5 Indiana Buffets Everyone Talks About And 5 More You Should Try
Indiana might surprise you with its incredible buffet scene. From classic comfort food spreads to international cuisine adventures, the Hoosier State offers something for every appetite and budget.
I’ve gathered the most popular spots along with hidden gems that deserve your attention for your next dining adventure.
1. Das Dutchman Essenhaus
Amish country cooking at its finest awaits you here. Located in Middlebury, this beloved spot serves up heaping portions of fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and homemade noodles that taste like grandma made them.
The dessert bar alone could make you weep with joy. Fresh pies, cobblers, and pastries rotate daily, ensuring you’ll never eat the same sweet twice if you visit regularly.
2. MCL Restaurant and Bakery
Generations of Hoosiers grew up eating at MCL locations across the state. You’ll find classic American comfort food done right, from pot roast to mac and cheese that actually has flavor.
Their cafeteria-style setup lets you pick exactly what you want without waste. The bakery section features legendary pies and cinnamon rolls that people drive miles to grab before they sell out each afternoon.
3. Shapiro’s Delicatessen
Since 1905, this Indianapolis institution has perfected the art of deli food. Towering corned beef sandwiches and matzo ball soup bring people back week after week for that authentic taste.
The cafeteria line moves fast but offers generous portions of everything. Grab a tray and load up on pastrami, potato pancakes, and those incredible house-made pickles that crunch with every bite.
4. Golden Corral
Everyone knows this chain, but Indiana locations consistently rank among the cleanest and most well-stocked. You’ll encounter every food group imaginable, from carved meats to surprisingly fresh salad options.
Kids love the chocolate fountain and cotton candy machine. Adults appreciate the bourbon street chicken and yeast rolls that come out piping hot every few minutes throughout your meal.
5. Saffron Cafe
Fort Wayne’s best-kept secret serves authentic Indian cuisine that rivals anything in major cities. Fragrant curries, tender tandoori meats, and fluffy naan bread fill the steam tables with aromatic delights.
First-timers shouldn’t feel intimidated by unfamiliar dishes. The friendly staff happily explains each item and suggests combinations that work well together for a balanced, flavorful plate you’ll remember.
6. Blue Gate Restaurant
Shipshewana’s crown jewel offers a buffet experience that feels like a family reunion dinner. Real mashed potatoes, hand-breaded chicken, and vegetables cooked with actual butter make every bite worthwhile.
Arrive hungry because the selection changes with the seasons. Summer brings fresh corn and tomatoes, while fall features hearty stews and pumpkin everything that warms you from the inside out.
7. Taste of India
Indianapolis locals rave about this unassuming spot on the north side. Lunch buffets here cost less than fast food but deliver restaurant-quality flavors that change your perception of Indian cuisine.
Vegetarians will find plenty of options beyond the usual fare. The paneer dishes melt in your mouth, and the lentil dal provides protein-packed comfort that keeps you satisfied for hours afterward.
8. Ponderosa Steakhouse
This chain still thrives in Indiana when others have closed nationwide. Order a steak cooked to your preference, then hit the buffet for sides, salads, and that addictive cheese toast everyone remembers.
Sunday after church brings crowds, so plan accordingly. The soft-serve ice cream machine and hot fudge bar make it easy to create your own sundae masterpiece to finish the meal.
9. Mandarin House
Evansville residents consider this their go-to spot for Asian variety. Fresh sushi sits alongside classic American-Chinese favorites, giving you options whether you’re adventurous or prefer familiar orange chicken territory.
The hibachi grill lets you customize stir-fry combinations with your choice of proteins and vegetables. Watch the chef work their magic while your personalized dish sizzles to perfection right before your eyes.
10. Eiteljorg Museum Cafe
Museum visitors often overlook this downtown Indianapolis gem that serves Native American-inspired cuisine. Bison chili, fry bread, and Southwestern salads provide a unique buffet experience you won’t find anywhere else in the state.
Portions are reasonable and prices stay affordable for museum-goers. The quiet atmosphere makes it ideal for a peaceful lunch break between exploring the impressive art collections and cultural exhibits upstairs.
