13 Hole-In-The-Wall Italian Restaurants In Tennessee Only Locals Know About
Tennessee holds more than country music and barbecue in its culinary heart.
Tucked along quiet streets and historic squares, family-run Italian kitchens serve up recipes passed down through generations, offering flavors that rival anything found in bigger cities.
These hidden spots may not have flashy signs or crowded waiting areas, but locals know exactly where to go when craving authentic lasagna, hand-rolled pasta, or tiramisu made the old-fashioned way.
From Knoxville to Chattanooga, these restaurants prove that the best Italian food often hides in the most unexpected places.
1. Savelli’s Italian Restaurant
Locals have been gathering at this Tennessee favorite since the 1970s, drawn by recipes that haven’t changed in decades.
The restaurant sits at 3055 Sutherland Ave, Knoxville, TN 37919, where the aroma of bubbling marinara greets guests before they even step inside.
Nonna’s original lasagna recipe remains the star of the menu, layered with rich meat sauce and creamy ricotta that melts perfectly with every bite.
The chicken parmigiana platters arrive generous enough to share, though most regulars prefer to take leftovers home for the next day.
Dim lighting and red-checkered tablecloths create an atmosphere that feels like dining in someone’s beloved dining room.
Weeknight dinners tend to be quieter, making it easier to snag a table without waiting.
The staff remembers faces and orders, adding a personal touch that chain restaurants simply cannot replicate.
2. Marina’s On The Square
Positioned right on the historic square, this restaurant brings a touch of Italy to the heart of Murfreesboro.
The address is 125 N Maple St, Murfreesboro, TN 37130, where Marina herself often greets guests and checks on tables throughout the evening.
Sizzling shrimp scampi arrives at the table still bubbling in garlic butter, with crusty bread perfect for soaking up every last drop of sauce.
The menu changes slightly with the seasons, but core favorites remain available year-round for regulars who count on their go-to dishes.
Large windows overlook the square, offering pleasant people-watching during lunch hours when downtown workers stop by for quick but satisfying meals.
The atmosphere balances casual comfort with just enough polish for date nights or small celebrations.
Reservations help during weekends, though walk-ins usually find space on quieter weeknights.
3. Casa D’Italia Ristorante
Military families from nearby Fort Campbell have made this spot a tradition, returning again and again for generous portions and welcoming service.
The restaurant operates at 1345 Fort Campbell Blvd, Clarksville, TN 37042, where the parking lot often fills with families celebrating homecomings and promotions.
Tableside fettuccine alfredo gets prepared with a flourish, as servers toss fresh pasta in butter and parmesan right before your eyes.
Portions run large enough that most diners leave with a to-go box, making the meal feel like even better value.
The dining room accommodates groups comfortably, with booths that fit families and larger tables available for gatherings.
Kids find plenty of familiar options on the menu, while adults appreciate more adventurous choices alongside classic favorites.
Lunch specials offer smaller portions at lower prices for those seeking a midday Italian fix without overindulging.
4. Tony’s Pasta Shop & Trattoria
Fresh pasta gets crafted daily in this Chattanooga, Tennessee gem, where Tony’s dedication to quality shines through every hand-stuffed ravioli.
You’ll find it at 212 High St, Chattanooga, TN 37403, tucked into a space that feels more like a friend’s kitchen than a commercial restaurant.
The marinara sauce tastes simple yet perfect, allowing the quality of ripe tomatoes and fresh basil to speak for themselves without unnecessary complications.
Ravioli fillings change based on what’s available and in season, so regulars enjoy discovering new combinations alongside tried-and-true favorites.
Counter seating lets diners watch the pasta-making process, adding entertainment value to an already satisfying meal.
The casual atmosphere means there’s no need to dress up, though the food quality rivals much fancier establishments.
Takeout orders come packaged carefully, with sauces stored separately to prevent sogginess during the ride home.
5. Il Primo
Tucked into the trendy Northshore neighborhood, this restaurant sources ingredients from local farms while importing specialty items directly from Italy.
Located at 1100 Hixson Pike, Chattanooga, TN 37405, the spot attracts food lovers seeking authentic flavors with a farm-fresh twist.
Osso buco arrives fork-tender over creamy polenta, with meat that falls off the bone after hours of slow braising.
The wine list features Italian bottles carefully selected to complement the menu, with servers happy to suggest pairings for those unfamiliar with regional varieties.
Exposed brick and warm wood tones create an intimate setting that works equally well for romantic dinners or catching up with old friends.
Reservations prove essential on weekends, as word has spread among locals about the quality found here.
Lunch service offers lighter fare and quicker turnaround for those on tighter schedules during workdays.
6. Mauricio’s Italian Restaurant
Cookeville, Tennessee locals guard this secret carefully, though word continues to spread about the bubbling hot cannelloni and grandmother-style red sauce.
The restaurant sits at 232 N Peachtree Ave, Cookeville, TN 38501, where the modest exterior gives no hint of the flavors waiting inside.
Cannelloni arrives stuffed with fresh ricotta and covered in sauce that tastes like it simmered all day, because it probably did.
The red sauce recipe supposedly came from Mauricio’s grandmother, and it shows in the depth of flavor that only develops through time-honored techniques.
Portions run generous without being overwhelming, striking a balance that leaves diners satisfied but not uncomfortably full.
The small dining room fills quickly during dinner rush, so arriving on the earlier or later side helps avoid waiting.
Regulars know to save room for dessert, as the tiramisu and cannoli both deserve attention after a satisfying main course.
7. Culaccino Italian Restaurant + Bar
Franklin families have relied on this spot for years when craving Italian comfort food in a relaxed, unpretentious setting.
Located at 104 E Main St, Franklin, TN 37064, the restaurant sits in a convenient location that makes it easy to stop by after shopping or running errands.
The garlic rolls arrive warm and addictive, with a butter-garlic coating that makes it nearly impossible to stop at just one.
Pasta dishes come in sizes that accommodate both lighter appetites and those seeking a hearty meal, with prices that won’t break the bank.
The casual atmosphere means kids feel welcome, and the menu includes familiar options that even picky eaters tend to enjoy.
Servers work efficiently during busy times while still maintaining friendly, attentive service that keeps regulars coming back.
Takeout orders move quickly, making this a reliable choice for nights when cooking at home feels like too much effort.
8. Amerigo Italian Restaurant
Nashville, Tennessee diners seeking Italian food with a modern twist while respecting traditional techniques have embraced this neighborhood favorite.
The restaurant operates at 1920 West End Ave, Nashville, TN 37203, where the kitchen balances innovation with classic preparations that have stood the test of time.
Wood-grilled fish and meats add smoky depth to Italian preparations, creating flavors that feel both familiar and excitingly different.
The open kitchen design lets diners watch the cooking process, adding an element of theater to the dining experience.
Seasonal menu changes keep regulars interested, though core favorites remain available for those who prefer consistency over experimentation.
The wine program features both Italian imports and domestic bottles that pair well with the menu’s range of flavors.
Noise levels can climb during busy weekend nights, so those seeking quieter conversations might prefer weeknight visits or early dinner times.
9. Crazy Tomato
Johnson City locals appreciate this spot for reliable Italian-American favorites served in a comfortable, family-oriented environment.
The address is 203 Princeton Rd, Johnson City, TN 37601, where the parking lot regularly fills with families seeking affordable meals that please everyone at the table.
The pizza menu offers both classic combinations and build-your-own options, with crusts that strike a pleasing balance between crispy and chewy.
Pasta dishes arrive hot and generously portioned, with red sauce that tastes homemade rather than dumped from a jar.
The salad bar provides fresh vegetables and toppings, adding value for those who enjoy starting meals with greens.
Kids receive crayons and activity sheets, making this a practical choice for parents dining with younger children who need entertainment.
Lunch buffets during weekdays offer excellent value for those with flexible schedules and healthy appetites.
10. Carrabba’s Italian Grill
While technically a chain, the Murfreesboro, Tennessee location has earned local loyalty through consistent quality and servers who remember regular customers by name.
Located at 544 N Thompson Ln E, Murfreesboro, TN 37129, this spot delivers reliable Italian-American cooking that satisfies without requiring adventurous palates.
The chicken marsala features tender meat in a rich wine sauce with mushrooms, paired with perfectly cooked pasta that arrives al dente.
Wood-fired preparations add depth to grilled items, creating subtle smoky notes that enhance rather than overpower the Italian seasonings.
The bar area offers a more casual vibe for those dining solo or catching up with friends over appetizers and drinks.
Happy hour specials make this an affordable option for those watching budgets while still wanting a sit-down restaurant experience.
Online ordering streamlines takeout, with food packaged carefully to maintain temperature and quality during the trip home.
11. Giuseppe’s
Kingsport diners have relied on this spot since it opened, creating generations of families who consider it their go-to for Italian celebrations.
Located at 2539 E Stone Dr, Kingsport, TN 37660, the restaurant occupies a building that feels like it has been serving Italian food forever, in the best possible way.
The spaghetti carbonara arrives creamy and rich, with pancetta adding salty depth and egg creating silky texture without scrambling into clumps.
House-made salad dressings accompany fresh greens, with a tangy Italian vinaigrette that regulars request on the side for dipping bread.
The menu covers Italian-American classics without attempting trendy fusion or unnecessary modern twists that might alienate longtime customers.
Booths provide comfortable seating for lingering conversations, while tables accommodate groups celebrating birthdays, anniversaries, and other milestones.
Prices remain reasonable despite rising costs elsewhere, making this an accessible option for families dining out on regular budgets.
12. Bellacino’s
Hermitage, Tennessee locals appreciate this spot for satisfying Italian-style sandwiches and pizzas that deliver big flavors without pretension or high prices.
The address is 4662 Lebanon Pike, Hermitage, TN 37076, where the counter-service format keeps things casual and accessible for quick lunches or easy dinners.
The grinders arrive hot and overstuffed with quality meats, cheeses, and toppings that spill out with each bite in the most delicious way possible.
Pizza by the slice offers a quick option for those in a hurry, though whole pies provide better value for groups or hungry families.
The simple dining area keeps focus on the food rather than fancy décor, with a few tables for those eating in and efficient packaging for takeout.
Online ordering makes it easy to call ahead and grab food without waiting, perfect for busy weeknight dinners or lunch breaks.
Delivery service covers nearby neighborhoods, bringing hot Italian comfort food directly to your door when leaving home feels like too much effort.
13. Altruda’s Italian Restaurant
Family recipes have been the foundation here since the doors opened in 1988, creating a loyal following that spans generations.
Located at 125 N Peters Rd, Knoxville, TN 37923, this spot maintains the warmth of a neighborhood gathering place where everyone feels welcome.
Veal piccata arrives tender and perfectly seasoned, with a lemon-butter sauce that balances richness without overwhelming the delicate meat.
Freshly made tiramisu provides the ideal finish, with layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone that taste homemade because they are.
The dining room stays cozy without feeling cramped, and conversations flow easily over candlelit tables.
Servers take time to explain dishes and offer suggestions based on what the kitchen prepared fresh that day.
Parking can get tight during peak dinner hours, so arriving slightly early or later in the evening tends to work better.
