Nobody Makes Fish And Chips Like This Little Washington Restaurant
The cod here is so big that the restaurant itself calls the fillets humongous.
That’s not a word most kitchens use about their own food. It’s a confession, and frankly, a generous one.
Then comes the side that makes people stop and blink.
Every order arrives with mushy peas, and they’re minted in house. Fat chips get cooked twice, too, because once apparently wasn’t enough.
So which is the real story here, the giant fish or the careful little details? Honestly, it’s both at once.
A London recipe found a home in Washington, and it brought its manners along.
I can’t pick a favorite part, and I’ve stopped trying. The fish gets the headlines. The peas quietly earn their own fan club.
A London Recipe Took A Ferry Ride And Never Left

Proper Fish began with a London-born cook and a Seattle food truck. The Nosh truck built its following around British-style fish and chips before the idea found a permanent home on Bainbridge Island in May 2019.
The best part? The restaurant opened with the truck’s original recipe, built around wild cod from the Bering Sea, a crisp coating, hand-cut chips, and familiar British accompaniments.
The business eventually passed to a new ownership team with roots in the island community, and the original fish-and-chips tradition remained central.
It’s a wonderfully specific stop for a Washington day trip: take a ferry across Puget Sound, wander through downtown, and finish with a basket that owes its character to a London-inspired food truck.
Bring A Friend, Because That Cod Is Seriously Huge

Wild Bering Sea cod is the star at Proper Fish. The kitchen uses substantial fillets, coats them in its seasoned batter, and fries them until the outside turns golden.
Then there’s the size. The restaurant calls its fish humongous, which feels like an honest warning label more than a brag.
The fish arrives with house-made tartar sauce, thick chips, and minted mushy peas. A lemon wedge adds brightness, and malt vinegar is a familiar option for anyone who likes the classic British combination.
Cut through the coating and the contrast becomes clear: a crisp exterior surrounds flaky white fish. That straightforward combination is the foundation of the menu, with the cod doing most of the talking.
Start with the original basket on your first visit. It’s the dish that connects the Bainbridge kitchen to its food-truck beginnings, and it gives every other menu item a tough act to follow.
Fat Chips And Minty Peas Deserve Their Own Applause

Skinny fries need not apply. Proper Fish serves freshly hand-cut fat chips, and each batch gets cooked twice for a more interesting texture.
The potatoes are soaked, blanched, and finished to order. That process helps create a crisp exterior while keeping the middle soft, giving the chips the comforting heft associated with a British fish shop.
Then there’s the green sidekick. The signature basket includes mushy peas with mint added in house, a distinctly British detail that makes this Washington seafood meal feel a little different.
For anyone unfamiliar with mushy peas, think of tender peas mashed into a soft, spoonable accompaniment rather than a neat row of vegetables. The mint brings a fresh note beside the fish and potatoes.
The sides aren’t afterthoughts here. The potatoes require their own careful preparation, and the peas keep the plate connected to the tradition that inspired the restaurant in the first place.
The Menu Has Plenty Of Tricks Beyond The Basket

Lobster rolls on a fish-and-chips menu? Proper Fish makes that work with an East Coast-style version packed with lobster claw and knuckle meat.
The lobster comes with a little house-made mayonnaise and seasoning, served in a toasted brioche bun. It’s quite a contrast to the generous battered cod, though both belong comfortably on a seafood-focused menu.
The cod chowder is another option. Cream and butter give the soup its rich base, while generous pieces of fish, spring onions, parsley oil, and oyster crackers finish the bowl.
Fish tacos bring a different direction, with cod, cabbage, pickled red onions, and a lively collection of sauces. There’s also a fish sandwich layered with slow-roasted tomatoes, onions, arugula, and tartar sauce on potato bread.
Fried oysters and panko-coated fish bites offer smaller alternatives, while large onion rings come with the same house tartar sauce.
An Octopus Watches Over Your Order

Menus are usually printed on paper. At Proper Fish, the menu shares a wall with a big octopus mural, which makes deciding what to eat a little more fun.
The golden, curling tentacles surround a chalkboard-style display, bringing a playful maritime touch to the interior. The artwork has been part of the restaurant’s identity since its opening.
Counter ordering keeps the experience casual. Choose your food, find a place to sit, and settle in while the kitchen prepares the next batch. The cooking area is visible, adding a little energy to the room without turning lunch into a formal occasion.
It’s a straightforward setting where the basket takes center stage.
The mural deserves a second look before you leave. Between its oversized sea creature and the generous cod, Proper Fish clearly isn’t afraid to let its best features take up space.
Yellow Tables Under A Pergola Make Lunch Feel Like A Vacation

Sunshine yellow is a bold choice for Pacific Northwest patio furniture. Proper Fish went for it anyway, and the result is cheerful.
Outside the gray-shingled storefront, rows of bright yellow tables and chairs sit beneath a wooden pergola. String lights stretch along the covered walkway, making the modest entrance feel lively before you’ve even opened the door.
The patio gives you a casual place to enjoy fish and chips when the weather cooperates. A plate of hot food and fresh outdoor air suit the easygoing pace of downtown Bainbridge.
Unlike waterfront restaurants, this address is on a town street rather than directly overlooking Puget Sound. The ferry and shoreline are nearby, but the outdoor tables look toward the neighborhood setting.
The yellow chairs are especially memorable against the pale exterior and natural wood overhead. Even a cool Washington afternoon looks a little brighter with that much color.
More Room Next Door For An Unhurried Meal

A popular little fish shop eventually needed more breathing room. Proper Fish expanded into a neighboring storefront, giving diners an additional indoor seating area beyond its original counter-service room.
The expansion took shape in 2024 and 2025, introducing more tables and a slightly different atmosphere for people who want to sit down rather than take their food away.
The neighboring room also makes group visits easier to picture. Friends can gather around a table, compare dishes, and linger without treating every meal like a race back to the ferry.
It’s an interesting contrast with the restaurant’s beginnings as a moving food truck. A concept once designed around a compact kitchen now has a permanent address and space to spread out.
Look for the original room’s octopus artwork if it’s your first visit, then choose whichever seating area suits the day. The expansion gives this small Winslow restaurant a little more flexibility while keeping its casual character intact.
A Little Seafood Shop With Room For A Crowd

The story doesn’t end with the fish basket. Proper Fish also offers catering for birthdays, family gatherings, office occasions, and other events where seafood sounds better than another ordinary sandwich tray.
Private event arrangements are available, with food organized for groups rather than individual counter orders. That makes the restaurant useful to the island community beyond everyday lunch and dinner.
Takeout is another option. Ordering ahead lets you collect a meal before heading toward the waterfront or returning to the ferry terminal, though the chips are best enjoyed while they’re fresh from the kitchen.
The restaurant opened in 2019 and has since developed from its original food-truck inspiration into an established downtown address with additional seating and event service.
For an island where visitors arrive by foot, bicycle, and ferry, that adaptable approach makes sense. It’s an approachable place for a quick bite, but also a kitchen that can feed a bigger gathering.
Catch The Ferry, Then Catch Your Dinner

Few lunch plans start with a boat ride. Getting to Proper Fish from Seattle often does, thanks to the ferry to Bainbridge Island.
The Seattle–Bainbridge crossing takes about 35 minutes, connecting downtown Seattle with the island’s Winslow neighborhood.
From the ferry terminal, you can continue on foot through the town center toward Madison Avenue.
You’ll find the restaurant at 112 Madison Ave. N., a short walk from shops, galleries, and the Bainbridge Island Museum of Art. It’s an easy addition to a day built around exploring rather than driving.
The restaurant opens at 11 a.m. daily. Its own published schedule has dining until 7 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 8 p.m. on Friday and Saturday, although hours can change around holidays and special events.
If you’re planning to catch a return ferry, check the sailing schedule as carefully as the restaurant’s hours.
A ferry ride, a downtown walk, and a giant piece of cod make an unusually satisfying Washington afternoon. Leave time for one last look at the harbor before heading home.
