Wisconsin All-You-Can-Eat Steakhouses Locals Say Get The Porterhouse Right

Wisconsin knows how to serve steak the right way. When you want a porterhouse cooked to perfection without worrying about portion sizes, all-you-can-eat steakhouses are your best bet.

I’ve gathered the top spots where locals swear by the quality and flavor of every single cut.

1. Five O’Clock Steakhouse

Since 1946, this Milwaukee gem has been serving some of the finest steaks around. Locals rave about the tender, flavorful porterhouse that melts in your mouth.

Classic ambiance makes every visit feel special. You’ll find generous cuts prepared with care and tradition that spans generations.

2. Copper Oak Steakhouse

Near the Wisconsin Dells, this spot combines modern elegance with serious flavor. Their 24-ounce wood-fired porterhouse delivers a smoky taste that balances perfectly with the meat’s natural tenderness.

Wood-fired cooking adds a unique touch you won’t find everywhere. Quality is never compromised here, making it worth the trip.

3. The Milwaukee Steakhouse

Old-school charm meets serious steak craftsmanship at this beloved spot. Their 24-ounce porterhouse gets praised for its incredible sear and juiciness that keeps locals coming back.

You’ll feel the history in every bite. This place knows how to treat steak lovers right with generous portions and expert preparation.

4. LongHorn Steakhouse

Located in Ashwaubenon, this chain location surprises many with its quality. Their 22-ounce porterhouse combines the tenderness of filet with the rich, bold flavor of strip steak.

Consistency matters when you’re hungry for a great meal. You can count on a satisfying experience every single time you visit.

5. Republic Chophouse

Green Bay’s upscale dining scene shines at this sophisticated spot. Their 24-ounce porterhouse receives high praise for exceptional quality and careful preparation that shows real skill.

Attention to detail makes all the difference here. Every cut is handled with expertise that transforms a good meal into an unforgettable experience.

6. Samba Brazilian Grill

Madison’s rodizio-style dining brings a fun twist to steak night. Chef-selected porterhouse slices arrive at your table as part of the endless meat parade.

Variety keeps things exciting throughout your meal. You’ll enjoy different cuts and flavors while servers bring fresh options straight from the grill to your plate.

7. Black Angus Steakhouse

Family-friendly atmosphere meets serious steak expertise at this Wisconsin favorite. Their porterhouse selection offers impressive size and flavor that satisfies even the biggest appetites.

Comfort and quality go hand in hand here. You’ll appreciate the relaxed vibe while enjoying perfectly cooked meat that hits every expectation you have.

8. Ishnala Supper Club

Overlooking Mirror Lake, this classic Wisconsin supper club delivers tradition with every bite. Their porterhouse captures that authentic supper club experience locals cherish with generous portions and old-fashioned preparation.

Scenic views add magic to your dining experience. You’ll understand why generations keep returning for steaks done the Wisconsin way.

9. North Country Steak Buffet

With over 3,000 glowing reviews, this La Crosse favorite has built a loyal following among steak lovers who appreciate quality without breaking the bank. The restaurant offers unlimited sirloin steaks and burgers alongside a massive hot buffet filled with comfort foods.

What sets this place apart is the combination of variety and value. You can load up on tacos, fresh salads, and homemade desserts between steak servings. The casual, welcoming atmosphere makes it perfect for families and groups celebrating special occasions.

10. Prime Quarter Steak House

Ever wanted to be the chef for the night? This Green Bay institution puts the power in your hands with its famous grill-your-own concept. Diners select their preferred cut from the meat case and cook it exactly how they like it at their own table grill.

The interactive experience transforms dinner into entertainment, especially for kids who love watching the sizzle and flame. Beyond the main attraction, the unlimited salad bar provides fresh vegetables and toppings to complement your perfectly grilled steak. The hands-on approach means no more sending back overcooked or undercooked meat.

11. Merrill & Houston’s Steak Joint

Step back in time at this Beloit treasure where steak dinners feel like proper celebrations rather than just another meal. The restaurant keeps alive the ticketed beefsteak dinner tradition, creating a communal vibe that brings strangers together over exceptional beef.

What makes this spot legendary among locals is the commitment to old-school hospitality and top-tier meat quality. The atmosphere buzzes with energy during their special events, where sharing tables and stories becomes part of the experience. Located on Pleasant Street, the restaurant lives up to its address by delivering pleasant memories every visit.