10 Kentucky Amish Markets That Locals Swear By For Holiday Baking Supplies
Your holiday baking list is long, and your pantry is looking awfully thin. The big box store wants a small fortune for a tiny jar of cinnamon.
Most of us sigh, pay up, and promise to bake fewer cookies next year. There is a smarter way to stock up, and it might come with a hitching post out front.
Amish markets across Kentucky sell baking basics by the scoop, the bag, and sometimes the bucket. You can find flour, spices, and colorful sprinkles without draining your wallet.
Many shelves also hold homemade jams, noodles, and treats that look suspiciously like cheating. The locals already know which stores are worth the drive.
Now you get to borrow their secrets for your own holiday kitchen. Make a list before you go, because you will want everything.
Check the hours, since many of these stores close on Sundays. Then go preheat the oven.
1. Habegger’s Amish Market

Your spice drawer is about to feel seriously outclassed. This Scottsville grocery stocks pre-weighed bags of flours, herbs, spices, beans, and candies, each one ready to grab and go.
That pre-weighed setup is a quiet gift during holiday baking season. You skip the scooping and measuring, then head home with exactly what your recipes call for.
Shelves of jarred goods fill out the rest of the story. Look for jams, jellies, pickled vegetables, salsa, and pasta sauces lined up like a colorful pantry parade.
A jar of homemade jam makes a handy last-minute gift, too. Tuck one into a basket with a loaf of fresh bread, and you’ve got a present nobody will regift.
Speaking of bread, the bakery side turns out fresh baked goods for shoppers with a sweet tooth. The deli also makes sandwiches, which comes in handy when browsing spice bags makes you hungry.
Fresh produce and flowers round out the shop, so your holiday table can get some color. A small bouquet next to a pie never hurt anybody’s dessert presentation.
Timing matters here, since the market runs Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. Saturdays are the busiest, so a weekday trip usually means a calmer stroll down the aisles.
Allen County’s country backroads lead the way, and a free parking lot waits when you arrive. Bring a sturdy tote, because those little bags of spices add up fast.
Address: 415 Perrytown Rd, Scottsville, KY 42164
2. Detweiler Country Store

Few grocery runs end with a stop at the fishing section, but here it’s practically tradition. Detweiler Country Store packs a grocery, a general store, and an outdoor shop onto one Hart County property.
Bakers should head straight for the grocery side first. The bulk food selection is large, and the pricing on those staples stays very fair.
That matters when your holiday list calls for five batches of cookies instead of one. Stocking up on bulk ingredients lets you bake big without wincing at the receipt.
Fresh baked goods sit right alongside the bulk bins. If your own pie crust stages a rebellion, you have a tasty backup plan within arm’s reach.
A deli makes sandwiches, too, so lunch can happen without leaving the property. Honestly, you’ll probably need the fuel for what comes next.
The general store carries a wide variety of merchandise beyond food. Outside, rows of composite outdoor furniture and yard art spread across the grounds in impressive numbers.
Then there’s the outdoor store, stocked with fishing supplies, hunting gear, and knives. It’s a sneaky way to finish holiday shopping for the person who never wants another sweater.
Hours run 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays and 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. on Saturdays. Sundays are closed, and Saturdays bring the heaviest traffic.
A free parking lot makes the stop easy, even with a trunk full of flour sacks. Cub Run’s winding roads are part of the fun.
Address: 12825 Priceville Rd, Cub Run, KY 42729
3. Country Pantry

Half the price, twice the cinnamon. That’s the kind of math that makes holiday bakers very happy, and this Guthrie shop delivers it.
Country Pantry is owned and run by an Amish family in Todd County. The surrounding area is home to extensive Amish farm settlements, so the store fits right into its rural neighborhood.
Seasonings and spices are the big draw here. They come in large amounts at prices that run around half of what many other stores charge.
Think about how fast you burn through nutmeg, ginger, and cloves in December. Buying bigger bags means fewer emergency runs in the middle of a gingerbread project.
The store also leans hard into bulk options and unprocessed goods. If you like baking from scratch with simple ingredients, you’ll feel right at home in these aisles.
Specialty items show up on the shelves too, which makes browsing part of the appeal. You might come for flour and leave with something you didn’t know your recipe needed.
Plan around the schedule, which runs Monday through Saturday from 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Friday afternoons and Saturdays get the busiest, so earlier in the week is calmer.
A restroom is available, which is good news after a long drive through Kentucky farm country. Shopping here is typically a quick visit, so it pairs nicely with other stops nearby.
Address: 9115 Guthrie Rd #8641, Guthrie, KY 42234
4. R & S Salvage Groceries

Grocery shopping turns into a treasure hunt at this Horse Cave salvage store. Beyond the staples, you never quite know what will land on the shelves, but the prices tend to run low.
The dependable basics are easy to count on. Milk, eggs, and an amazing selection of bulk dry goods cover the core of most holiday recipes.
Now for the part your sweet tooth cares about. The in-house bakery turns out donuts, breads, cakes, homemade Amish fruit pies, and fried pies.
Fried pies alone might justify the trip. They make an easy dessert for a family gathering when your oven is already booked solid.
An in-house deli adds Amish meats and cheeses at very friendly prices. A holiday snack tray practically builds itself from that counter.
Canned goods and a large selection of freezer items round out the inventory. Stocking the freezer before company arrives is a smart move here.
Fresh produce also earns a spot on the list. Grab some fruit for pies while you’re filling your basket with baking basics.
Horse Cave sits in Hart County, a small Kentucky town known for its rural countryside and cave history. The store keeps hours of 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays and 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. on Saturdays.
Saturdays bring the busiest stretch, while early-week days stay quieter. On-site parking and a restroom make the stop simple.
Address: 235 Irvin Cemetary Rd, Irving Cemetery Rd, Horse Cave, KY 42749
5. Ottenheim Country Store

Some of the best pantry stops come in small packages. Ottenheim Country Store is owned and operated by an Amish family in rural Lincoln County.
Bulk dry goods make up the heart of the shelves here. For holiday bakers, that’s where the flour, sugar, and oats conversation usually starts.
Buying dry goods in bulk has a clear perk during the busy season. You can grab the exact amount your recipes need instead of guessing with prepackaged boxes.
Specialty food items add some variety to the mix. Browse slowly, since a new ingredient might inspire a twist on your usual cookie lineup.
Fresh produce also lines up alongside the pantry goods. A few fresh apples or pumpkins could turn into this year’s best pie.
A simple tip helps a lot with stores like this. Bring your recipe list, because a focused plan keeps you from forgetting the baking soda again.
Hours run 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. on weekdays. Saturday hours are shorter, wrapping up at 3 p.m., and the store stays closed on Sundays.
That early Saturday close catches people off guard, so plan your weekend drive with care. Showing up at 3:15 with an empty cookie tin is nobody’s idea of fun.
Waynesburg is an unincorporated crossroads community with deep farming roots. The drive along KY-643 gives you a quiet slice of Kentucky countryside before the shopping starts.
Address: 5920 KY-643, Waynesburg, KY 40489
6. Amish Goods & Bulk Food Store

Flip a light switch here and you’ll be waiting a long time. This Hazel Green shop runs without electric lights, keeping things simple in true Amish fashion.
That also means the sodas aren’t cold. Grab one anyway for the road, but don’t expect an icy fizz.
The real reason to visit sits on the baking shelves. The flour and cornmeal earn praise for good quality, which matters when a recipe depends on them.
Cornbread fans, take note before your next holiday dinner. Quality cornmeal can be the difference between crumbly and wonderful.
Shelves stay well stocked with a decent selection beyond those two staples. Expect a no-fuss bulk food setup rather than a sprawling supermarket.
A tip for shopping by daylight: visit earlier in the day for the brightest view of the shelves. Labels are easier to read when the sun is doing the work.
The store opens Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. Sundays are closed, so weekend bakers should aim for Saturday.
Hazel Green is a tiny, quiet hamlet in the Wolfe County foothills. The drive feels peaceful, and the store makes for a quick, practical stop.
One more pointer: the address uses a map code instead of a street number. Plug it into your navigation app before you lose signal in the hills.
Address: RH65+C8, Hazel Green, KY 41332
7. Yoder’s Country Market

Pennsylvania-style Amish cooking found a home in the Kentucky mountains. Yoder’s Country Market brings that flavor to Hindman, a small Appalachian town in Knott County.
Part grocery and part general store, the market covers plenty of ground. Homemade baked goods, spices, and fresh produce lead the lineup.
Bulk foods are where holiday bakers will want to linger. Buying in bulk saves money and lets you pick quantities that suit your plans.
Need just a little molasses-friendly spice for one batch of cookies? You can buy small, or go big if your family treats December like a baking marathon.
Spices deserve their own shout-out here. A fresh stash makes a noticeable difference in pumpkin bread and spice cakes.
Freshly made sandwiches keep shoppers fueled, which is helpful after a mountain drive. Flowers also brighten the shelves if your table needs a festive touch.
Watch the clock when you plan your trip. Weekday hours run 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., while Saturday runs a shorter 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Sundays are closed, so weekday visits give you more breathing room. A restroom is available too, a small mercy on a long country drive.
Hindman has under 800 residents, which makes the market a handy local stop. It’s proof that great baking supplies aren’t limited to big towns.
Address: 1319 Hindman Bypass, Hindman, KY 41822
8. D.G. Miller Groceries

Maple syrup and honey in a Christian County farm store? Yes, and your holiday breakfasts are about to get a serious upgrade.
D.G. Miller Groceries is a well kept Amish store outside Pembroke.
Tidy shelves make it easy to find what you need without hunting.
Bulk foods form the backbone of the inventory. Bakers can stock up on staples and skip the tiny boxes from big chain stores.
Dried fruit is another gem for holiday recipes. Toss it into fruitcake, granola, or oatmeal cookies for a chewy, sweet boost.
Those jars of honey and bottles of maple syrup pull double duty. Use them in baking, or drizzle them over pancakes on a slow holiday morning.
Herbs show up on the shelves as well, handy for savory dishes alongside the sweets. Snacks and canned food also help round out a pantry before guests arrive.
The store goes beyond food, too. Essential oils, vitamins, and natural remedies share space with the groceries.
That mix makes it a nice stop if you’re shopping for more than flour and sugar. You might cross a few gift ideas off your list while you’re there.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Pembroke sits among farmland, so the drive comes with plenty of open Kentucky scenery.
Address: 1525 Barkers Mill Rd, Pembroke, KY 42266
9. Sunny Valley Country Store LLC

Organic rolled oats can be weirdly hard to track down. Here, they sit among the bulk foods like it’s no big deal.
Sunny Valley Country Store sits in the South Fork Old Order Amish settlement near Liberty. Casey County’s farming valley surrounds it with plenty of rural scenery.
Bulk food lovers get lots of choices. Dry goods and dried herbs line the shelves, giving bakers a strong start on holiday prep.
Oatmeal cookies, fruit crisps, and homemade granola all benefit from those oats. It’s an easy way to stock up before the baking frenzy kicks off.
Kitchen supplies make this stop extra useful. Rada Cutlery is on hand, which could solve a gift dilemma or replace that dull paring knife.
Hungry? Made-to-order deli sandwiches and fresh baked goods are ready when you are.
And yes, soft serve ice cream is part of the deal. Holiday shopping doesn’t have to mean skipping dessert.
Homegrown fruits and vegetables add a seasonal touch to the mix. Fresh produce pairs nicely with pie plans.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Saturday afternoon gets busiest, while Monday morning is the calmest window.
Free parking comes in both a lot and along the street. That makes loading up heavy bags of oats a lot less of a workout.
Address: 2767 S Fork Creek Rd, Liberty, KY 42539
10. Shellma’s Country Market, Formerly Family Food Market LLC Amish Market

A new name doesn’t erase a good reputation. Shellma’s Country Market used to go by Family Food Market LLC Amish Market, and the Amish-style shopping experience carries on.
Baked goods are a big part of the appeal. Pies and cinnamon rolls headline the prepared foods, which feels tailor-made for holiday season.
Think of those cinnamon rolls as a Christmas morning shortcut. You get the treat without setting an alarm for dough duty.
Pies offer the same kind of rescue for busy hosts. Pick one up when your own baking schedule gets out of hand.
Organic products fill out the shelves for shoppers who care about ingredients. That’s helpful when you want cleaner basics for homemade recipes.
Sandwiches round out the prepared food lineup. Grab one for the drive, since Gravel Switch sits out in rolling Marion County hills.
Prices also stay friendly, which matters when the holiday budget gets stretched thin. Stocking up feels a lot less painful here.
In-store pickup is available, a smart option during the busy season. Free Wi-Fi is offered too, handy if you need to check a recipe mid-aisle.
The market opens Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Free parking in a lot and on the street keeps the stop easy on US-68.
Address: 5581 US-68, Gravel Switch, KY 40328
