This Old-Fashioned Pennsylvania Candy Shop Says It Invented The Heart-Shaped Box Of Chocolates
A 16-year-old opened this candy shop in 1897, and the company claims it later invented the heart-shaped box of chocolates.
That’s a big claim for a small-town sweet shop. I like it already.
The story gets better. A beloved peanut butter candy here was perfected with help from Penn State food scientists in the early 1960s.
Somewhere in Pennsylvania, a candy recipe went to college.
Today, the flagship store packs a candy counter, a free museum, and an old-fashioned ice cream parlor under one roof.
Penny candy still sits in its own nook. Antique candy-making gear rests nearby like retired heroes.
I believe holiday shopping should feel this sweet. With Advent calendars, Santa-shaped treats, and pretzel pails on the shelves, the season gets plenty of help here.
So where exactly is this place hiding?
A Candy Store That Keeps Going The Farther You Walk

Gardners Candies sits in downtown Tyrone, a small central Pennsylvania town with a big chocolate reputation. The flagship store holds three attractions in one stop.
You get a retail candy shop, a free candy museum, and an old-fashioned ice cream parlour. That’s a lot of sweetness for one address.
The candy side runs large, with traditional chocolates, chocolate-covered pretzels, roasted nuts, gummies, and bulk confections. Penny candy still has a home here too.
Kids tend to treat that corner like a treasure chest.
The museum sits between the shop and the parlour. It shows off the company’s long history with vintage equipment and packaging.
Then the ice cream counter waits at the back with Hershey’s Ice Cream.
This place earns its spot on a holiday drive for one simple reason. It mixes shopping, history, and dessert without asking you to drive anywhere else.
That’s efficient joy.
Gardners Candies also runs other stores across central Pennsylvania, but Tyrone is the original home. The factory sits nearby on the hill above town.
So the candy you buy downtown doesn’t travel far before it lands in your bag.
That kind of closeness feels rare now. It also makes the holiday stop feel personal.
How A Teenager With A Horse-Drawn Wagon Started It All

James “Pike” Gardner was just sixteen when he opened a small candy store in Tyrone in 1897. Most teens that age were thinking about chores, not chocolate empires.
Pike started simple. He sold candy, popcorn, and peanuts from his shop.
He also loaded treats onto a horse-drawn wagon and hauled them to local fairs and carnivals. Picture the hustle of that, minus the word picture.
A teenager with a wagon full of sweets was basically the original food truck.
That go-getter spirit carried the business for decades. Pike kept the company growing until his passing in 1951.
His daughter Nancy Black and her husband David Black then took over. They kept the family name and the family standards in place.
That handoff mattered, because it set up one of the company’s biggest successes.
In 1997, Bill Sarris of Sarris Candies acquired the company. The Gardners name stayed, and so did Pike’s focus on quality.
The company now celebrates more than 125 years of candy-making in Pennsylvania. Not many small-town businesses can say that.
Fewer can say it started with a teenager, a wagon, and a bag of peanuts.
History rarely tastes this good.
The Heart-Shaped Box Story You Probably Never Heard

Every Valentine’s Day, stores fill up with heart-shaped chocolate boxes. Gardners Candies claims it got there first.
According to the company, the idea took shape in 1910. Pike Gardner teamed up with a local cigar-box maker to build something special.
Together, they created unique boxes decorated with satin. The heart shape turned a box of candy into a gift that felt romantic before the lid even opened.
Smart move, Pike.
The heart-shaped box later became a staple across the candy industry. That’s why this claim tends to make people pause.
A small Tyrone candy maker possibly shaped one of the most familiar gifts in America.
The partnership with a box maker also says a lot about the town back then. Local craftsmen worked together and solved problems with what they had.
Packaging became part of the treat.
Today, the holiday season keeps that gift-box spirit alive at the store. Tins, pails, and assortments still show how much presentation matters here.
Chocolate always tastes better when it arrives looking dressed up.
You don’t need February to appreciate the story. It makes every holiday gift box on the shelf feel like part of a longer Pennsylvania tale.
That’s a fun thing to know at the register.
The Peanut Butter Meltaway That Went To College

Ask what put Gardners Candies on the map, and one answer comes up fast. It’s the Original Peanut Butter Meltaway.
David Black developed it in the early 1960s. He worked with the Penn State University Food Science Department to perfect the creamy blend.
That’s right, a candy got academic help in Pennsylvania. Somewhere, a food scientist took notes on peanut butter.
The result became the company’s signature product and best-seller.
The company describes the meltaways as cloud-like squares of whipped peanut butter. Each one gets a thick coating of Gardners milk chocolate.
That description alone should test anyone’s willpower.
The meltaway line has grown over the years with other flavors too. Cappuccino meltaways appear among the options, along with several more varieties.
But the original still holds the crown.
During the holidays, the meltaway even shows up in festive forms. Some novelties are shaped like Santa.
It’s hard to imagine a happier stocking surprise.
Peanut butter and chocolate fans in Pennsylvania already have plenty of choices. This one carries more than sixty years of history and a college connection.
Good luck stopping at just one square.
Santa Gets Help From A Very Sweet Workshop

December turns this candy shop into a gift-giver’s headquarters. Holiday Specialties and Stocking Stuffers fill the shelves each season.
The Advent Calendar is a fun place to start. Each door hides a sweet surprise leading up to December 25th.
Countdowns rarely felt this rewarding as a kid. Now adults can get in on the fun too.
Nobody’s checking whose calendar it really is.
Christmas Tin Deluxe Assortments make an easy gift for coworkers, teachers, or grandparents. Holiday Pretzel Pails bring the salty-sweet crowd into the mix.
Then there are the Original Peanut Butter Meltaway Novelties, some shaped like Santa.
Holiday cookie trays already rule many Pennsylvania kitchens this time of year. A few chocolates tucked beside them never hurt anyone.
Consider it a tray upgrade.
The seasonal lineup can change from year to year. So it’s smart to check ahead if you’re hunting for a specific item.
Popular gifts may not wait on the shelf forever.
Shopping here also feels different than grabbing candy at a big-box store. These treats come from a company that has been making candy in Tyrone for well over a century.
That backstory makes a nice gift tag.
A Free Museum Full Of Copper Kettles And Old Molds

Free admission and candy history in the same sentence? That’s a deal worth noticing.
The Gardners Candy Museum adjoins the retail area and the ice cream parlour. It walks visitors through the company’s long story.
Displays include antique candy-making equipment like copper kettles. Historic molds and vintage packaging round out the collection.
It’s a peek at how candy came together long before modern machines.
The museum also includes a video tour of the factory. That gives you a look at how today’s candy gets made.
It’s a handy way to connect the old tools with the current process.
Older items add extra fun, including vintage scales and old ice cream freezers. A Coca-Cola machine from the 1920s also appears in the space.
Grandparents may spot a few things from their own childhoods.
The museum isn’t huge, and that’s part of its appeal. You can explore it at an easy pace before grabbing a sundae.
Kids get history in bite-size pieces.
Families on a budget will appreciate the price tag of zero. A holiday outing doesn’t need to empty the wallet to feel special.
This stop helps stretch the fun without stretching the budget.
Hershey’s Ice Cream Waits In The Back For A Reason

Candy first, then ice cream. That order feels right, and the store layout seems to agree.
The old-fashioned Ice Cream Parlour serves Hershey’s Ice Cream. You can choose classic sundaes, milkshakes, or hand-dipped cones.
The space carries a retro feel that matches the store’s long history. It’s the kind of parlor that makes a winter cone sound reasonable.
Pennsylvanians rarely let cold weather stop dessert anyway.
Generous scoops show up again and again in descriptions of this parlor. Gluten-free options are also part of the lineup.
That’s a nice touch for families with different needs.
Flavors rotate, so check the case when you arrive. Rich chocolate options and peanut butter twists have appeared before.
Picking just one can turn into a family debate.
The parlor also gives the visit a natural ending. You browse, explore the museum, and then sit down with something cold.
It turns a shopping trip into a real outing.
Ice cream prices may run higher than they once did. Still, sharing a big bowl can stretch the treat.
Bring an extra spoon and make friends.
The parlor sits right inside the flagship store, so no second stop is needed.
Planning Your Sweet Stop In Tyrone

Finding the flagship store is easy. Gardners Candies sits at 30 W. 10th Street, Tyrone, PA 16686.
Tyrone lies in Blair County in central Pennsylvania. It makes a handy stop for drivers heading through the region.
Street parking is often available nearby. That helps during busy holiday shopping runs.
Nobody wants to circle the block with a sweet tooth.
The store generally opens seven days a week, with shorter hours on Sundays. Hours can shift around holidays, though.
Check ahead before making the drive.
Prices vary depending on what you choose. Penny candy keeps things cheap for kids.
Boxed chocolates and milkshakes cost more, so set a budget if needed.
The museum is free, which helps balance the spending. A family can explore history without paying a dime.
Then everyone can pick one treat.
Can’t make the trip? Gardners also ships chocolates to customers far away.
Other store locations operate in places like Altoona, State College, Huntingdon, and Johnstown.
Still, the Tyrone store offers the full experience. The museum and parlour make it more than a quick candy grab.
Give yourself time to wander.
