14 Florida Lobster Roll Shacks That Keep It Simple And Fresh
Florida might be famous for its sunshine and beaches, but the state also serves up some of the best lobster rolls outside of New England. These no-frills shacks focus on what matters most: fresh lobster, quality ingredients, and that perfect balance of simplicity and flavor.
Whether you’re craving a classic Connecticut-style roll or a Maine-inspired version, these spots deliver without the fuss.
1. The Lobster Shack – Key West
Tucked away in the heart of Key West, this spot has mastered the art of keeping things refreshingly uncomplicated. The lobster arrives fresh daily, and the rolls are piled high with tender, sweet meat lightly dressed to let the natural flavor shine.
Outdoor seating offers a breezy, laid-back vibe that pairs perfectly with a cold drink and the island atmosphere. Locals and tourists alike appreciate the straightforward approach here – no over-the-top toppings, just honest, delicious seafood done right.
2. DJ’s Clam Shack – Key West
This place brings a cheerful, easygoing energy to the Key West dining scene. The lobster rolls here are generously portioned and come on buttery, toasted rolls that add just the right amount of crunch.
There’s something special about enjoying fresh seafood while watching peaceful surroundings. The menu stays simple, letting the quality of the lobster speak for itself without unnecessary frills or complicated preparations.
3. Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant – Key West
Part seafood market, part casual eatery, this Eaton Street gem offers the best of both worlds. Customers can watch as their lobster is prepared fresh, ensuring every bite is as flavorful as possible.
The setting feels authentic and unpretentious, with picnic-style tables and a menu that celebrates simplicity. Whether grabbing lunch to go or settling in for a leisurely meal, the focus remains squarely on fresh, quality seafood without any pretense.
4. Kelly’s Landing New England Seafood – Fort Lauderdale
Bringing a taste of New England to South Florida, Kelly’s Landing has earned a loyal following for its authentic approach to lobster rolls. The meat is cold-served with just a touch of mayo, letting the sweet, briny flavor take center stage.
Inland seating adds to the charm, making it easy to enjoy a meal while soaking in panoramic views. The atmosphere feels relaxed and welcoming, perfect for anyone seeking a classic lobster roll experience far from the Northeast coast.
5. Lobster Haven – Tampa
Tampa’s Lobster Haven lives up to its name, offering a cozy spot where lobster lovers can indulge without breaking the bank. The rolls are packed with fresh chunks of lobster, lightly seasoned and served on soft, buttery buns.
The casual setting encourages diners to relax and savor each bite at their own pace. With friendly service and a commitment to freshness, this spot has become a go-to for anyone craving straightforward, satisfying seafood in the Tampa area.
6. Captain & Krewe Seafood Market & Raw Bar – Naples
Naples’ Captain & Krewe blends the charm of a traditional seafood market with the energy of a lively raw bar. Lobster rolls here are crafted with care, featuring generous portions of tender meat that’s never overdressed or overpowered.
The nautical-themed space feels fresh and inviting, with a menu that highlights the day’s catch. Diners appreciate the transparency and quality, knowing their lobster comes straight from the market’s own display cases to their plate.
7. Lobster Lady Seafood Market & Bistro – Cape Coral
Cape Coral’s Lobster Lady combines market-fresh seafood with a warm, welcoming bistro atmosphere. The lobster rolls are a standout, featuring sweet, succulent meat that’s simply prepared to highlight its natural flavor.
The family-friendly environment makes it a great stop for lunch or an early dinner. With an emphasis on freshness and quality ingredients, the Lobster Lady has built a reputation for delivering consistently delicious seafood without any unnecessary complications or gimmicks.
8. The Clam Bake – Fort Myers
Fort Myers’ Clam Bake channels classic New England vibes with a menu that keeps things wonderfully simple. Lobster rolls arrive piled high with fresh meat, lightly tossed in mayo or butter, depending on preference.
Clam Bake’s laid-back atmosphere make this spot feel like a true seaside escape. The focus stays firmly on quality and freshness, with no fancy presentations or complicated recipes – just good, honest seafood that tastes like summer year-round.
9. Cape Cod Fish Company – Fort Myers
Bringing a slice of Cape Cod to Southwest Florida, this Fort Myers favorite specializes in traditional lobster rolls that honor New England traditions. The lobster is sweet and tender, served cold with a light mayo dressing that doesn’t mask the flavor.
Coastal decor and a friendly staff create a comfortable, unpretentious dining experience. Whether stopping by for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner, customers can count on consistently fresh seafood prepared the old-fashioned way.
10. Timoti’s Seafood Shak – Fernandina Beach
Up in Fernandina Beach, Timoti’s Seafood Shak captures that perfect beachy, barefoot vibe. The lobster rolls are simple yet satisfying, loaded with fresh lobster and served on toasted rolls that add a nice textural contrast.
The casual, open-air setting invites diners to kick back and enjoy their meal without any formality. With a menu that celebrates fresh, local seafood, Timoti’s has become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors seeking authentic coastal flavor.
11. Boston’s Fish House – Winter Park
Winter Park’s Boston’s Fish House brings East Coast seafood traditions to Central Florida with warmth and authenticity. The lobster rolls are generously filled with fresh, sweet meat that’s dressed simply to let the lobster’s natural flavor shine through.
The cozy interior and friendly service make it a comfortable spot for a meal any day of the week. This location has earned a loyal following by staying true to classic recipes and never cutting corners on quality or freshness.
12. Boston’s Fish House – New Smyrna Beach
The New Smyrna Beach location of Boston’s Fish House offers the same commitment to quality and simplicity that made the brand a favorite. Lobster rolls here are packed with tender chunks of lobster, lightly seasoned and served on perfectly toasted buns.
The beachy atmosphere and relaxed vibe make it an ideal stop after a day on the sand. With a menu that stays true to New England roots, this spot delivers satisfying seafood that feels both familiar and fresh.
13. Cod & Capers Café – North Palm Beach
North Palm Beach’s Cod & Capers Café offers a charming, neighborhood feel with a menu that highlights fresh seafood done right. The lobster rolls are a customer favorite, featuring sweet, succulent meat nestled in soft, buttery rolls.
The bright, airy space feels welcoming and casual, perfect for a leisurely lunch or early dinner. With a focus on quality ingredients and straightforward preparation, this cafe has carved out a reputation for serving some of the best lobster rolls in the area.
14. Dive Bar Restaurant – Jupiter
Jupiter’s Dive Bar Restaurant combines a fun, tropical vibe with seriously good seafood. The lobster rolls here are no joke – loaded with fresh, sweet lobster and served in a relaxed, tiki-style setting that feels like a mini vacation.
Waterfront views and a laid-back crowd make this spot a local favorite for both food and atmosphere. Despite the playful name, the kitchen takes its seafood seriously, delivering fresh, flavorful lobster rolls that keep customers coming back for more.
