New Jersey Cafés Where Fresh, Homemade Pie Is The Star Of The Menu

There’s something magical about a slice of pie that just came out of the oven, with its flaky crust and perfectly sweet filling. New Jersey is home to some incredible cafés where pie isn’t just a dessert, it’s the main event.

Whether you’re craving fruity classics or creative new flavors, these spots serve up homemade goodness that’ll make your taste buds dance.

1. Crema In Jersey City

This place takes pie seriously, and I mean seriously. Crema in Jersey City is a cozy café known for its expertly crafted coffee and delightful homemade treats, including some of the best pies in the area.

This charming spot has become a local favorite, offering a warm atmosphere that invites customers to relax and enjoy delicious offerings from pastries to savory bites. Their pies, made fresh daily, stand out for their flaky crusts and rich fillings, with flavors like classic apple, seasonal fruit, and creamy lemon meringue.

Crema’s inviting vibe and focus on quality ingredients make it a must-visit destination for dessert lovers and coffee enthusiasts alike. The café’s attention to detail in both their drinks and baked goods sets it apart as a jewel in Jersey City.

2. Penza’s Pies At The Red Barn Café

Nestled in the heart of Hammonton, Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn Café offers a nostalgic escape with its rustic charm. The café is renowned for its scrumptious homemade pies, crafted with love and local ingredients. Visitors often return for the signature blueberry pie, a sweet nod to the town’s famous harvest.

The welcoming atmosphere invites patrons to linger over a slice and coffee, making it a beloved community spot. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Penza’s promises a pie experience worth savoring.

Generations have cherished this spot, where tradition meets taste in every bite.

3. Pie Lady Café

Tucked away in Moorestown, Pie Lady Café is a quaint spot with a passion for perfection. Known for its diverse selection of fruit pies, each slice is a celebration of flavor and heritage. The café’s cozy interior and friendly staff create a welcoming vibe.

Here, pies are more than just dessert, they’re an ode to time-honored recipes handed down through generations. Seasonal ingredients ensure that every bite bursts with freshness.

The Pie Lady herself is often seen chatting with customers, sharing stories behind each creation, making every visit a personal affair.

4. The Pie Store

The Pie Store in Montclair is a slice of England in New Jersey. Specializing in savory and sweet pies, this quaint bakery combines classic British recipes with local flair. Steak and ale or apple crumble, there’s something for every palate.

Warm, welcoming, and filled with delightful aromas, it’s a place that feels like home. Regulars rave about their rich, buttery crusts and hearty fillings.

Owned by a British expat, it’s a genuine taste of the UK, with every pie crafted with authenticity and care. It’s a perfect blend of comfort and tradition.

5. Lillipies Bakery

Lillipies Bakery in Princeton is a treasure trove for pie enthusiasts. Known for its small-batch creations, each pie is a masterpiece of flavor and texture. The bakery’s commitment to quality is evident in every carefully crafted slice.

From classic apple to inventive seasonal specialties, the pies here are a delight to the senses. The modern, airy space encourages lingering, with an open kitchen providing a glimpse into the pie-making artistry.

Owner Jen Carson’s dedication to her craft shines through, making Lillipies a must-visit for dessert devotees.

6. Magpie Bakery

In the heart of Asbury Park, Magpie Bakery is a feast for the eyes and the taste buds. With a whimsical interior that mirrors the playfulness of its pie offerings, it’s a place where creativity meets culinary excellence.

The pies range from traditional favorites to unique house specialties, each as delightful as the last. The lively atmosphere is matched only by the bold flavors found in every slice.

Owner and chef, Kati Lacker, infuses each pie with passion and innovation, inviting patrons to enjoy both the ambiance and the artistry of her creations.

7. Terhune Orchards

Terhune Orchards in Princeton is a gem that combines the freshness of farm-to-table ingredients with the warmth of homemade pies. Surrounded by lush orchards, this spot offers pies that celebrate the bounty of the season.

The farm store is bustling with locals and visitors eager to taste the famed apple pies and cider donuts. Each pie is a testament to Terhune’s commitment to quality and tradition.

Family-owned for over 40 years, Terhune Orchards remains a beloved destination for those seeking a genuine taste of New Jersey’s harvest.

8. Pure Love Pies

Pure Love Pies in Montclair is more than a bakery, it’s a celebration of flavors that feed the soul. Known for its Southern-inspired creations, the café offers pies that are as comforting as they are delicious.

Signature favorites like sweet potato and pecan pie draw crowds eager for a taste of home. The bakery’s inviting atmosphere and friendly service make every visit feel special.

Owned by Leslie Ann Henry, Pure Love Pies is a testament to her dedication to sharing warmth and joy through her delicious confections.

9. Hainesville General Store

Hainesville General Store offers more than just a pie, it’s a slice of history. Nestled in the small town of Hainesville, this store is a beloved landmark imbued with rustic charm.

The homemade pies here are crafted with recipes that have been cherished for generations. Each bite is a journey through time, filled with nostalgia and flavor.

Locals and travelers alike find themselves drawn to this quaint spot, where the past and present blend seamlessly, making every pie a delicious reminder of simpler times.

10. Delicious Orchards

Delicious Orchards in Colts Neck is a bustling hub of fresh produce and baked goods. Their pies, however, are the true stars of the show. Made with ingredients from their own orchards, each pie is fresh and full of flavor.

The atmosphere is vibrant and welcoming, with families and friends gathering to enjoy the delights on offer. Whether it’s a classic apple or a seasonal creation, each pie is crafted with care.

As frequent visitors can attest, there’s something truly special about enjoying a slice amidst the lively ambiance of this cherished community spot.

11. Bean Pie Café

In Newark, Bean Pie Café is a unique spot where the humble bean pie reigns supreme. This café offers a modern twist on a traditional favorite, appealing to both locals and newcomers alike.

The pies are rich and flavorful, offering a delicious alternative to more conventional fruit pies. The café’s modern setting provides a comfortable spot to enjoy a slice.

Owner Salaam Ismial’s dedication to his craft shines through, making Bean Pie Café a must-visit for those seeking something a little different and distinctly delicious.