8 Must-Try Florida Key Lime Pie Spots That Perfectly Balance Tart And Creamy
Florida’s signature dessert, key lime pie, combines tangy citrus with sweet creaminess in a way that makes taste buds dance.
The perfect slice balances tartness with just enough sweetness, all atop a buttery graham cracker crust. From the Florida Keys to unexpected spots across the Sunshine State, these eight destinations serve up the most memorable versions of this iconic treat.
1. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe – Key West
Green umbrellas and cheerful vibes welcome pie-seekers to this Florida Keys institution. The pies here pack a bold citrus punch that’ll make your cheeks pucker with delight.
What makes Kermit’s special? Their innovative presentations! Try their chocolate-dipped pie on a stick for a walking treat or take home a whole pie with mile-high meringue.
2. The Fish House – Key Largo
Nestled among mangroves, this seafood haven surprises guests with a finale worth saving room for. Their key lime pie features an extra-thick graham cracker crust that crumbles perfectly with each forkful.
Locals recommend finishing a seafood feast with their signature slice. The contrast between the rich, citrusy filling and the substantial crust creates pie perfection.
3. Old Town Bakery – Key West
Morning aromas of fresh-baked goods fill this charming corner bakery tucked away on a quiet street. Their key lime pie stands out with a silky texture that melts instantly on your tongue.
Regulars pair a slice with strong Cuban coffee for the ultimate Key West experience. The refreshing tartness cuts through the coffee’s richness, creating flavor harmony you’ll remember long after vacation ends.
4. Key Lime Pie Company – Key West
Yellow and green décor hints at the citrus treasures awaiting inside this dedicated pie shop. Their classic version nails the sweet-tart balance that defines great key lime pie.
Can’t stay in Florida forever? No problem! They ship nationwide, bringing sunshine to your doorstep. Each bite delivers authentic Keys flavor without the airfare.
5. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen – Key Largo
License plates cover the walls at this beloved roadside stop where hungry travelers have been refueling since 1976. Their pie arrives cool and creamy, topped with a cloud of fresh whipped cream that slowly melts into the filling.
Road-trippers often plan their Keys journey around a stop here. The first bite explains why; it’s the perfect blend of tangy and sweet that embodies Florida sunshine.
6. Joe’s Stone Crab – Miami Beach
White tablecloths and bow-tied waiters set the scene at this century-old institution where celebrities and locals alike finish meals with legendary key lime pie. The secret? A perfect ratio of condensed milk to lime juice.
While famous for stone crabs, their pie has developed its own following. Chilled to perfection, each slice arrives with a simple dollop of whipped cream that complements without overwhelming.
7. Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village – Sarasota
“Amish key lime pie?” visitors often ask with raised eyebrows. One taste converts the skeptics! This unexpected gem creates pies with loving attention to detail that rivals any Keys establishment.
Family recipes and fresh ingredients make the difference here. The filling achieves that elusive perfect consistency, firm enough to hold its shape when cut, yet creamy enough to melt in your mouth.
8. Pineapple Point Bakery – Fort Lauderdale
Tucked away on a palm-lined street, this neighborhood bakery doesn’t advertise – their pie speaks for itself. Small-batch production ensures each pie receives careful attention from mixing to baking.
The result? A custard-like texture with pronounced lime flavor that’s neither too sweet nor too tart. Locals guard this secret spot jealously, but now you’re in on the delicious discovery.
