10 Maine Italian Sub Shops That’ll Satisfy Every Craving
A freshly baked roll splits open to reveal layers of deli meats, sharp cheese, and tangy oil and vinegar soaking into the bread just right. Each bite balances salt, crunch, and comfort – a flavor born from tradition and perfected over time.
Across Maine, Italian sub shops keep that tradition alive, stacking ingredients with care and pride. From Portland to Bangor, these sandwiches reflect the state’s love for simple food done with heart.
1. Amato’s
A Maine legend since 1902, this spot practically invented the Italian sandwich as locals know it. Generations of families have grown up ordering the same combination of ham, cheese, and fresh vegetables tucked into soft rolls.
With locations across the state, grabbing one on a road trip or lunch break feels like a tasty tradition. The simplicity and quality keep people coming back year after year.
2. Sam’s Italian Foods
Family recipes and time-tested methods make every bite here feel authentic. The deli counter bustles with regulars who know exactly what they want, and newcomers quickly become fans.
Freshly sliced meats and house-made touches give each sandwich character. Stopping by means joining a community that values flavor, quality, and a welcoming atmosphere where everyone feels at home.
3. DiPietro’s Market
Walking into this Maine market feels like stepping into a slice of Italy right in Portland. Shelves lined with imported olive oils, pastas, and specialty ingredients surround the deli counter where subs are crafted with care.
Each sandwich showcases premium ingredients and attention to detail. It’s a neighborhood gem where food lovers gather for authentic flavors and friendly conversation.
4. George’s Sandwich Shop
This unassuming shop has been feeding Biddeford for decades, earning loyal fans who swear by the generous portions. The counter service is quick, but the flavors are never rushed.
Piled high with meats, cheese, and all the toppings, each sub feels like a hearty meal. It’s the kind of place where regulars know the staff by name and newcomers leave planning their next visit.
5. Lisa’s Pizza
Pizza might be the main draw, but the Italian subs here in Maine deserve just as much attention. Made with the same commitment to flavor, they’re loaded with meats, cheese, and crisp vegetables.
Ordering for a group? Grab a few subs alongside a couple of pies for a meal everyone will enjoy. It’s casual, affordable, and consistently delicious.
6. Harvest Moon Deli
Fresh, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible set this deli apart from the rest. Each Italian sub feels thoughtfully assembled, with bright flavors and textures that complement each other beautifully.
The welcoming atmosphere and multiple locations make it easy to stop by no matter where travels take you. It’s a reliable choice for a wholesome, flavorful meal any day of the week.
7. Angelo’s Pizzeria
Known for pizza, this Maine spot also turns out Italian subs that rival any dedicated deli. The same care that goes into every pie extends to the sandwiches, with fresh ingredients and generous portions.
Families stop by for dinner, grabbing subs alongside slices in a lively, casual atmosphere. It’s a neighborhood staple where good food and friendly faces make every visit feel special.
8. Mancini’s Italian Deli
Authentic recipes passed down through generations define this deli’s approach to Italian subs. Every ingredient is chosen carefully, from the bread to the final drizzle of oil and vinegar.
The cozy space invites lingering, though many grab their subs to go. Either way, the flavors transport taste buds straight to an Italian kitchen where tradition and quality matter most.
9. Corsetti’s
Decades of serving the community have made this Maine spot a trusted name for Italian subs. The recipes haven’t changed much over the years, and that’s exactly how loyal customers like it.
Walking in feels like visiting an old friend who knows just what you need. The subs are generous, flavorful, and made with the kind of pride that keeps traditions alive.
10. Moran’s Market
A neighborhood favorite, this market deli serves up Italian subs that hit all the right notes. Fresh bread, quality meats, and just the right amount of toppings create a balanced, satisfying bite every time.
Stopping by feels like visiting a corner of Portland where everyone knows each other. The relaxed pace and friendly service make lunch feel less like an errand and more like a treat.
