with your pie, and you have a snack for the guests who arrive early.
Farm stores follow the seasons, so stock can change through the year. A quick check before you go saves you from a sad, pieless ride home.
Old orchards like this one are part of what makes holiday food here so special. You’re not just buying dessert, you’re supporting a farm with deep local roots.
Address: 336 Long Bottom Rd, Southington, CT 06489
3. Oronoque Farms Gift & Bakery

Connecticut Magazine readers once crowned this Shelton bakery for the Best Apple Crumb Pie. That is a big title in a state packed with apple orchards.
Oronoque Farms bakes its pies in a 9-inch size. The lineup covers apple, apple crumb, blueberry, and cherry for fruit lovers.
Cream pie fans have plenty to consider too. Chocolate cream, banana cream, chocolate banana cream, and coconut cream all show up on the list.
Watching your sugar but still craving dessert? A sugar-free apple pie option means more people at the table can enjoy a slice.
Now for my favorite detail. The bakery makes its own premium homemade ice cream, so pie a la mode can come from one stop.
Thanksgiving pies here go first-come, first-served. Translation: don’t stroll in late on Wednesday afternoon and expect a full selection waiting for you.
Arrive early, pick your crumb pie, and maybe grab a pint of ice cream on the way out. Your future self, sitting on the couch after dinner, will thank you.
Address: 188 Leavenworth Rd, Shelton, CT 06484
4. Kouign Bakery

Pumpkin cookie butter pie. Read that again slowly, because it is a real holiday pie from this Wallingford bakery.
Chef Chelsea Tripp runs the kitchen with a playful streak. The menu changes weekly and often mixes sweet and savory ideas in surprising ways.
Past holiday pies have included salted caramel apple and chocolate pecan. Blueberry cornmeal pie has made an appearance too, which sounds like summer sneaking into winter.
The creativity doesn’t stop at pie. The bakery has worked ingredients like miso and turmeric into its sweets, so expect a few delightful plot twists.
Timing matters here more than most places. Regular retail hours run Friday through Sunday mornings, from 8 a.m. until 1 p.m. or until things sell out.
Holiday orders work through pre-order windows with set pickup dates. Christmas Eve morning pickup has been offered for cinnamon rolls and quiche, which could solve breakfast too.
Not into pie? The chewy-crisp chocolate chip cookies and plush cinnamon rolls are popular picks.
Still, I’d find it hard to walk past anything called cookie butter.
Address: 600 N Colony Rd, Wallingford, CT 06492
5. Kneads Bakery Cafe

Most bakeries buy their flour by the bag. Kneads grinds its own, stone-milling local grain on site into 100 percent whole grain organic flour.
The Fairfield spot is a family-run bakery, cafe, and mill. Fresh artisan breads and pastries come out of the ovens daily.
Holiday pie orders get seriously thoughtful here. The Apple Crumb Pie and Double-Crusted Apple Pie both use Mutsu apples from Woodland Farm.
Pecan Pie gets its sweetness from Hudson Valley maple syrup. The Sweet Potato Pie comes topped with toasted meringue over a graham cracker crust.
Want something less traditional? A S’mores Pie with dark chocolate cremeux and toasted meringue sounds like a campfire wearing its holiday best.
Key Lime Pie with vanilla chantilly brings a bright, tangy break from heavy desserts. Pumpkin Cheesecake and Sticky Toffee Pudding also join the holiday lineup.
On a regular day, you can stop in for breakfast, lunch, coffee, or tea. Seating is limited, so a grab-and-go plan might work better on busy mornings.
Address: 1916 Post Rd, Fairfield, CT 06824
6. Organic Roots Farm Bake Shoppe

Einkorn is one of the oldest grains people ever grew. At this Hampton farm, baker Rosetta Fisher uses it to make pies by hand.
Rosetta is the farmer’s wife and the owner of the Bake Shoppe. She bakes with einkorn flour and natural ingredients in a commercial kitchen right on Organic Roots Farm.
The holiday pie list reads like a family reunion menu. Pumpkin, pecan, apple crumb, and blueberry double crust are all available for pre-order.
Then there’s Grandma’s Double Crust Apple Pie. Any pie with Grandma in the name gets my vote before I even know the recipe.
The farm store makes this trip extra useful. You can shop for in-season organic produce, eggs, raw milk, cheese, and grass-fed meats in one visit.
Christmas brings fresh roping, wreaths, and cider donuts. That means you could decorate your door and fill your dessert plate before heading home.
Just remember the shop closes on Sundays, so plan your farm run for another day.
Address: 147 E Old Route 6, Hampton, CT 06247
7. Michele’s Pies

Fifty-six first-place wins at the National Pie Championships is an impressive achievement for this bakery. That trophy shelf belongs to a Norwalk shop that bakes its pies from scratch.
Owner Michele Stuart learned to bake from her grandmother. She opened the Norwalk store in 2007, and it now offers more than 30 flavors.
Her Thanksgiving pumpkin pie even went head to head on Food Network’s Throwdown with Bobby Flay. That is a lot of pressure for one pie, and it handled the spotlight with style.
Fruit fans can look for blueberry crumble and apple crumb. Cream pie lovers get choices like coconut cream, which sounds like a holiday table upgrade to me.
Most pies come in a mini 6-inch size or a bigger 9-inch size. The small one is handy if you want to try two flavors without starting a family debate.
Savory eaters are covered too, with chicken pot pies and cheddar biscuits. The shop also makes cookies, tea breads, puff pastry, and cheesecakes, so dinner and dessert can share one stop.
Plan ahead, since the store is open Tuesday through Saturday. Pickup happens right at the Norwalk shop, so mark your calendar early.
Address: 666 Main Ave, Norwalk, CT 06851
8. Cutie Pies Bakery & Cafe

With a name like Cutie Pies, this Thomaston bakery practically begs for a holiday visit. The dessert case backs up that charm with a wide spread of treats.
Fruit fans can grab an Apple Turnover, which tastes like a hand-held cousin of apple pie. Lemon Bars and Raspberry Bars bring tart, bright flavor to any dessert table.
Cheesecake is a big player here, with several kinds on the menu. Churro Cheesecake Bars sound like the kind of mash-up that wins over picky relatives.
The case also mixes in cannolis, French macarons, tiramisu, and baklava. That variety helps when your crowd can’t agree on a single holiday dessert.
Ready-made 6-inch cakes are baked fresh daily and sit right in the showcase. They’re perfect for smaller gatherings or a last-minute hosting rescue.
Need a gluten-sensitive option? The bakery offers them by special order, though it is not a fully gluten-free facility because of airborne flour.
Hours run Tuesday through Saturday, with Sunday and Monday off. Stop by early in the week before your holiday plans get too hectic to manage.
Address: 131 Main St, Suite 105A, Thomaston, CT 06787
9. Dondero Orchards

Back in 1911, the Dondero family started farming in South Glastonbury. More than a century later, their farm stand is still a stop worth making.
Orchard bakeries have a clear advantage when it comes to pie. The fruit doesn’t travel far before it lands in a crust.
Dondero’s farm stand sells baked goods along with its fruits and vegetables. Pies fit right in with the apples and seasonal produce the farm grows.
Glastonbury has a long farming tradition along the Connecticut River. Stopping at a family orchard here feels like taking part in that story.
Holiday hosts, here’s a handy trick. Pair your pie with a bag of local apples or fresh produce, and you’ll cover dessert plus a side dish.
Farm stands change with the seasons, so offerings can shift throughout the year. Check before you head out, especially as the holidays get close.
There’s also a fun pairing on this list. Brown Butter Creations sits in the same town, so a two-pie Glastonbury tour is very doable for ambitious dessert fans.
Address: 529 Woodland St, South Glastonbury, CT 06073
10. Brown Butter Creations

Brown butter is the secret handshake of serious bakers. This Glastonbury shop built its whole name around that nutty, toasty flavor.
The holiday pie list leans into it, too. Brown Butter Apple Crumb and Brown Butter Sweet Potato Meringue both carry the signature ingredient.
Pumpkin Mascarpone Swirl gives the classic pumpkin pie a creamy makeover. French Silk Chocolate is there for the guests who just want chocolate, period.
Nut allergies in the family? Most items here are nut-free, and anything with nuts says so right in the name.
Gluten-free shoppers should look elsewhere, since the bakery skips those products to avoid cross-contamination. Delivery isn’t offered either, so plan on picking up your order.
Saturday mornings bring the highly coveted Brown Butter Cinnamon Rolls. Saturday hours end at noon, so sleeping in could cost you a roll.
The shop also makes cakes, cupcakes, pastries, cookies, and platters. Cakes need at least seven days of notice, which is good to know before holiday parties pile up.
Address: 353 New London Turnpike, Glastonbury, CT 06033
11. Lyman Orchards Apple Barrel

This farm was already growing when the colonies still answered to a king. Lyman Orchards got its start in 1741 and now covers 1,100 acres.
The Apple Barrel Farm Market and Bakery is the pie headquarters. Its scratch bakery turns out award-winning pies and famous apple cider donuts.
The hi-top apple pie is the one people know best. Picture a tall dome of apples under a crust, built for a crowd.
Since the orchard grows apples, pumpkins, peaches, and berries, the bakery sits close to its fruit. Pick-your-own season runs from June through November.
The market stocks local foods, farm produce, and specialty groceries too. The on-site Creamery serves apple crisp sundaes, which is dessert stacked on dessert.
Good news for busy holiday weeks: the market is open daily year-round. The bakery counter opens at 9 a.m., with current posted hours running until 4 p.m. on weekdays and 5 p.m. on weekends.
Leave your pup at home, since the property is pet-free, though service animals are welcome. Then go grab the tallest apple pie you can carry.
Address: 32 Reeds Gap Rd, Middlefield, CT 06455
