10 Wisconsin Supper Clubs Serving Up The Ultimate Friday Fish Fry
Friday night in Wisconsin means one thing: fish fry. This beloved tradition brings families together at supper clubs across the state for crispy, golden fish and all the fixings.
From lakeside establishments to cozy small-town haunts, these classic supper clubs serve up the authentic Wisconsin experience alongside perfectly prepared perch, walleye, and cod.
1. Clifford’s Supper Club
Locals have been flocking to this Hales Corners institution for generations. The secret? Hand-breaded perch that’s light and flaky with a perfect crunch.
Friday nights buzz with energy as families gather around tables topped with coleslaw, rye bread, and those famous potato pancakes. The retro bar area, with its warm wood paneling, feels like stepping back in time.
2. Wissota High Shores Supper Club
Perched above Lake Wissota, this charming supper club pairs breathtaking water views with expertly prepared fish fry platters. Sunset reflections dance across the lake while diners savor crispy fish.
The relaxed atmosphere encourages lingering over old fashioneds and hearty portions. Family-owned since the 1970s, their commitment to quality shines through in every golden-brown fillet they serve.
3. Feil’s Supper Club
Don’t let the unassuming exterior fool you. Hidden near tiny Randolph, Feil’s delivers fish fry that draws patrons from miles around. Generations of families have celebrated special occasions here.
Friday’s fish fry often features hand-breaded or beer-battered options, a tradition locals love. The cozy, wood-paneled dining room fills with conversation and laughter as plates of golden fish keep emerging from the kitchen.
4. The Wisco Supper Club
Younger owners have breathed new life into this Le Roy establishment while honoring supper club traditions. Their beer-battered fish fry strikes the perfect balance between innovation and nostalgia.
Farm-to-table sides complement the perfectly crisp fish. The recently renovated space maintains vintage charm with updated comforts – think classic brandy old fashioneds served in a space where grandparents and grandkids equally feel at home.
5. Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club
Milwaukee residents no longer need to drive hours north for authentic supper club atmosphere. Buckatabon brings Northwoods charm to Wauwatosa, complete with taxidermy and knotty pine.
Their Friday fish fry reflects Wisconsin tradition, often offering choices like beer-battered, breaded, or occasionally baked fish. Potato pancakes or fries round out the classic sides. Friendly servers share the history behind this urban homage to up-north dining.
6. Norwood Pines Supper Club
Snowmobilers, lake-goers, and locals all converge on this Minocqua-area landmark when Friday arrives. The massive stone fireplace warms the rustic dining room where generations have gathered for fish fry.
Their walleye comes straight from local waters, prepared simply to let the quality shine. Between bites, take in the vintage Northwoods artifacts decorating walls and the genuine hospitality that makes Wisconsin supper clubs special.
7. Buck-A-Neer Supper Club
Community spirit defines this Stratford landmark, recently saved when locals rallied to keep it open. Friday nights transform the parking lot into a gathering of license plates from every surrounding county.
The fish fry here is straightforward excellence – perfectly breaded haddock with homemade tartar sauce. Regulars chat across tables while newcomers quickly feel like family in the unpretentious dining room that’s been serving central Wisconsin for over 40 years.
8. Ishnala Supper Club
Nestled among towering pines overlooking Mirror Lake, Ishnala offers a fish fry experience that feeds both stomach and soul. Floor-to-ceiling windows showcase nature’s splendor as you dine.
Their walleye pike comes perfectly golden, accompanied by traditional Wisconsin sides. What makes this place special? Perhaps it’s the dramatic approach through the forest or the historic Native American heritage celebrated throughout the space.
9. Cedar Lodge Supper Club
Stunning Lake Winnebago views accompany your fish fry at this Malone treasure. Summer evenings find boats docking directly at the restaurant, while winter brings ice fishermen straight from the lake to dinner.
Their fish plates arrive golden and abundant, often featuring perch or other regional favorites when available. The vintage boating memorabilia throughout the dining room celebrates the lake culture that defines this region and makes Cedar Lodge a true Wisconsin experience.
10. Dreamland Supper Club
Near the Wisconsin-Minnesota border sits this South Range gem, serving Lake Superior’s finest fish since the 1930s. The original neon sign welcomes you to a place where recipes haven’t changed in generations.
Their legendary fish fry features a variety of freshwater fish alongside traditional cod options. Red vinyl booths, wood paneling, and vintage photos create the quintessential Wisconsin supper club atmosphere that keeps families returning decade after decade.
