20 South Carolina Pizzerias That Regulars Pick Over The National Names

South Carolina’s pizza scene is bursting with local spots that make regulars forget about the big chains. These independent pizzerias serve up everything from classic New York slices to Detroit-style pies, each with its own personality and loyal following.

Whether you’re craving thin crust, thick crust, or something totally unique, the Palmetto State has a local favorite waiting to impress you.

1. Baker’s Bar

Topping the charts with a 4.84 rating from over 100 reviews, this Charleston gem delivers quality that keeps people coming back. The atmosphere blends upscale charm with approachable warmth, making it ideal for date nights or casual dinners with friends.

Each pizza reflects careful attention to ingredients and technique. The service matches the food quality, creating an experience that feels both special and welcoming without any pretense.

2. Toni’s Detroit Style Pizza

Mount Pleasant’s pride and joy earned national attention by ranking 9th on Yelp’s top ten pizzas across the entire country in December 2023. That thick, airy crust with caramelized cheese edges defines authentic Detroit-style pizza.

Locals appreciate how Toni’s stays true to tradition while keeping the vibe relaxed and friendly. The rectangular slices are substantial and satisfying, with toppings layered in reverse order for maximum flavor impact.

3. Belladina’s Pizzeria

Greenville’s Belladina’s captures traditional Italian flavors in a cozy setting that feels like stepping into a family kitchen. With a 4.82 rating from 183 reviews, the pizzeria has built a devoted following among locals seeking authentic taste.

The menu showcases classic recipes prepared with care and quality ingredients. Portions are generous, and the atmosphere invites lingering conversations over shared plates and laughter.

4. Coast Pizza

Myrtle Beach’s Coast Pizza brings together delicious pies and coastal vibes in a combination that feels perfectly suited to its oceanside location. The 4.79 rating from 272 reviews speaks to consistent quality and satisfied customers.

Beyond the food, the ambiance captures that relaxed beach town energy. Whether stopping by after a day in the sun or seeking a casual dinner spot, Coast Pizza delivers comfort and flavor.

5. Uncle Mikey’s Pizza

Murrells Inlet residents know Uncle Mikey’s as the place where toppings don’t hold back and friendly faces greet regulars by name. With 620 reviews averaging 4.73, this spot has earned its community favorite status.

Generous portions mean you get real value with every order. The service feels personal rather than rushed, creating a neighborhood hangout where families and friends gather regularly for satisfying meals.

6. Guys Pizza

Pendleton’s Guys Pizza keeps things classic with recipes that honor pizza’s timeless appeal and a welcoming environment that feels like home. The 4.72 rating from 550 reviews reflects years of consistency and community connection.

Nothing here tries too hard or follows fleeting trends. Instead, the focus stays on well-executed fundamentals and creating a space where everyone feels comfortable gathering for a good meal together.

7. Knead Pizza

Lexington’s Knead Pizza bridges traditional pizza-making techniques with contemporary flavor combinations that surprise and delight. The 4.72 rating from 435 reviews shows how this balance resonates with diverse tastes.

Watching dough get hand-stretched adds a touch of theater to the dining experience. The menu offers enough creativity to keep things interesting while maintaining the comforting familiarity that makes pizza universally beloved.

8. Park Pizza Co.

Charleston’s Park Pizza Co. stands out with innovative toppings and a diverse menu that encourages adventurous ordering. The 4.71 rating from 525 reviews indicates plenty of satisfied diners willing to try something different.

Flavor combinations range from familiar favorites to unexpected pairings that work surprisingly well. The atmosphere feels current and energetic, attracting crowds who appreciate creativity alongside quality ingredients and solid execution.

9. D’Allesandro’s Pizza

Craving that classic New York slice? This spot delivers thin crust perfection with just the right amount of flop and char. The cheese-to-sauce ratio hits that sweet spot, and the slices are big enough to fold properly.

Regulars swear by the simplicity here – no fancy toppings needed when the fundamentals are executed this well. The counter service keeps things moving, perfect for grabbing a quick bite that satisfies completely.

10. Mellow Mushroom

While technically a regional chain, Mellow Mushroom’s South Carolina locations feel distinctly local with their quirky decor and laid-back vibe. The hand-tossed dough and creative specialty pizzas set them apart from typical corporate pizza places.

The menu goes beyond pizza with calzones, hoagies, and a solid craft beer selection. Families appreciate the relaxed atmosphere where kids can marvel at the psychedelic artwork while everyone enjoys genuinely tasty food.

11. Renzo

Wood-fired ovens create those signature leopard-spotted crusts that pizza enthusiasts seek out. The high heat and quick cooking time produce pizzas with blistered edges and a tender, chewy center that tastes genuinely Italian.

Simple, quality ingredients shine here – San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fragrant basil. The menu stays focused rather than overwhelming, allowing each pizza to showcase its individual character and the skill behind its creation.

12. Brixx Wood Fired Pizza

Another regional favorite with South Carolina presence, Brixx combines the appeal of wood-fired cooking with a contemporary casual dining experience. The open kitchen lets diners watch pizzas emerge from the flames with perfectly charred crusts.

The menu balances traditional pizzas with inventive options featuring seasonal ingredients. Salads and appetizers complement the pizza offerings, making it easy to build a complete meal that satisfies various appetites and preferences.

13. Barbaro Pizza

Build-your-own pizza concepts appeal to diners who want control over every topping and combination. Barbaro Pizza offers this customization with quick service that doesn’t sacrifice quality or flavor for speed.

The assembly-line format means pizzas cook fast in high-temperature ovens, getting you from order to table in minutes. It’s ideal for lunch breaks or when hunger strikes and patience runs thin, without resorting to frozen or reheated options.

14. Johnny Brusco’s

Family-owned pizzerias carry a special warmth that comes from recipes passed down through generations and genuine care for customers. Johnny Brusco’s embodies this tradition with pizzas that taste like someone’s nonna is in the kitchen.

The menu extends beyond pizza to include pasta dishes and Italian classics, all prepared with the same attention to authenticity. Regulars know the staff, and the staff remembers their usual orders.

15. Woodhaven Pizza

Stone ovens impart a distinct character to pizza crusts, creating texture and flavor that metal ovens can’t quite replicate. Woodhaven Pizza understands this difference and makes it central to their pizza-making approach.

The result is crust with complex flavor – slightly smoky, perfectly crisp outside, and tender within. Toppings range from traditional to adventurous, all benefiting from that stone-baked foundation that turns good pizza into memorable pizza.

16. Giovanni’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Known for its classic hand-tossed pies, it offers a tantalizing menu filled with locally sourced ingredients. The rustic decor adds a nostalgic touch, making each visit a trip down memory lane.

Regulars rave about the crispy crust and flavorful toppings. Every slice is crafted with care, reflecting the passion of its owner, a lifelong pizza enthusiast. It’s the perfect spot for family gatherings or casual get-togethers.

17. Bravo Cucina Italiana

The mural-adorned walls tell a story of community and creativity. Famous for its signature pepperoni with a unique blend of spices, this spot sees regular families and friends sharing laughter over delicious slices.

The staff’s cheerful demeanor adds to the joyful experience, ensuring every visit feels special. It’s a staple for anyone craving a taste of authentic, artisanal pizza.

18. Coastal Crust

The ambience is inviting, complete with twinkle lights and cozy nooks. Their specialty pies, like the truffle mushroom, keep patrons coming back for more.

The commitment to quality is evident in every bite. Whether it’s a date night or a quick lunch break, this pizzeria offers a slice for every occasion, all served with a smile and a dash of love.

19. EVO Pizzeria

The retro-style booths and cheese-themed decor set a playful tone. Famous for its quadruple cheese blend, each slice is a melty masterpiece. The pizzeria is a haven for cheese enthusiasts and culinary adventurers alike.

The friendly service and whimsical atmosphere create a delightful dining escape, perfect for indulging in a cheesy feast with friends or family.

20. Famulari’s Pizzeria

The rustic charm and aroma of freshly baked dough create an inviting atmosphere. Known for its handcrafted creations, each pizza tells a story of culinary dedication and art.

Regulars appreciate the unique combinations and quality ingredients. This is a go-to spot for those seeking authentic, artisanal pizza experiences that transport them to another world, one slice at a time.