16 Secret Illinois Burger Spots Serving Double Cheeseburgers So Good They Sell Out Fast
Illinois hides some of the most amazing burger joints you’ve probably never heard of, and they’re serving double cheeseburgers that disappear faster than you can say “extra pickles.”
These under-the-radar spots have mastered the art of the perfect patty, crispy edges, melted cheese, and all the toppings that make your mouth water.
I’ve tracked down sixteen places across the state where locals line up early because once these burgers sell out, you’re out of luck until tomorrow.
1. Moonshine Store
Arriving at this rural gem feels like stepping back in time to simpler days.
The address is 10995 IL-1, Martinsville, IL 62442, and you’ll find it tucked away in farm country.
Their double hamburger comes with thin, crispy patties that crunch perfectly with every bite.
Melted American cheese oozes over pickles and mustard, creating a classic flavor combination that never gets old.
The grill shuts down at exactly 12:30 p.m., so sleeping in means missing out completely.
Locals know to show up before noon if they want any chance of snagging one of these beauties.
The early closure adds to the mystique and makes every burger feel like a special treasure.
2. The Region
Roscoe Village keeps this delicious secret tucked in its cozy neighborhood streets.
You’ll find it at 1801 W Addison St, Chicago, IL 60613, ready to blow your mind.
The ‘Diggity Dos’ double cheeseburger features lacy, caramelized edges that add incredible texture and flavor.
Each patty gets smashed perfectly on the griddle, creating those crispy bits everyone fights over.
Their hand-cut onion rings deserve just as much attention and frequently vanish during rush times.
Peak hours bring crowds of burger lovers who know exactly what they’re after.
Getting there early on weekends gives you the best shot at experiencing everything this spot offers before items disappear from the menu board.
3. Paradise Pup
Drive-up burger stands don’t get more legendary than this Des Plaines favorite.
Located at 1724 S River Rd, Des Plaines, IL 60018, it operates only when the sun is up.
Their ‘double cheddar char’ absolutely drips with Merkts sharp cheddar, coating every inch of the patties.
The cheese choice alone sets this burger apart from typical American cheese options elsewhere.
Lines form quickly and stretch long because word has spread about how incredible these burgers taste.
Daylight-only hours mean you need to plan your visit carefully around their schedule.
Missing the window means waiting another day to experience what many consider the ultimate cheddar burger in Illinois.
4. Krekel’s Custard & Burgers
Since 1949, this Decatur institution has been perfecting the art of the smashed burger.
The address is 2323 N Water St, Decatur, IL 62526, where generations have gathered for burgers.
Thin, smashed double cheeseburgers arrive wrapped in wax paper, just like they did decades ago.
Crispy edges form naturally when the patties hit the hot griddle and get pressed down hard.
Their frozen custard makes the perfect sweet companion to balance the savory burger flavors.
Ordering both together creates a complete meal that satisfies every craving at once.
The vintage atmosphere and unchanged recipes make every visit feel like a journey to simpler times when burgers were simple and delicious.
5. Leavitt Street Inn & Tavern
Neighborhood taverns in Bucktown don’t get cozier or more welcoming than this spot.
Find it at 2223 W Leavitt St, Chicago, IL 60618, where regulars gather like family.
Their double smash burger sits on a buttered, toasted bun that adds richness to every bite.
The butter soaks slightly into the bread, creating a golden crunch that contrasts with the juicy patties.
A relaxed atmosphere makes this place perfect for unwinding after a long day with friends.
Locals treat it as their go-to spot because the quality never wavers and the vibe stays consistently comfortable.
The combination of great food and easygoing environment explains why this tavern has become a Bucktown staple.
6. The StopAlong
Bucktown holds another burger treasure that disappears fast when evening crowds arrive.
Located at 1812 W Wabansia Ave, Chicago, IL 60622, it’s a neighborhood favorite.
The ‘Stop-In’ and ‘That Other Burger’ are both griddled doubles that vanish during busy nights.
Each burger gets cooked to order on a hot griddle, ensuring maximum flavor and texture.
Busy evenings bring waves of hungry customers who know exactly what to order.
The speed at which these burgers sell out speaks volumes about their quality and reputation.
Showing up early or calling ahead helps secure your order before the kitchen runs out of supplies for the night.
7. Nick’s Drive-In
Retro vibes hit you immediately when you pull up to this Norwood Park gem.
The address is 7301 W Caldwell Ave, Niles, IL 60714, right on the Norwood Park/Niles line.
Their ‘Bubba Double Cheeseburger’ delivers juicy patties with nostalgic flavors that transport you back decades.
Every bite tastes like summer cookouts and simpler times when burgers were uncomplicated and satisfying.
The retro setting adds to the experience, making you feel like you’ve traveled through time.
Old-school decor and classic menu items keep the authentic drive-in spirit alive.
Families and burger enthusiasts make regular pilgrimages here to relive memories and create new ones with every delicious double cheeseburger.
8. Diner Grill
Late-night cravings meet their match at this 24-hour railcar diner in North Center.
You’ll find it at 1635 W Irving Park Rd, Chicago, IL 60613, open around the clock.
Their double bacon cheeseburger adds a smoky crunch from perfectly cooked bacon strips.
The bacon elevates the entire burger experience, bringing texture and flavor that regular burgers can’t match.
Being open all night means you can satisfy burger cravings whenever they strike, no matter the hour.
The railcar setting provides an authentic diner atmosphere that feels timeless and comforting.
Whether you’re ending a night out or starting your day early, this spot delivers consistent quality that keeps people coming back repeatedly.
9. Edzo’s Burger Shop
College towns know good burgers, and Evanston proves this point perfectly.
Head to 1571 Sherman Ave, Evanston, IL 60201, where students and locals unite over burgers.
Hand-formed patties get cooked fresh throughout the day, never frozen or pre-made.
The difference in taste and texture is immediately obvious from the first bite.
Their special sauce recipe remains a closely guarded secret that keeps people guessing and returning.
Counter seating creates a casual, friendly environment where conversations flow easily between strangers.
Rush times around lunch and dinner mean burgers fly out the door faster than the kitchen can keep up, so timing your visit matters greatly here.
10. Hackney’s on Harms
Dark rye bread might sound unusual for a burger, but this Glenview spot makes it work brilliantly.
Located at 1241 Harms Rd, Glenview, IL 60025, it’s been serving unique burgers for years.
Their double cheeseburger on dark rye creates a flavor combination you won’t find anywhere else.
The rye adds a slightly tangy, earthy taste that complements the beef and cheese perfectly.
Signature onion rings are legendary in their own right and deserve a spot on every order.
The rustic interior makes you feel like you’re dining in a comfortable lodge.
People travel from across the state specifically for this unique burger experience that challenges traditional burger expectations while exceeding taste expectations completely.
11. Schoop’s Hamburgers
Regional chains sometimes hide in plain sight, and this one deserves way more attention.
Visit 215 Torrence Ave, Calumet City, IL 60409, for a taste of Illinois burger history.
Their classic double cheeseburger follows a time-tested recipe that hasn’t changed in decades.
Consistency across locations means you know exactly what delicious experience awaits every single visit.
Vintage signage and retro decor transport you straight back to the golden age of American diners.
The red-and-white color scheme and classic menu board complete the nostalgic atmosphere.
Families have been making memories here for generations, passing down the tradition of Schoop’s burgers from parents to children who now bring their own kids.
12. Meatheads Burgers & Fries
Fresh ingredients make all the difference when building the perfect burger.
Find them at 1470 McConnor Pkwy, Schaumburg, IL 60173, where quality comes first.
Their double cheeseburger features never-frozen beef that tastes noticeably better than frozen alternatives.
Hand-cut fries accompany every burger, providing the ideal crispy, salty sidekick.
The modern fast-casual approach means you get quality without the long wait times.
Clean, contemporary interiors appeal to families and professionals looking for quick, satisfying meals.
During peak lunch rushes, burgers move so quickly that the kitchen operates at full speed constantly, proving that fresh ingredients and efficient service create the winning combination customers crave.
13. Top Notch Beefburgers
Beverly neighborhood residents guard this secret jealously but word keeps spreading anyway.
Located at 2116 W 95th St, Chicago, IL 60643, it’s a true community treasure.
Grilled onions top their double cheeseburger, adding sweetness and caramelized flavor to every bite.
The onions cook low and slow until they reach perfect tenderness and golden color.
An outdoor ordering window keeps things simple and efficient during warmer months.
Vintage signage announces the spot from blocks away, drawing hungry customers like a beacon.
Neighbors line up regularly because they understand that quality like this doesn’t come around often, and supporting local businesses means keeping these delicious traditions alive for future generations to enjoy.
14. Linnie’s Pub
Irish pubs and American burgers might seem like an odd pairing, but Peoria makes it work.
The address is 5901 N Prospect Rd, Peoria, IL 61614, where pub culture meets burger excellence.
Their double cheeseburger is surprisingly juicy and flavorful, exceeding expectations every single time.
Dark wood interiors and cozy booth seating create an inviting atmosphere for long conversations.
Draft beer selection pairs perfectly with their burger offerings for a complete pub experience.
Locals consider this their neighborhood hangout where everybody knows your name and order.
The combination of friendly service, comfortable surroundings, and outstanding burgers explains why this pub stays packed most evenings with loyal customers who wouldn’t dream of going elsewhere.
15. Billy Goat Tavern
Underground taverns carry stories and legends, and this Chicago icon has plenty of both.
Find it at 430 N Michigan Ave, Chicago, IL 60611, beneath the bustling city streets.
Their double cheeseburger, famously shouted as ‘cheezborger,’ has appeared in countless stories and sketches.
The no-nonsense attitude and rapid-fire service create an experience as memorable as the food.
Newspaper clippings covering the walls tell decades of Chicago history and celebrity visits.
Tourists and locals mix together at the crowded counter, united by their love of simple, delicious burgers.
The atmosphere alone makes this worth visiting, but the burgers keep people coming back long after the novelty wears off completely.
16. Johnnie’s Beef
Beef stands usually focus on Italian beef, but this Elmwood Park legend does burgers exceptionally well too.
Located at 7500 W North Ave, Elmwood Park, IL 60707, it’s been serving hungry crowds for decades.
Their double cheeseburger holds its own against the famous Italian beef sandwiches on the menu.
Grilled patties develop a slightly charred exterior that adds depth and smoky notes.
Outdoor picnic tables fill quickly during nice weather as families and friends gather to eat.
The busy takeout counter moves at lightning speed, handling massive crowds with practiced efficiency.
Selling out happens regularly because people order multiples, knowing these burgers taste even better as leftovers the next day, though they rarely last that long.
