9 Ohio Hardware Stores With Home Decor Finds Beyond The Big Chains

Across Ohio, neighborhood hardware stores are redefining what it means to shop local. Beyond aisles of nails and paint, many now feature corners filled with handcrafted décor, seasonal accents, and pieces that reflect the character of their communities.

These family-owned businesses bridge the gap between practicality and style, offering shoppers a place to tackle repairs and discover distinctive home touches under the same roof.

1. Hartville Hardware’s Rustic Charm Collection

Sprawling across seven acres, this family-owned gem houses an impressive selection of farmhouse-inspired decor that perfectly complements any country-style home.

Vintage signs, handcrafted wooden furniture, and locally made pottery line the dedicated home decor section. Seasonal displays showcase how to blend functional hardware items with decorative pieces for a cohesive look.

2. Lehman’s Hardware Amish-Crafted Treasures

Founded in 1955 to serve the local Amish community, Lehman’s now attracts visitors seeking authentic, non-electric home goods with timeless appeal.

Hand-dipped candles, oil lamps, and expertly crafted wooden utensils fill the shelves. Their selection emphasizes quality craftsmanship over mass production, offering decor items that tell a story while bringing warmth to any room.

3. Terry Lumber Supply’s Upcycled Architectural Elements

What began as a lumber yard has expanded into a resource for builders and decorators, offering materials and hardware that can be repurposed into unique focal pieces.

Antique doorknobs become coat hooks while weathered window frames transform into unique mirrors. The knowledgeable staff eagerly shares creative ways to incorporate these conversation pieces into modern homes without sacrificing functionality.

4. Bona Decorative Hardware’s Luxury Fixtures

Elevating everyday hardware to art forms, this Cincinnati specialty shop transforms functional necessities into statement pieces that anchor room designs.

The showroom highlights high-end finishes, with cabinet pulls, knobs, and other hardware chosen as much for visual appeal as for everyday function. Beyond mere functionality, each piece serves as jewelry for the home, proving that even the smallest hardware elements can make dramatic decorative impacts.

5. Independent Ace Hardware’s Seasonal Decor Haven

Many of Ohio’s independently owned Ace stores dedicate space to rotating seasonal displays, offering décor and inspiration alongside everyday hardware needs.

Handpicked garden statuary transitions to autumn wreaths and holiday centerpieces as seasons change. These thoughtfully arranged vignettes help customers envision how decorative elements might enhance their own homes, creating complete seasonal transformations beyond basic hardware needs.

6. Do It Best Co-Op’s Local Artisan Corner

Member-owned cooperative stores across Ohio partner with regional craftspeople to showcase handmade decor you won’t find anywhere else.

Turned wooden bowls crafted from fallen Ohio trees sit beside hand-poured soy candles in repurposed vintage containers. Some co-op locations highlight regional products or locally sourced décor, helping connect shoppers with makers in their own communities.

7. True Value Community Stores’ Custom Paint & Decor Pairings

Family-operated True Value locations throughout Ohio have mastered the art of connecting paint selections with complementary home accessories for foolproof design coordination. Many True Value stores pair their paint selections with coordinating décor items, making it easier for shoppers to visualize a cohesive design.

This innovative approach helps decorating novices confidently create cohesive looks without hiring designers, making stylish home updates accessible regardless of budget or experience.

8. Village Hardware Shops’ Vintage-Inspired Collections

Tucked into historic downtown districts across Ohio, these charming small-town hardware stores specialize in nostalgic decor that celebrates local heritage. It’s common to find vintage-style signs and reproduction hardware in these shops, allowing homeowners to add nostalgic character to their spaces.

These carefully selected pieces help homeowners honor architectural history while creating spaces that feel personally meaningful and connected to community roots.

9. Specialty Decor Sections At Hardware Destinations

Ohio’s largest hardware destinations have become unexpected havens for holiday decorating enthusiasts seeking both traditional and unconventional seasonal displays. Both Hartville and Lehman’s are known for large seasonal décor sections, with holiday displays that shift throughout the year to match the season.

These immersive displays go beyond mere merchandise, creating memorable shopping experiences that inspire creativity and make hardware stores unexpected destinations for decorative inspiration year-round.