Forget Sweet Pies, This Virginia Bakery Is All About Savory Meat Pies, Sausage Rolls And Pasties
A chef who spent nearly a decade cooking for touring musicians ended up building a pie shop around a craving.
He couldn’t find a proper New Zealand-style pie after leaving home, so he made his own.
The whole business runs through a walk-up window nicknamed the PieHole, and the savory pies come as personal hand pies.
Steak, curried lamb, butter chicken and sausage rolls all fit neatly in one hand. It’s a homesick idea built for people on the move.
This Virginia bakery also makes sweet pies by the slice or whole.
One famous chef called its pumpkin pie the best of his life. Which side wins?
A Homesick Chef Built This Shop Around One Missing Pie

Cravings can change a career. Proper Pie Co. grew out of a New Zealand chef’s search for the savory pastries he remembered from home.
In Whangarei, where he grew up, savory pies were everyday food. He later worked in London kitchens and spent nearly ten years cooking for touring musicians.
Travel strengthened his appetite for familiar New Zealand food. Eventually, he and his wife made Richmond, Virginia, the home of a different kind of bakery.
Proper Pie Co. opened in November 2012 in Church Hill. The idea was straightforward: bake individual savory pies with flaky pastry and fillings inspired by different cuisines, while leaving room for sweet slices and seasonal creations.
The changing menu moves between steak, vegetables, and inventive curry fillings. Much of the appeal comes from the pastry itself.
Each pie is made by hand, with attention given to both its crust and filling. That’s quite a career change, from feeding touring performers to making lunch that fits in one hand.
Order At The PieHole And Skip The Usual Bakery Routine

There’s no door to hold open here, at least not for customers. Proper Pie Co. serves everyone through a walk-up window that goes by a delightful nickname: the PieHole.
Choose your pies at the window and collect your order. A few sidewalk tables offer seating, but there are no indoor tables or customer restrooms.
Planning ahead pays off. Online orders for same-day pickup open at 10 AM, while the window starts serving walk-up customers at noon. Pies are baked daily, so availability changes.
Hours run from noon to 6 PM, Wednesday through Sunday. The shop stays closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, making those days better suited to planning your next visit.
Online orders reserve the pies you select, and pickup still happens at the PieHole. You can choose lunch before leaving home. Since the pies are ready when purchased, the actual pickup process is straightforward.
Hand Pies Packed With Steak, Lamb And Butter Chicken

Steak and Vegetable is the kind of pie that explains the whole shop in one bite. The savory pies are individual servings, wrapped in pastry and made for an easy lunch.
The lineup rotates, so you might encounter Steak and Cheese, Curried Lamb and Lentil, Butter Chicken, or a pork filling depending on the day. This Virginia kitchen also draws inspiration from flavors far beyond New Zealand.
Pork Chile Verde is a particularly distinctive example, combining slow-roasted pork shoulder, cheese, and green chile seasoning. Other fillings feature herbs, vegetables, and savory sauces.
Pasties are part of the selection, too. A traditional beef pasty or a bacon-and-cheese version offers a different pastry shape and filling combination from the round savory pies.
Each batch involves preparing pastry, adding filling, sealing, and baking the pies. That’s a considerable amount of kitchen work for something designed to be eaten without a plate.
Sausage Rolls Deserve A Spot In Every Order

House-ground pork is where this one begins. The sausage roll pairs seasoned pork with caramelized onions and sage, wrapped in layers of puff pastry.
Across New Zealand, Australia, and Britain, sausage rolls are familiar bakery fare, substantial enough to accompany a savory pie.
The pastry gives the roll its characteristic flaky exterior, while the filling stays savory and aromatic. Caramelized onions bring sweetness, and sage gives the sausage a warm herbal note.
Proper Pie has also offered a broccoli, chickpea, and feta roll, bringing a vegetarian alternative to the same convenient format. Its filling includes onion, garlic, and sun-dried tomato.
Because the menu changes, the particular roll selections can vary. The classic sausage roll, though, has been one of the shop’s longstanding specialties.
The combination of crisp pastry and seasoned filling makes it an appealing choice for anyone who enjoys savory baked goods.
Vegans Get Their Own Options, Too

Plant-based eaters aren’t limited to a plain vegetable side at Proper Pie. Vegan savory pies are part of the rotating selection, with fillings that can be every bit as interesting as the meat versions.
Past choices include Butternut and Chickpea, Vegan Cheesesteak, and Chili Bean and “Cheese.” They combine legumes, spices, and plant-based ingredients.
The shop marks vegan items so groups can distinguish their orders. Still, it’s worth checking the day’s ingredient information, particularly if anyone has allergies.
Sweet choices are available, too. Blueberry Apple, Strawberry Rhubarb, and Peach and Blackberry have appeared among the plant-based dessert pies.
That suits mixed groups: one person gets steak, another chooses chickpea, and everyone gets pastry.
The exact number of vegan choices varies by day, since the selection responds to ingredients and seasonal recipes.
For anyone avoiding dairy or eggs, asking about the pastry and fillings is especially useful. Check the day’s selection before heading over with a particular flavor in mind.
Sweet Pies Sneak In With A Very Tall Meringue

The bakery may revolve around savory pies, but the dessert selection offers serious competition. Sweet pies are available by the slice, with whole pies offered for sharing at home.
Lemon Meringue brings a bright lemon filling beneath peaks of whipped meringue. Coconut Cream, Chocolate Chess, and fruit-filled pies take the menu in entirely different directions.
Seasonal pies include Pumpkin and Salted Caramel, while other choices range from Sour Cream and Wild Blueberry to Buttermilk and Raspberry, apple, and strawberry rhubarb.
The pastry case can also include New Zealand-inspired sweets such as lamingtons and caramel slices. They’re another connection to the founder’s home country.
The rotation means a favorite from last time might make room for something new.
Whole pies are particularly handy for family gatherings, although arranging one ahead of time is a good idea when you have a specific occasion in mind.
A fair plan works well here. Pick a savory hand pie for lunch, then grab a sweet slice for later. That way both sides of the menu get a turn.
Church Hill Gives Your Pie A Historic Backdrop

Old brick, quiet streets, and a pie window make a pretty good trio. Proper Pie Co. sits in Church Hill, one of Richmond’s oldest neighborhoods.
You’ll find it at 2505 E Broad St, Suite 100, Richmond. Historic houses and neighborhood businesses line nearby streets.
Through the storefront windows, you can glimpse the bakery workspace where the pastry is prepared. The compact shop keeps its focus on the kitchen and walk-up counter.
Street parking is the main option, so allow time to find a spot.
Church Hill’s brick buildings and tree-lined streets provide an appealing setting for a short stroll with lunch in hand.
The surrounding area also includes old churches, historic homes, and parks with elevated views toward the James River.
Its architecture reflects different periods of the city’s development, giving even an ordinary neighborhood walk something interesting to discover.
This part of Virginia has a particularly strong connection to Richmond’s early history. Your pie is a good reason to explore at least a few blocks before heading home.
Carry Your Pie Around The Corner For A Sunset View

No dining room? No problem. Libby Hill Park sits a few blocks away, and it makes a lovely spot to eat.
The park overlooks the James River and downtown Richmond, with benches, open green space, and broad views from its hilltop. It’s known for the river vista traditionally linked to the city’s name.
Find a bench, unwrap a hand pie, and enjoy the scenery.
Late-afternoon light warms the river and rooftops. Keep the park’s daylight hours in mind, especially in winter.
Bring napkins, because flaky pastry tends to leave evidence of an enthusiastic lunch. A drink and a small bag for packaging are helpful, too.
The park’s elevated setting makes it easy to appreciate the bend of the river and the historic neighborhood spreading across the hillside. It’s a pleasant neighborhood stroll without another drive.
A Small Grant Helped Launch A Big Richmond Favorite

Back in October 2011, a modest boost helped this dream get moving. Proper Pie Co. received support through a neighborhood entrepreneurship program that encouraged new businesses in Richmond’s East End.
The funding helped purchase kitchen equipment before opening. The idea was to bring the everyday savory pie tradition of New Zealand to a city where sweet dessert pies were already familiar.
Since opening in November 2012, the shop has focused on handmade pastry and rotating fillings.
That focus is still easy to recognize today. The window remains the place to collect your order, pies are baked fresh, and the selection includes savory meals alongside slices of dessert.
Its small-scale operation makes the experience wonderfully straightforward, with the day’s baked selection taking center stage.
It’s a small Virginia tradition with a very specific beginning: one homesick cook wanted a proper pie and decided to make it himself.
