11 New Hampshire Pizza Spots Worth Every Mile
New Hampshire just claimed the crown as America’s top pizza destination, and locals have known this secret for years.
With more pizzerias per capita than almost anywhere else and prices that won’t empty wallets, the Granite State delivers slice after perfect slice.
From wood-fired Neapolitan pies to family recipes passed down through generations, these pizza spots turn simple ingredients into unforgettable meals that keep people coming back for more.
1. Mary’s Pizza
Four generations have perfected the recipe at this Gorham institution, where homemade dough and a secret cheese blend create pizza that tastes like coming home.
You’ll find this beloved spot at 9 Cascade Flats, Gorham, NH 03581, serving pies that have earned top rankings in countless Best Pizza polls across the state.
The dough rises slowly each morning, developing flavors that quick-rise versions can never match, while the proprietary cheese mixture melts into golden perfection that stretches with every bite.
Walking through the door means entering a space where locals greet each other by name and newcomers quickly become regulars.
Photos covering the walls tell decades of community stories, from Little League championships to anniversary celebrations, all fueled by Mary’s legendary slices.
The menu keeps things straightforward with classic toppings done exceptionally well rather than chasing trendy combinations.
Pepperoni curls into crispy cups, vegetables arrive fresh-cut, and the sauce strikes that elusive balance between sweet and tangy.
Service feels like family, with staff remembering orders and asking about kids by name.
Lines form during dinner rushes, but the kitchen moves efficiently without sacrificing quality on a single pie.
2. Tilton House Of Pizza
Generous doesn’t begin to describe the toppings here, where every order arrives piled high enough to satisfy the hungriest appetites and leave leftovers for tomorrow.
Find this local favorite at 298 Main St, Tilton, NH 03276, where friendly service and abundance create a winning combination that keeps tables full year-round.
The philosophy centers on giving customers more than expected, from extra cheese that blankets every inch to pepperoni layered so thick it creates delicious grease puddles that true pizza lovers cherish.
The casual atmosphere welcomes families with kids fresh from soccer practice and couples seeking comfort food after long workdays.
Booths offer cozy corners for conversation while larger tables accommodate groups celebrating everything from birthdays to Friday simply being Friday.
Beyond pizza, the menu stretches into Greek specialties and hefty subs, but most folks come for those gloriously overloaded pies.
Crust holds up admirably under all that weight, staying crisp on the bottom while providing enough chew to feel substantial.
Staff treats everyone like neighbors, checking in without hovering and keeping drinks filled throughout meals.
Prices remain remarkably reasonable considering how much food ends up on each plate, making this spot perfect for feeding hungry crews without breaking budgets.
3. La Festa Brick & Brew
Creativity meets tradition in Dover, where brick ovens turn out inventive pizzas that push boundaries while respecting the fundamentals that make great pies work.
Located at 300 Central Ave, Dover, NH 03820, this establishment combines artisan pizza-making with a carefully curated beer selection that elevates the entire dining experience.
The menu ventures beyond standard offerings with combinations like fig and prosciutto or butternut squash with sage, yet classic Margheritas still shine with simple perfection.
Brick ovens impart that distinctive char and smoky depth that regular ovens simply cannot replicate, while high heat creates crusts with ideal texture contrasts.
Toppings arrive fresh and thoughtfully balanced, never overwhelming the palate with too many competing flavors on a single pie.
The atmosphere leans contemporary casual, with exposed brick walls and warm wood accents creating spaces equally suited for date nights or family gatherings.
Craft beer taps rotate regularly, offering local brews alongside regional favorites that pair beautifully with various pizza styles.
Service strikes a nice balance between knowledgeable and approachable, with servers happy to suggest pairings without sounding pretentious.
Weekend evenings bring crowds, so reservations help avoid waits, though the bar area welcomes walk-ins seeking quicker seating.
4. The Community Oven
Fresh ingredients and wood-fired technique come together at two locations that have become gathering spots where neighbors connect over exceptional pizza.
Visit 845 Lafayette Rd, Hampton, NH 03842 to experience pies that showcase local farms and seasonal bounty.
The name reflects a genuine philosophy about creating spaces where communities build connections, with communal tables encouraging conversation between strangers who leave as friends.
Wood-fired ovens produce crusts with those coveted charred bubbles and chewy interiors that make each bite interesting.
Toppings change with seasons, featuring spring asparagus, summer tomatoes, fall squash, and winter greens that keep the menu feeling alive and responsive to what grows best right now.
Both locations maintain warm, inviting atmospheres with open kitchens that let diners watch pizzas being assembled and fired.
The crackling flames and aromatic smoke create multisensory experiences that engage more than just taste buds.
Staff radiates genuine enthusiasm about the food, often sharing stories about local farms or explaining why certain toppings pair beautifully.
Prices reflect the quality ingredients without climbing into intimidating territory, making regular visits feasible rather than special-occasion-only splurges.
5. Britt’s Pizzeria
Consistency reaches an art form at this Hampton favorite, where every pizza emerges from the oven exactly as it should, time after time, year after year.
Located at 888 Lafayette Rd, Hampton, NH 03842, this pizzeria has earned fierce loyalty by never cutting corners or having off nights that disappoint regulars.
The secret lies in rigorous attention to detail, from dough that gets proper proofing time to sauce that maintains the same balanced flavor profile batch after batch.
Locals know they can order their usual without worry, confident that tonight’s pizza will taste just as perfect as last month’s or last year’s.
That reliability might sound boring, but achieving it requires skill and dedication that many flashier places lack.
The space feels comfortably worn-in, with familiar faces behind the counter and booths that have hosted countless family dinners.
Nothing about the décor tries too hard or follows trendy design schemes, creating an atmosphere that feels honest and unpretentious.
Service moves efficiently during rushes while maintaining friendly interactions that make customers feel valued rather than rushed.
Takeout orders stay organized even when the phone rings constantly, and pickup times prove reliably accurate for those grabbing dinner on the way home.
6. Nana’s Kitchen & Pizzeria
Newcomers sometimes bring the freshest energy, and this Auburn spot quickly became a local favorite by combining great food with an atmosphere that feels like visiting family.
Find this gem at 15 Dartmouth Dr, Auburn, NH 03032, where the menu extends beyond pizza into Italian comfort food that all tastes made-with-love delicious.
The pizzas themselves strike that sweet spot between traditional and interesting, offering enough variety to keep meals exciting without overwhelming indecisive diners with too many choices.
What sets this place apart is the genuine warmth that permeates every interaction, from the greeting at the door to the goodbye as guests leave.
The name Nana’s wasn’t chosen randomly – it reflects a desire to recreate that feeling of eating at grandmother’s house where everyone gets fed well and sent home happy.
Décor mixes cozy touches with practical restaurant functionality, creating spaces that feel personal without seeming cluttered.
Families with children find welcoming attitudes rather than annoyed glances, while couples enjoy intimate corners perfect for quieter conversations.
The kitchen clearly takes pride in what leaves the pass, with pizzas arriving hot and properly constructed.
Prices remain accessible for regular dining rather than occasional treats, helping explain how this newer spot built such devoted followings so quickly.
7. The Shannon Door
Mountain town charm meets excellent thin-crust pizza at this Jackson pub where après-ski crowds and summer hikers both find exactly what they’re craving.
Located at 9 Spancil Hill Rd, Jackson, NH 03846, this establishment serves pizzas with crackling-crisp crusts that provide the perfect vehicle for creative toppings and classic combinations alike.
The thin style means you can actually taste the interplay between crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings rather than just filling up on bread.
Visiting after a day on the slopes or trails makes every bite taste even better, though the pizza stands up perfectly well without the hunger earned through outdoor adventures.
The pub atmosphere brings lively energy without becoming overwhelmingly loud, with wooden beams and mountain-lodge touches creating cozy surroundings.
Beyond pizza, the full menu offers pub fare and local beers that round out satisfying meals.
The location makes this spot particularly convenient for those staying in the Mount Washington Valley, providing quality dining without requiring drives to larger towns.
Service understands the tourist-and-local mix, treating everyone with equal friendliness whether they’re first-timers or weekly regulars.
Weekend evenings get busy during peak seasons, but the energy feels festive rather than stressful, with everyone relaxing after days spent enjoying New Hampshire’s outdoor offerings.
8. Pizza Bella Family Restaurant
Upscale Italian dining meets approachable pizza perfection at this Hooksett restaurant where the full menu impresses but the pies steal the show.
Visit 178 State Rte 101, Bedford, NH 03110, to experience pizzas that benefit from a kitchen trained in broader Italian cuisine, bringing techniques and flavor understanding that elevate simple pies into memorable meals.
The crust achieves that ideal balance between substantial and light, with enough structure to hold toppings while remaining easy to eat without feeling heavy.
Sauce tastes bright and fresh rather than overly sweet or acidic, while cheese quality clearly matters to whoever orders ingredients.
Toppings range from traditional to more sophisticated options that reflect the restaurant’s overall Italian focus.
The atmosphere leans more toward sit-down dinner than quick pizza joint, with table service and décor that creates pleasant surroundings for lingering over meals.
This makes the spot particularly nice for occasions that deserve something beyond paper plates and plastic cups.
Servers demonstrate knowledge about both the pizza menu and broader Italian offerings, helping guests navigate choices without being pushy.
Prices reflect the elevated experience without reaching levels that require second mortgages, positioning this as a solid choice for treating yourself without extreme splurging.
9. Shorty’s Mexican Roadhouse
Sometimes the best pizza comes from unexpected places, and this Mexican roadhouse proves that fusion done right creates exciting new favorites rather than confused messes.
With locations including 1050 Bicentennial Dr, Manchester, NH 03104, this spot takes pizza in directions that purists might question but adventurous eaters absolutely love.
Think toppings like seasoned ground beef, jalapeños, cilantro, and even nacho cheese that somehow work beautifully together on pizza dough.
The roadhouse atmosphere brings vibrant colors, casual energy, and a fun-loving vibe that makes meals feel like mini-celebrations.
Margaritas flow alongside pizza orders, creating pairings that traditional Italian spots would never imagine but that taste surprisingly perfect together.
What makes these pizzas work is the kitchen’s understanding of flavor balance – the combinations might sound wild but they’re carefully constructed to complement rather than clash.
Traditional pizza lovers can still find familiar options, though trying something adventurous often leads to pleasant surprises.
Service matches the upbeat atmosphere with friendly efficiency and genuine smiles.
Families find welcoming environments while groups of friends enjoy the party-ready energy, making this spot versatile for different occasions and moods when pizza cravings strike with a side of adventure.
10. Lui Lui
Portsmouth’s Italian dining scene reaches impressive heights at this intimate restaurant where pizza shares menu space with sophisticated Italian dishes but never plays second fiddle.
Located at 8 Glen Rd #11, West Lebanon, NH 03784, this establishment brings serious Italian credentials to every pie, using imported ingredients and traditional techniques that honor pizza’s Neapolitan roots.
The oven temperature, dough hydration, and timing all receive the attention that separates good pizza from transcendent experiences.
Each pizza arrives as a study in simplicity done right – quality ingredients need little embellishment when they’re this good.
The crust blisters and chars in all the right places, cheese melts into creamy perfection, and toppings taste like themselves rather than generic versions.
The intimate setting creates romantic atmospheres perfect for date nights or special celebrations, with dim lighting and Italian music setting sophisticated moods.
Reservations become essential during weekends when Portsmouth’s dining scene attracts crowds from throughout the Seacoast region.
Service demonstrates deep knowledge about Italian food traditions, answering questions and making recommendations with authority earned through genuine expertise.
Prices reflect the downtown Portsmouth location and ingredient quality, positioning this as a special-occasion spot rather than weekly casual dining, though the pizza quality justifies every dollar spent.
11. 900 Degrees Neapolitan Pizzeria
Winning the Best NH Pizza title for 13 years straight takes serious dedication to craft, and this Manchester spot proves it every single day.
Located at 50 Dow St, Manchester, NH 03101 this pizzeria brings authentic Neapolitan tradition to New England with blazing wood-fired ovens that reach perfect temperatures for that signature leopard-spotted crust.
The secret lies in imported Italian flour, San Marzano tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella that melts into creamy pools across each pie.
Every pizza emerges from the oven with blistered edges and a tender center that folds beautifully without getting soggy.
The menu offers classic Margherita alongside creative seasonal options that change with what’s freshest at local markets.
Dining here feels like stepping into a Naples trattoria, with warm lighting and the intoxicating aroma of wood smoke mingling with basil and garlic.
Whether grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for dinner with friends, the atmosphere stays lively without being overwhelming.
Servers know their pies inside out and happily guide newcomers through the menu.
The wait during peak hours can stretch a bit, but watching pizzaiolos work their magic makes time fly faster than expected.
