12 Must-Try South Carolina Pizza Joints Locals Can’t Stop Raving About
You can tell a lot about a town by how it treats its pizza, and South Carolina treats it like a beloved friend worth driving thousands of miles for!
From wood fired char and tangy red sauce to buttery square slices that crunch at the edge, the state is stacked with pies that punch above their weight.
Resisting the urge to reveal some of the finest Palmetto State pizza secrets, I decided to bring you something of a delicious list.
I’ve mapped out a hungry road loop to help you, too, taste what locals have been raving about in their reviews!
Consider this your friendly nudge to grab the keys, call a buddy, and chase the slices that make detours feel like destiny.
1. EVO Pizzeria
EVO Pizzeria feels like the neighborhood anchor where the wood fired glow pulls you in before the menu even opens.
Should you follow the map that leads you to 1075 E Montague Ave, North Charleston, you’ll find EVO right in the heart of the street.
The service here moves with a confident rhythm, waters refilled, pies dropped hot, and a smile that reads welcome back even on a first visit.
The seasonal salads crunch like they were picked an hour ago, and the house mozzarella melts soft!
But, I kept hearing about the pistachio pesto and the tangy red sauce, so these would be the top recommendations as they both land with bright, clean flavor that lets the dough do the talking.
The crust is springy with a gentle chew, a char that crackles at the rim, and just enough smoke to frame the toppings.
Locals are right about the balance here, nothing overloaded, everything tuned for that next bite.
The Margherita snaps with basil perfume while the Old School layers fennel sausage and onions like a greatest hits record.
I would drive for the lemony finish on the arugula pie alone, but the cozy street patio seals the deal.
2. Indaco
Indaco is what takes pizza night and dresses it in Charleston cool, all flicker and flourish from the open hearth.
You will find the joint at 526 King St in the city of Charleston!
This trendy spot brings the best of rustic Italian pizza to the Lowcountry, featuring wood-fired pies with a perfect balance of flavors.
Their open kitchen lets you watch as the pizza cooks to perfection in the blazing oven, and you can smell the aromas from the moment you walk in.
One of my favorites at Indaco is the Margherita Pizza, a simple but incredible pie with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a rich, tangy tomato sauce.
Still, if you’re looking for something a bit more adventurous, try the Black Pepper Tagliatelle that will give you a ride for your money: a generous helping of spice and a delightful hint of sweetness, a perfect balance of the force, if you will!
Even with style points, the vibe stays welcoming, never stiff.
Share a pie, then another, because the size is perfect for tasting through the list without tapping out early.
Oh, and don’t forget to save some room for a creamy panna cotta, but honestly, that final crust dip in tomato is the memory that lingers.
3. Famulari’s
Famulari’s wears two hats and pulls off both, flipping from foldable New York slices to legit Chicago style deep dish.
The shop sits at 1000 Tanner Ford Blvd unit 310, Hanahan.
The restaurant’s cozy, inviting atmosphere is perfect for enjoying their delicious, hand-crafted pizzas, which are known for their perfect crust, gooey cheese, and fresh toppings.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or enjoying a leisurely dinner, this is a spot you won’t want to miss.
The Famulari’s Deluxe pizza is a crowd favorite, with a great combination of pepperoni, mozzarella, mushrooms, and green peppers.
For those of us who are more adventurous, the Chokes-n-Chicken is a must-try, topped with grilled chicken, pesto sauce, and a generous helping of mozzarella.
Trust me, it’s as good as it sounds.
And let’s not forget their garlic knots, they are an absolute game-changer!
The best part of Famulari’s is the consistency.
Every slice was balanced and perfectly presented, but not just for your Instagram photos!
So, if you’re looking to fill your belly with some authentic pizza from the heart of South Carolina, bring a crowd, split a thin pie and a deep one, and argue over winners while every plate empties at this lovely joint!
4. Coastal Crust
When I dropped by Coastal Crust, I was instantly charmed by the rustic, cozy vibe, the exposed brick walls, and a casual, welcoming atmosphere perfect for a laid‑back dinner or pizza night with friends.
Situated at 1254 Pendleton Street in Greenville, the joint offers particularly popular Neapolitan‑style pies that just draw you in.
Just think: perfectly baked crusts with just the right amount of char and a thin, crisp base that holds fresh toppings beautifully!
One memorable pizza was their sausage pie, which is a savory fennel sausage combined with caramelized onions and smoky mozzarella that creates a lovely balance of flavors.
The crust came out wood‑fired to perfection, crispy yet tender.
Beyond the pizza, I learned Coastal Crust also does a solid panini and offers craft beer and wine, so you’ve got choices if you’re not craving a whole pie.
It’s that kind of laid‑back, good‑food hangout that feels like a treat whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for a slow dinner!
5. Tito’s Restaurant Pizzeria
Tito’s immediately gives off that classic pizzeria vibe: simple, no-frills, and focused on solid, comforting pizza that hits the spot.
You can find the place in Greenville at 2018 N Pleasantburg Dr!
More importantly, you’ll definitely be able to see how friendly and welcoming the staff was.
I dare say, with, admittedly, some exaggeration to serve the purpose, that Tito’s pies are slices of heaven, especially when you’re craving something hearty and familiar.
But you can always go for a classic pizza, too: generous pepperoni and cheese on a robust crust that wasn’t too thin, nicely baked, and had a reliable chew.
The flavor is straightforward, but in the best way. Nothing fancy, just good pizza done right.
So, remember: if you’re looking for a cozy, laid‑back spot where the focus stays on good pizza and good vibes, Tito’s is exactly that kind of place.
I’d call it a go-to when you want to ditch pretension and just enjoy a classic pie.
6. Myle’s Pizza Club
Myle’s Pizza Club hits that modern pie shop groove with crisp edges, bright toppings, and a playlist that keeps the energy up.
If you find yourself with some extra time while in Greenville, you can find the joint at 555 S Pleasantburg Dr
So, what makes Myle’s so special?
Let’s go with the dough: baked thin but elastic,with a light chew that stands up to saucy enthusiasm without wilting.
I went heavy on the hot honey pep and loved the sweet heat against a peppery red sauce.
The shroom pie pops with herby olive oil and a squeeze of lemon that wakes everything up.
Service is fast and friendly, with helpful nudges toward limited specials and a quick overview of the oven timing.
Overall, the flavors are clean with a nice crunch, and the pie arrived exactly like that, blistered and balanced.
And let’s not forget! They offer some craft sodas that round out the set without crowding the focus.
Essentially, if you like your pizza bright, light, and ready for a second round, this clubhouse fits the mood.
7. Parcheggio Pizza
Pizza Parcheggio is one of those spots that instantly feels like a hidden gem.
Tucked away off Woodruff Road in Greenville, at 775 Woodruff Rd J2, it’s the perfect place to escape the hustle and enjoy a delicious meal.
The atmosphere is relaxed yet lively, with friendly staff who make you feel right at home as you browse the menu full of tempting options.
I suggest going straight for their Margherita Pizza.
The crust is thin, crispy, and perfectly charred from the oven, giving it that signature flavor I personally adore.
The fresh mozzarella and basil were spot on, and the rich tomato sauce tied it all together. It’s simple, but oh-so-good.
The Pepperoni Pizza here is finger-licking good, too, with generous toppings, plenty of cheese, and just the right amount of spice.
If you’re in the mood for some no-nonsense, flavorful pizza, Pizza Parcheggio is certainly the place for you!
It’s a fantastic place for a casual dinner with friends or a laid-back family meal.
And with the generous portions, you’re definitely going to leave full and satisfied.
8. Frankie’s NY Pizza
If you’re craving a classic New York-style slice, Frankie’s NY Pizza at 101B The Parkway in Greenville is a must-visit.
Nestled on The Parkway, this pizzeria does it right, serving up big, foldable slices with all the iconic flavors that make NY pizza so irresistible.
As soon as you step in, the aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, and you just know you’re in the right place.
I opted for a Classic Cheese Pizza, and I couldn’t have been happier.
The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the cheese had that satisfying melt that pulls when you lift a slice.
It’s exactly what you want from a NY-style pizza.
The Pepperoni Pizza here is another fan favorite, with the pepperoni crisping up perfectly as it bakes, adding that irresistible salty bite.
There’s something about the balance of flavors here that just makes every bite better than the last.
Basically, Frankie’s is casual and unpretentious, making it the perfect spot for grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a full meal with friends.
With consistently great pizza and an inviting vibe, this place has earned its reputation as one of Greenville’s top pizza spots.
9. Thirsty Fellow Pizzeria & Pub
Thirsty Fellow Pizzeria & Pub is a Columbia favorite, and for good reason.
Located on Gadsden Street, specifically at 621 Gadsden Street, this cozy spot combines great pizza with a fun pub atmosphere.
Whether you’re grabbing a bite after work or enjoying a relaxed dinner with friends, Thirsty Fellow offers the perfect balance of good food and good vibes.
Thirsty Fellow is special regarding one more thing: their Stone-Fired Pizza.
Let me tell you: it did not disappoint.
The crust was slightly thicker than what I’m used to, but it was soft and chewy on the inside with a nice crisp on the outside.
The onions were fresh, and the pepperoni was simply delicious!
What I love about this place is the welcoming, relaxed environment, where you can sip a cold beverage while enjoying a hearty slice.
So, if you’re in the mood for pizza or a pint (or both!), Thirsty Fellow hits the spot every time.
It’s no wonder it’s a popular hangout in Columbia!
10. Schiano’s
When you’re in the mood for classic, no-frills pizza in Columbia, Schiano’s is the spot.
Nestled on 4839 Forest Drive in Columbia, this pizzeria offers a menu that hits all the right notes. It’s simple, hearty, and satisfying.
The restaurant’s welcoming vibe makes it perfect for a quick bite or a casual dinner with friends.
The service is excellent and the staff welcoming, making you feel like you’ve just come back home after a long day at work.
Their pizza was just what I expected, and mind you, I tend to set my expectations high: a crispy, thin crust with rich tomato sauce and gooey cheese.
The pasta, by the way, is no exception so if you’re looking for something beyond pizza, definitely go for it!
If you’re in the Columbia area and craving a straightforward pizza experience, Schiano’s is definitely worth a visit.
If you don’t feel like sitting down, feel free to order takeout because it will be done and ready before you can say Schiano’s!
With its no-nonsense approach to pizza, it’s honestly easy to see why this place has such a loyal following.
11. Village Idiot Pizza
Village Idiot Pizza brings that funky college town slice swagger with friendly chaos and pies that hold up past midnight.
The spot sits at 2009 Devine St, Columbia and the moment you walk in, you’ll feel the chill atmosphere with its eclectic decor and friendly vibe!
The slices here are big and foldable, and salty in the best way, with a tangy sauce that stands out even after a long night.
My recommendation?
Go big or go home, aka try the Godfather or dive straight into another special of theirs: the White Pizza Paradise.
Godfather will soothe your palate with its perfect balance of Italian sausage, onion, and green pepper, while the White Pizza Paradise will treat you like a dear, ol’ friend.
Its selection of delicious white base, perfectly roasted red peppers, capers, onions and a touch of garlic makes this a top choice for those of us who crave something unique.
So, if you’re looking to spend a casual night with friends or if you’re seeking a unique spot to take your date to, Village Idiot Pizza is a must!
You’ll leave with a full tummy and stars in your eyes!
12. AJ’s Pizza
If you’re heading to Myrtle Beach and want a pizza joint that feels like home, AJ’s Pizza is the place to be.
Located on 5917 North Kings Highway, this spot has all the charm of a classic pizza parlor, with friendly service and some seriously good pies.
It doesn’t matter whether you’re coming off the beach or just craving a delicious slice.
AJ’s is the perfect place to kick back and enjoy some top-notch pizza.
I decided to try their Meatlover Pizza, and it definitely hit the spot.
The crust was soft and chewy with a nice, crispy edge, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio was spot on.
Not to mention the balance that bacon, ground beef and Italian sausage bring to the table…literally.
AJ’s also gets high marks for their Chicken Alfredo Pizza, with crispy edges on the chicken, bacon that melts in your mouth and plenty of cheese to write home about.
It’s the kind of place where the pizza is reliably good, and the casual, laid-back atmosphere makes you want to hang out and enjoy your meal.
