14 Kentucky Pizza Spots Locals Swear Beat The Big Chains Hands Down

When you’re craving pizza in Kentucky, you don’t need to settle for the same old chain restaurant experience. Local pizzerias across the Bluegrass State are serving up incredible pies that put big-name competitors to shame.

From wood-fired classics to creative specialty slices, these homegrown favorites deliver flavor, quality, and that special touch only a local spot can provide.

1. Impellizzeri’s Pizza

Family recipes passed down through generations make every bite here taste like authentic Italian tradition. This Louisville gem has been feeding hungry locals since 1979, and their commitment to fresh ingredients shows in every slice.

You’ll find creative topping combinations alongside classic favorites, all baked in their signature ovens. The crust strikes that perfect balance between crispy edges and chewy center that keeps people coming back weekly.

2. Papalino’s Pizzeria

Walking into this Florence favorite feels like stepping into your Italian grandmother’s kitchen. The aroma of garlic and fresh basil hits you immediately, making your mouth water before you even order.

Their New York-style pies feature hand-tossed dough made daily and sauce that tastes like summer tomatoes. Locals rave about the generous cheese portions and perfectly charred crust that delivers authentic pizzeria flavor.

3. Goodfellas Pizzeria

Brooklyn-style pizza found its Kentucky home at this Lexington hotspot. The owners studied traditional New York techniques and brought that big-city flavor to the Bluegrass State with impressive results.

Their oversized slices fold perfectly in half, just like the real deal. The secret lies in their dough recipe and high-temperature ovens that create those signature crispy-yet-tender crusts everyone loves.

4. Joe’s Older Than Dirt

Don’t let the unusual name fool you—this Paducah institution serves seriously delicious pizza. Operating since the 1970s, they’ve perfected their recipes through decades of practice and customer feedback.

Their thick-crust pies come loaded with toppings that reach all the way to the edges. Locals especially love their special house blend of cheeses that melts into gooey perfection with every bake.

5. The Post

Housed in a beautifully restored historic building, this Louisville spot combines atmosphere with outstanding food. Their wood-fired pizzas feature seasonal ingredients sourced from local farms whenever possible.

Each pie gets cooked at extremely high temperatures, creating those coveted leopard-spotted crusts. The creative topping combinations change regularly, giving regulars something new to discover with each visit while maintaining crowd-pleasing classics.

6. Puccini’s Smiling Teeth

This quirky Lexington pizzeria proves that personality and quality can coexist beautifully. The playful name matches the fun atmosphere inside, where colorful artwork covers the walls and friendly staff treat everyone like family.

Their thin-crust pizzas bake quickly in blazing-hot ovens, emerging with perfectly blistered edges. Fresh mozzarella and house-made sauces elevate simple ingredients into something truly memorable.

7. Bearno’s Pizza

Louisville natives grew up with Bearno’s, and many still consider it the gold standard for local pizza. Multiple locations across the city mean you’re never far from their famous pies.

Their signature crust recipe remains a closely guarded secret that competitors can’t quite replicate. Generous portions and consistent quality explain why families choose this spot for celebrations, game nights, and casual Tuesday dinners alike.

8. Bella Notte

Upscale doesn’t mean stuffy at this Lexington favorite where pizza shares the menu with refined Italian dishes. The chef treats pizza-making as an art form, carefully selecting premium ingredients for each creation.

Their thin, crispy crusts provide the perfect canvas for sophisticated topping combinations you won’t find elsewhere. Wine pairings complement the pies beautifully, making dinner here feel special without breaking the bank.

9. Mellow Mushroom Bowling Green

Funky artwork and creative pizzas make this Bowling Green location stand out from typical chain experiences. The eclectic decor creates an energetic vibe that appeals to college students and families equally.

Stone-baked crusts come in multiple styles, from thin and crispy to thick and doughy. Their extensive topping selection includes adventurous options like tempeh and jerk chicken alongside traditional pepperoni and mushrooms.

10. Wick’s Pizza Parlor

Consistency and reliability define this Louisville mini-chain that locals trust for satisfying pizza every single time. Their no-frills approach focuses on doing the basics exceptionally well rather than chasing trendy gimmicks.

Hand-stretched dough gets topped with quality ingredients and baked until golden brown. The result is straightforward, delicious pizza that hits the spot whether you’re feeding hungry kids or hosting game day parties.

11. Danny Mac’s Pizza

This Covington neighborhood spot has earned devoted fans through simple excellence and genuine hospitality. Regulars know the staff by name, and newcomers quickly understand why people drive across town for these pies.

Their sauce balances tangy and sweet perfectly, complementing rather than overpowering the other ingredients. Generous cheese coverage and properly cooked toppings show attention to detail that separates good pizza from great.

12. Pies & Pints

Craft beer and creative pizzas pair beautifully at this Lexington establishment that takes both seriously. The extensive tap list features local breweries alongside national favorites, giving beer enthusiasts plenty to explore.

Their artisan pies push boundaries with unexpected ingredient combinations that somehow work perfectly together. From fig and prosciutto to Thai chicken, each pizza tells a flavor story that keeps adventurous eaters coming back.

13. Parlour Pizza Bar

Industrial-chic decor meets serious pizza craftsmanship at this Louisville hotspot popular with young professionals. The open kitchen lets you watch skilled pizza makers stretch dough and build each pie with practiced precision.

Their menu rotates seasonally, incorporating fresh produce at peak flavor. The bar program is equally impressive, offering cocktails and wines that complement the food beautifully for a complete dining experience.

14. DiOrio’s Pizza & Pub

Sports fans and pizza lovers unite at this Bowling Green favorite that combines great food with a lively atmosphere. Multiple TVs ensure you never miss important games while enjoying your meal.

Their pub-style pizzas feature hearty toppings and substantial crusts that satisfy serious appetites. The casual environment welcomes everyone from solo diners grabbing a quick slice to large groups celebrating victories together over shared pies.