13 New York Grocery Stores Known For Fresh Chestnuts And Harvest Treats

Fall in New York brings crisp air, colorful leaves, and the delicious aroma of roasted chestnuts on street corners. Finding the freshest chestnuts and seasonal harvest treats can turn any autumn meal into something special.

Whether shopping in the city or exploring upstate, these grocery stores offer the best seasonal produce and ingredients to celebrate the harvest season.

1. Agata & Valentina – New York

Located on the Upper East Side, this European-style market brings Old World charm to neighborhood shopping. The produce section shines during autumn with carefully selected chestnuts imported from Italy and France.

Staff members often roast samples on weekends, filling the store with that irresistible nutty aroma. Alongside chestnuts, shoppers find heirloom squashes, fresh cranberries, and specialty items perfect for holiday cooking.

2. Chestnut Supermarket – Brooklyn

Right in the heart of Brooklyn, this aptly named store lives up to its reputation for quality nuts and seasonal goods. Chestnut varieties rotate throughout fall, from sweet Chinese chestnuts to robust American types.

The market also stocks apple cider, pumpkins, and root vegetables that pair beautifully with roasted chestnuts. Friendly service and reasonable prices keep locals coming back season after season.

3. All Fresh Supermarket – Brooklyn

Fresh produce takes center stage at this Brooklyn favorite, where quality matters more than fancy packaging. During harvest season, chestnut bins overflow with plump, glossy nuts ready for roasting or cooking.

The store sources from regional farms when possible, ensuring maximum freshness. Shoppers appreciate the variety of fall produce, from Brussels sprouts still on the stalk to multiple types of winter squash.

4. Butterfield Market – New York

This Upper East Side gem caters to discerning shoppers who value quality above all else. Butterfield’s chestnut selection includes both raw nuts for home roasting and pre-roasted varieties for instant enjoyment.

The gourmet grocery also offers chestnut flour, preserved chestnuts, and recipe cards for seasonal dishes. Everything from the lighting to the presentation creates an upscale shopping experience worth savoring.

5. Gristedes – New York

A New York institution since 1891, Gristedes stores dot Manhattan neighborhoods with reliable service and seasonal selections. Come autumn, multiple locations stock fresh chestnuts alongside traditional holiday ingredients.

Prices remain competitive compared to specialty markets, making seasonal cooking accessible to everyone. The chain’s longevity speaks to its ability to adapt while maintaining neighborhood grocery store charm and convenience.

6. 4th Street Food Co-Op – New York

Community ownership means this East Village co-op prioritizes local sourcing and organic options whenever available. Members and non-members alike can purchase chestnuts from regional growers during peak season.

The co-op’s commitment to sustainability shows in every department, from bulk bins to compostable packaging. Shopping here feels less like a transaction and more like supporting neighbors and local agriculture together.

7. The Market Place – Brooklyn

Brooklyn Heights residents treasure this neighborhood market for its carefully curated selection and personal service. Fall brings chestnuts alongside other seasonal treasures like fresh figs, persimmons, and quince.

The knowledgeable staff can recommend preparation methods and suggest complementary ingredients for autumn recipes. Small batch products and artisanal finds make every visit feel like discovering something special around the corner.

8. Finger Lakes Nut Farm – Locke

Driving to this Central New York farm becomes part of the autumn experience itself. The family operation grows and processes chestnuts right on the property, ensuring unbeatable freshness.

Visitors can purchase chestnuts in various quantities, from small bags for roasting to bulk orders for holiday baking. The farm store also sells chestnut products, local honey, and other regional specialties worth the scenic trip.

9. Breadtree Farms – Salem

Nestled in Washington County, this working farm offers chestnuts grown with care and attention to sustainable practices. The farm market operates seasonally, with peak chestnut availability from September through November.

Beyond nuts, the farm grows heirloom apples, pears, and vegetables that reflect the region’s agricultural heritage. Shopping here connects customers directly to the land and the farmers who tend it year-round.

10. Dressel Farms Ice Cream & Market – New Paltz

This Hudson Valley destination combines farm-fresh produce with homemade ice cream for a complete autumn outing. Chestnuts arrive fresh from regional growers, alongside apples, cider, and vegetables from Dressel’s own fields.

Families make traditions of visiting for pumpkin picking and staying to shop the market. The friendly atmosphere and quality products make it worth the trip from anywhere in the Hudson Valley region.

11. Adams Fairacre Farms – Poughkeepsie

This Hudson Valley institution spans multiple locations, with the Poughkeepsie store offering an impressive array of seasonal produce. Chestnut selection peaks in October, with both local and imported varieties available.

The market’s size allows for variety without sacrificing the personal touch of a farm stand. Prepared foods, fresh bakery items, and specialty groceries make it a one-stop destination for holiday meal planning.

12. Union Square Greenmarket – New York

Four days weekly, this iconic farmers market transforms Union Square into a celebration of regional agriculture. Multiple vendors sell chestnuts during autumn, each offering slightly different varieties and growing methods.

Shopping here means talking directly with growers about their harvest and getting preparation tips. The market atmosphere buzzes with energy as New Yorkers gather to support local farms and enjoy seasonal abundance together.

13. Wegmans – Rochester

Rochester’s hometown grocery chain sets the standard for supermarket excellence throughout New York. The produce department dedicates significant space to seasonal items, including multiple chestnut varieties during fall months.

Educational signage helps shoppers select and prepare unfamiliar ingredients with confidence. Wegmans combines the convenience of a large supermarket with attention to quality that rivals specialty stores, making seasonal cooking accessible to everyone.