New Jersey Friday Fish Fry Spots Families Love Every Season

Friday night means one thing in New Jersey: crispy fried fish that brings families together around the table. From coastal towns to inland communities, restaurants across the Garden State serve up golden-brown fillets that keep locals coming back week after week.

Whether you’re craving traditional recipes or unique twists on this beloved tradition, these spots deliver delicious meals your whole family will enjoy.

1. Roy’s Fish Fry – Irvington

Crispy batter meets perfectly moist fish at this multi-location legend that locals can’t stop talking about. Every bite delivers that satisfying crunch you crave, followed by tender, flaky goodness inside.

Families appreciate the consistent quality that makes Roy’s a Friday night staple. The portions are generous enough to satisfy even the hungriest appetites, and the prices won’t break your budget.

2. Monte’s Fish Fry – Toms River

Walking through the door feels like coming home because the owners actually remember your name and your usual order. This family-run gem serves fish so tender it practically melts on your tongue.

The secret blend of seasonings creates a flavor profile you won’t find anywhere else in the state. Kids love the welcoming atmosphere, and parents appreciate the genuine hospitality that makes every visit special.

3. Crockett’s Fish Fry – Montclair

Owner Frank Crockett hand-picks each day’s catch, ensuring only the freshest fish makes it to your plate. The light cornmeal coating provides a delicate crunch without overwhelming the natural flavors.

Hidden away from the main streets, this spot rewards those who seek it out with exceptional quality. Frank’s personal touch shows in every detail, from the seasoning to the cooking time, creating perfection in every serving.

4. Two Fish Five Loaves – Union

Community spirit fills this welcoming spot where neighbors gather for Friday fish and friendly conversation. The batter stays remarkably crispy even after sitting for a few minutes, which is perfect for families who eat at different paces.

Don’t skip the hush puppies—they’re fluffy inside with a golden exterior that complements the fish beautifully. The portions are thoughtfully sized for sharing, making it easy to sample everything on the menu.

5. Mr. Shrimp Seafood – Belmar

Salt air mingles with the irresistible aroma of perfectly fried seafood at this coastal treasure near the beach. The location alone makes it worth the trip, especially when you can grab your meal and head to the boardwalk.

Fresh catches arrive daily from local fishermen, guaranteeing quality that landlocked restaurants simply can’t match. Your kids will love the casual vibe, and you’ll appreciate the authentic shore town experience that comes with every order.

6. Mike’s Seafood & Dock Restaurant – Sea Isle City

Waterfront views provide the perfect backdrop for enjoying fish that tastes like it jumped straight from the ocean onto your fork. Mike’s signature seasoning blend creates a distinctive flavor that keeps vacationers and locals returning year after year.

The dock location means you’re eating fish at peak freshness, often caught the same morning. Sunset dinners here become cherished family memories, combining great food with stunning scenery.

7. Bahrs Restaurant & Marina – Highlands

Since 1917, this historic establishment has been serving classic fish and chips to generations of New Jersey families. Panoramic water views stretch across the horizon, creating an atmosphere that’s both nostalgic and timeless.

The recipe hasn’t changed much over the decades because when something’s this good, you don’t mess with success. Grandparents love sharing their childhood memories here while creating new ones with their grandchildren.

8. Keyport Fishery – Keyport

Half fish market, half casual eatery, this unique spot lets you watch your dinner being selected from the display case. The combination ensures absolute freshness because there’s literally no middleman between the catch and your table.

Knowledgeable staff can answer questions about where each fish came from and how it was caught. Educational and delicious, it’s a fantastic way to teach kids about sustainable seafood while enjoying an amazing meal.

9. The Committed Pig – Morristown

Upscale comfort food meets Friday fish fry tradition at this gastropub that elevates the classic dish. Creative sides and craft beverages make this spot perfect for parents who want something beyond the standard fish fry experience.

The elevated atmosphere doesn’t mean stuffy—families feel completely welcome here. Kids enjoy the fun menu options while adults appreciate the thoughtful preparation and quality ingredients that set this place apart from typical fry joints.

10. Hoffman’s Ice Cream – Point Pleasant Beach

Yes, they’re famous for ice cream, but their Friday fish fry is a well-kept secret among locals. The combination of excellent fried fish followed by world-class ice cream makes for an unbeatable family outing.

Located steps from the beach, you can plan an entire evening around dinner and dessert here. The casual counter service keeps things moving quickly, which is perfect when you have excited kids ready to hit the boardwalk afterward.

11. The Cabin – Howell

Rustic charm and hearty portions define this landlocked favorite that proves you don’t need oceanfront property to serve amazing fish. The cozy interior features wood paneling and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like a countryside retreat.

Families love the relaxed pace and the fact that nobody rushes you through your meal. The fish arrives hot and perfectly seasoned, with sides that taste homemade because they actually are.

12. Schneider’s – Avon-by-the-Sea

German-American heritage influences the fish preparation at this shore town institution, adding unique flavors to traditional fry recipes. The crispy exterior gives way to incredibly moist fish that’s been seasoned with Old World expertise.

The multigenerational crowd proves this place appeals to everyone from toddlers to great-grandparents. Outdoor seating during warmer months lets you enjoy the sea breeze while savoring your meal, creating the perfect Friday evening experience.

13. Spike’s Fish Market – Point Pleasant Beach

Market-fresh fish gets fried to order at this no-frills spot where quality speaks louder than fancy decor. What you see is what you get: honest, delicious seafood prepared simply and perfectly.

The lack of pretension means affordable prices that let families eat well without overspending. Regulars know to arrive early on Fridays because word has spread about how good the fish is, and lines can form quickly during peak hours.

14. Barnacle Bill’s – Rumson

Nautical decor and friendly service create a fun atmosphere that kids absolutely adore while parents enjoy consistently excellent fish. The menu offers variety beyond just fish, making it easy to accommodate picky eaters in your group.

Located in an upscale area, the prices reflect the neighborhood, but the portions and quality justify the cost. The attention to detail in preparation shows that the kitchen takes pride in every plate that goes out.

15. The Shrimp Box – Point Pleasant Beach

Waterfront dining reaches its peak at this iconic restaurant where the fish tastes as good as the views look. The menu features multiple fish options, letting everyone in your family choose their favorite variety.

The upstairs deck provides spectacular sunset views that transform dinner into a special occasion. Reservations are recommended for Fridays because locals and visitors alike flock here for the unbeatable combination of location, atmosphere, and perfectly fried seafood.