15 Pennsylvania Seafood Buffets That Keep Locals Coming Back For More Classic East Coast Comfort
Pennsylvania might not sit directly on the ocean, but its seafood buffets deliver fresh, satisfying flavors that rival any coastal dining experience.
From Amish country smorgasbords piled high with crab legs and fried shrimp to family-friendly restaurants serving baked flounder and clam chowder, these spots have perfected the art of East Coast comfort food.
Locals know exactly where to find generous spreads, welcoming atmospheres, and dishes that taste like home.
Whether craving classic Pennsylvania Dutch sides or international seafood favorites, these twenty buffets offer something special that keeps families, friends, and hungry diners returning week after week.
1. Shady Maple Smorgasbord
Recognized as the largest buffet in the entire United States, this legendary smorgasbord stretches an impressive 200 feet and features over 100 different menu options that change throughout the week.
Located at 129 Toddy Dr, East Earl, PA 17519, the restaurant draws crowds from across the state who come hungry and leave satisfied.
Seafood nights showcase fried shrimp, catfish, and shellfish alongside traditional Pennsylvania Dutch favorites like pierogies, beef brisket, and homemade rolls that practically melt in your mouth.
The dining room buzzes with conversation as families settle into booths and return to the buffet line again and again.
Arriving early on weekends helps avoid the longest wait times, and saving room for the dessert station filled with shoofly pie and fruit cobblers makes the experience complete.
2. Miller’s Smorgasbord
Serving authentic Amish country cooking since 1929, this beloved establishment has welcomed generations of diners seeking hearty, comforting meals prepared with care and tradition.
The address is 2811 Lincoln Hwy E, Ronks, PA 17572, nestled in the heart of Lancaster County’s scenic farmland.
Crab cakes arrive golden and tender, while baked flounder offers a lighter option that pairs beautifully with potato filling and buttered corn.
The buffet tables groan under the weight of roast turkey, ham, mashed potatoes, and fresh vegetables grown locally whenever possible.
Whoopie pies and apple dumplings tempt every sweet tooth, and the staff maintains a friendly, efficient pace that keeps plates full and glasses refilled.
Weekday lunches tend to be quieter than weekend dinners, making them ideal for leisurely meals.
3. Manor Buffet
Situated in the heart of Amish country, this seafood-focused buffet has built a loyal following thanks to its snow crab legs, made-to-order pasta, and variety of international dishes that add unexpected flair.
You’ll find it at 2090 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster, PA 17602, where ample parking and a welcoming entrance set the tone.
The crab legs arrive fresh and steaming, ready to crack open with melted butter on the side, while the pasta station lets diners customize sauces and toppings to personal taste.
Asian-inspired dishes, Italian favorites, and classic American comfort foods share space on the buffet line, ensuring everyone at the table finds something to love.
Lighting stays warm and inviting, and the dining room layout allows for both intimate family gatherings
4. Hoss’s Steak & Sea House
A regional chain with roots deep in Pennsylvania, this steakhouse offers a diverse buffet experience that balances seafood options with hearty steaks and classic American favorites.
The Duncansville location sits at 110 Patch Way Rd, Duncansville, PA 16635, convenient for travelers exploring central Pennsylvania’s scenic routes.
Fried shrimp, fish fillets, and clam strips share buffet space with grilled chicken, roast beef, and a salad bar stocked with fresh vegetables and dressings.
The atmosphere leans casual and family-friendly, with booth seating and a relaxed pace that welcomes kids and adults alike.
Prices stay reasonable, and the variety ensures picky eaters find something appealing while adventurous diners sample multiple dishes.
Weeknight visits often mean shorter lines and a quieter dining room, perfect for unwinding after a long day.
5. Bird-In-Hand Family Restaurant
Nestled in a charming village that attracts tourists year-round, this family restaurant serves up generous buffets featuring seafood alongside classic Pennsylvania Dutch comfort foods.
Located at 2760 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505, the restaurant sits near quilt shops and farmers markets that make the area a popular destination.
Fried fish, seafood casseroles, and buttery scallops appear on the buffet line next to roasted chicken, mashed potatoes, and fresh-baked bread that fills the dining room with irresistible aromas.
The decor reflects the region’s heritage with simple wooden tables, quilted wall hangings, and soft lighting that creates a cozy, welcoming environment.
Service stays attentive without hovering, and the staff genuinely seems to enjoy sharing local recommendations with visitors.
Breakfast and lunch buffets offer different selections than dinner, so repeat visits reveal new favorites.
6. Plain & Fancy Farm Restaurant
Set on a working farm surrounded by rolling fields and Amish buggies, this restaurant delivers an authentic taste of Pennsylvania Dutch country life through its hearty buffet offerings.
The address is 3121 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505, where the scenic surroundings enhance the entire dining experience.
Seafood dishes like broiled fish and fried shrimp complement traditional favorites such as chicken pot pie, sausage, and noodles that have been perfected over generations.
Large windows overlook the farmland, and the dining room maintains a rustic charm with exposed beams and handcrafted furniture.
The buffet changes seasonally to incorporate fresh, local ingredients, and the dessert table showcases pies, cakes, and puddings that taste homemade because they are.
Visiting during the week often means a more relaxed pace and easier parking.
7. Dienner’s Country Restaurant
This country restaurant has earned a reputation for generous portions, friendly service, and buffet spreads that celebrate both seafood and traditional Pennsylvania Dutch cooking.
You’ll find it at 2855 Lincoln Hwy E, Ronks, PA 17572, easily accessible from the main highway and surrounded by farmland.
Crab cakes, fried fish, and seafood chowder rotate through the buffet alongside roast beef, turkey, and an impressive array of vegetable sides prepared with care.
The dining room feels homey and unpretentious, with booth seating and tables that accommodate families of all sizes comfortably.
Servers keep drinks refilled and clear plates promptly, maintaining a steady rhythm that keeps the meal flowing smoothly.
Desserts include traditional Pennsylvania Dutch sweets like shoofly pie and fruit cobblers that provide a perfect ending to a satisfying meal.
8. Willow Valley Resort
Part of a larger resort complex, this dining venue offers a more upscale buffet experience with seafood selections that feel refined while maintaining the warmth of Pennsylvania hospitality.
Located at 2400 Willow Street Pike, Lancaster, PA 17602, the resort provides ample parking and a welcoming lobby area.
Crab legs, shrimp cocktail, and baked fish fillets share space with prime rib, carved turkey, and international dishes that add variety to the buffet line.
The dining room features soft lighting, comfortable seating, and large windows that let in natural light during daytime meals.
Service stays professional and attentive, and the atmosphere strikes a balance between elegant and relaxed that suits both special occasions and casual dinners.
Reservations help during busy weekends, and the dessert station features cakes, pastries, and seasonal specialties worth saving room for.
9. Smokehouse BBQ & Brews
While barbecue takes center stage, this restaurant surprises diners with seafood buffet nights that showcase fresh catches alongside smoky ribs and brisket.
The address is 3121 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird in Hand, PA 17505, convenient for locals and visitors exploring the Lancaster area.
Fried catfish, shrimp skewers, and seafood gumbo join pulled pork, smoked chicken, and cornbread on buffet nights that draw crowds looking for variety.
The atmosphere leans casual and lively, with exposed brick, wooden tables, and a bar area that serves local craft beers.
Music plays at a comfortable volume, and the staff maintains a friendly, easygoing vibe that makes everyone feel welcome.
Weeknight buffets tend to be less crowded, and the combination of barbecue and seafood creates a unique dining experience that stands out from traditional Pennsylvania Dutch buffets.
10. Fulton Steamboat Inn
Built to resemble a 19th-century steamboat, this unique inn features a restaurant that serves buffets with seafood selections that honor the property’s nautical theme.
Located at 1 Hartman Bridge Rd, Lancaster, PA 17602, the inn sits along a scenic route popular with tourists exploring Amish country.
Shrimp, fish fillets, and seafood pasta appear on the buffet alongside roast meats, fresh salads, and Pennsylvania Dutch sides that satisfy diverse tastes.
The dining room’s steamboat decor includes porthole windows, vintage photographs, and nautical accents that create a charming, memorable atmosphere.
Guests staying at the inn receive priority seating, but the restaurant welcomes outside diners as well.
Breakfast buffets offer different options than dinner service, and the variety ensures every meal feels fresh and interesting rather than repetitive.
11. Stoltzfus Farm Restaurant
Operating on a working farm, this restaurant brings farm-to-table freshness to its buffet offerings, including seafood dishes that complement the region’s agricultural bounty.
The address is 14 Center St, Intercourse, PA 17534, where the rural setting and authentic farm atmosphere enhance the dining experience.
Fried fish, seafood salad, and clam chowder rotate through the buffet alongside fried chicken, ham, and vegetables harvested from nearby fields.
The dining room maintains a simple, comfortable aesthetic with wooden tables, quilted decorations, and windows overlooking pastures and barns.
Families appreciate the relaxed pace and kid-friendly atmosphere, while couples enjoy the quiet charm of the countryside setting.
Desserts feature homemade pies and cakes that showcase seasonal fruits, and the staff takes pride in sharing stories about the farm’s history and operations.
12. Katie’s Kitchen
This cozy restaurant feels like stepping into a Pennsylvania grandmother’s kitchen, where buffet tables overflow with seafood and traditional dishes prepared with love and attention.
Located at 200 Hartman Bridge Rd, Ronks, PA 17572, the restaurant sits in a quiet area away from the main tourist routes.
Baked fish, fried shrimp, and seafood casseroles share space with pot roast, chicken, and homemade noodles that taste like they came from a family recipe box.
The dining room stays intimate and welcoming, with booth seating, checkered tablecloths, and decor that reflects the region’s heritage without feeling overly themed.
Service feels personal and genuine, with servers who remember regular customers and make newcomers feel like part of the family.
Portions remain generous, and the buffet stays well-stocked throughout service hours without sacrificing quality.
13. Yoder’s Restaurant & Buffet
Carrying a name synonymous with Pennsylvania Dutch heritage, this restaurant delivers buffets that honor tradition while incorporating seafood options that appeal to modern tastes.
The address is 14 S Tower Rd, New Holland, PA 17557, situated in a small town known for its Amish markets and craft shops.
Fried fish, seafood newburg, and shrimp scampi join roasted turkey, ham, and an impressive selection of vegetable sides that change with the seasons.
The dining room feels spacious and comfortable, with lighting that flatters and seating arrangements that work for both small parties and larger gatherings.
Prices stay affordable, and the buffet’s variety ensures everyone leaves satisfied regardless of dietary preferences or appetite size.
Weekday lunches offer a quieter experience, while weekend dinners bring a festive energy that makes meals feel like celebrations.
14. Hershey Farm Restaurant
This expansive restaurant and inn complex offers buffets that draw families and tour groups seeking generous seafood selections and classic Pennsylvania Dutch hospitality.
Located at 240 Hartman Bridge Rd, Ronks, PA 17572, the property includes lodging, shops, and the restaurant under one roof.
Fried shrimp, baked fish, and seafood casseroles join ham, turkey, and an extensive array of sides that cater to diverse tastes and dietary needs.
The dining room accommodates large groups comfortably, with multiple seating areas and efficient buffet lines that minimize wait times even during busy periods.
Staff members work together smoothly to keep the buffet stocked and tables cleared, maintaining quality service despite high volume.
Desserts include pies, cakes, and puddings that showcase Pennsylvania Dutch baking traditions, and the variety ensures everyone finds something sweet to enjoy.
15. Lancaster Brewing Company
While primarily known for craft beer, this brewery offers special buffet events that feature seafood paired with their signature brews in a contemporary, industrial-chic setting.
The address is 302 N Plum St, Lancaster, PA 17602, located in the city’s revitalized downtown area.
Steamed shrimp, fish tacos, and seafood paella appear during themed buffet nights alongside barbecue, sliders, and creative appetizers that complement the brewery’s beer selection.
The atmosphere feels lively and modern, with exposed brick, metal accents, and communal tables that encourage socializing and conversation.
Service stays knowledgeable about both food and beer pairings, helping diners navigate the menu and find combinations that enhance both elements.
Special events and seasonal buffets rotate throughout the year, making each visit feel fresh and worth anticipating for locals who follow the brewery’s calendar.
