9 Kentucky Bakeries Baking The Kind Of Old-Fashioned Pies Your Family Will Fight Over

featured image 25222d510441 61e895aebdfc - Decor Hint

Every family has that one relative who guards the last slice of pie like a treasure. Maybe that relative is actually you.

No judgment here, because good pie deserves protection. The trouble is that truly old-fashioned pie is getting harder to find.

Too many crusts taste like cardboard with a fancy name. Too many fillings come from a can and pretend otherwise.

Luckily, Kentucky still has bakers who refuse to cut corners. They roll dough the way grandmothers did and fill it with flavors that feel like home.

You will find flaky crusts, glossy meringues, and fried pies that crackle when you bite them. Some of these spots are famous in their towns, while others are worth a scenic drive.

Either way, you should bring a big appetite and a very sturdy pie box. Just remember that whoever carries the pie into the house gets to choose the first slice.

1. The Midway Bakery And Cafe

The Midway Bakery And Cafe
© The Midway Bakery and Cafe

School lunch never looked this good. The Midway Bakery and Cafe opened in 2012 in the basement of the old Midway School, right where the cafeteria used to be.

You can still spot the cream and aqua subway tile from the 1940s. It’s a fun reminder that this room has fed hungry people for a long time.

The pies here are made from scratch with real butter and traditional recipes. Even better, the crusts use flour from nearby Weisenberger Mill, a Kentucky mill with deep local roots.

So what should you put in your box? Sour Cream Apple Pie and Traditional Pecan Pie lean classic, while Lemon Chiffon Pie feels light and old-school.

Coconut Cream Pie is another familiar favorite. If the kids want something playful, Cookies and Cream Pie and Peanut Butter Mousse Pie should keep them quiet for a few minutes.

The bakery belongs to a well-known chef who runs a group of farm-to-table restaurants in the area. That local focus shows up in the ingredients, including chocolate from Ruth Hunt Candies.

Some recipes even come from family history. The sugar cookies are based on the owner’s great-grandmother’s recipe, which is about as old-fashioned as baking gets.

There’s a small eat-in area plus a patio with a bird feeder. A playground sits next door, which helps when little ones need to burn off sugar.

Plan around the hours, since the bakery runs Monday through Saturday from morning until mid-afternoon. Sundays are closed, so don’t show up then with a pie craving.

Address: 510 S Winter St, Midway, KY 40347

2. Schlabach’s Bakery

Schlabach's Bakery
© Schlabach’s Bakery

Fried pies might be the most dangerous road snack ever invented. At Schlabach’s Bakery in Guthrie, apple and peach versions are menu highlights, and they travel almost too well.

This family-owned Amish and Mennonite bakery keeps things simple. You’ll find handmade breads, cinnamon rolls, donuts, and a range of pies on the shelves.

Chess pie deserves your attention. That sweet, custardy Southern classic is one of those pies grandparents remember fondly, and it gets plenty of love here.

Don’t stop at pie, though. The cinnamon rolls come in more than one flavor, so picking just one could start its own family debate.

Oatmeal cream pie cookies are another treat worth a spot in your bag. They’re a handy bribe for whoever is driving you home.

The store also stocks apple butter, honey, and basket items. Those make sweet gifts if you’re heading to a family dinner and want to look thoughtful.

One quirk to remember: the bakery closes on Thursdays as well as Sundays. It’s open the other days from morning until late afternoon.

Saturdays tend to bring the biggest crowds. If you’d rather browse in peace, a weekday morning is your smarter bet.

There’s no dine-in seating, so think of this as a grab-and-go stop. Bring a cooler bag and maybe a napkin or ten for those fried pies.

Address: 6255 Guthrie Rd, Guthrie, KY 42234

3. Farmwald’s Dutch Bakery & Deli

Farmwald's Dutch Bakery & Deli
© Farmwald’s Dutch Bakery & Deli

Early birds, rejoice. Farmwald’s opens its doors at 5:45 in the morning, Monday through Saturday, so pie for breakfast is technically an option.

We won’t judge. This casual Dutch bakery and deli in Horse Cave is known as a must-stop spot for homemade pies.

Blackberry pie is a classic choice here. It’s the kind of fruit pie that disappears fast at a family cookout, so maybe buy two.

Hand pies and fried pies are another strong move. The crust gets special praise, which matters a lot when the crust is half the fun.

Got a cheesecake fan at home? Farmwald’s makes that too, along with cookies, doughnuts, and soft sourdough bread.

You can also stay for a real meal. The deli serves hearty sandwiches like a ribeye sandwich, a fish sandwich, and something called the Amish Po Boy.

Families will feel right at home. There’s a kids’ menu, high chairs, and outdoor seating where dogs are allowed.

Before you leave, check the shelves for jams and ciders. They make easy souvenirs from your trip through south-central Kentucky.

Saturdays get busy, while weekday afternoons tend to be calmer. Weekday hours stretch into the evening, which makes this a handy dinner stop too.

Address: 3720 L and N Turnpike Rd, Horse Cave, KY 42749

4. Missy’s

Missy's
© Missy’s

Missy left town, but her name stayed behind. In 1989, a diner owner on High Street set up a pie shop for his lead prep cook, and the business kept her name after she moved away.

That shop became Missy’s, and Lexington has been grateful ever since. It specializes in homemade pies and sells them whole or by the slice.

Need proof it can bake? Missy’s won the professional division of the Lexington July 4th Pie Contest in 2005, 2007, 2008, and 2009.

The butterscotch pie wears a light meringue topping over a sweet filling. Black Bottom Banana Pie uses an old-fashioned custard filling, which sounds like a hug in pie form.

Cherry pie comes with a lattice crust, and the buttermilk pie tastes like something from a grandmother’s recipe box. Peanut butter pie is another highlight.

Then come the wild cards. Mayday Pie mixes pecans and chocolate chips, while Combination Pie stacks peanut butter on top of chocolate brownie.

Watching sugar? Ask about the Sugar Free Pie of the Day.

You can also grab soup, sandwiches, or chicken salad from the diner across the street.

In 2014, the shop moved across the road into a remodeled historic building. A small eat-in area lets you enjoy a slice right away.

Missy’s opens seven days a week, from morning until late afternoon. It does close for several major holidays, so plan ahead before Thanksgiving.

Address: 502 E High St, Lexington, KY 40502

5. Hidden Valley Kitchen Baked Goods

Hidden Valley Kitchen Baked Goods
© Hidden Valley Kitchen Baked Goods

Any bakery on Butter Road had better deliver. Lucky for you, Hidden Valley Kitchen Baked Goods in Marion lives up to its delicious address.

This Amish bakery keeps its style plain and old-fashioned. The star attraction is the homemade fried pie, and the flavor lineup is hard to resist.

Fried raisin pie is a true throwback that you rarely see anymore. Cherry and peach cover the fruit lovers, while strawberry and cream adds a softer twist.

Who gets the last raisin one? That’s a fight you’ll have to settle in the car.

Pies aren’t the only temptation here. Homemade yeast rolls, cinnamon rolls, breads, cookies, and donuts all show up on the menu.

The pantry side is just as fun. Shelves hold jams, jellies, canned goods, and pickles, plus fresh flowers for a sweet touch.

Bring cash, because that’s the only payment accepted. This is also a takeout-only stop with no delivery, so you’ll need to make the drive.

Hours run Monday through Saturday from morning to late afternoon. Sundays are closed, which fits the quiet country pace of this corner of western Kentucky.

The staff are known for being polite and friendly. Combine that with fried pies and a road named Butter, and you’ve got a pretty great afternoon.

Address: 301 Butter Rd, Marion, KY 42064

6. Burke’s Bakery & Delicatessen

Burke's Bakery & Delicatessen
© Burke’s Bakery & Delicatessen

Some family recipes get passed down. At Burke’s, the whole bakery did, starting back in 1922.

This Danville favorite is a multi-generational, family-run business. It still prides itself on baking from scratch, which is exactly what you want from an old-fashioned bakery.

Pies sit right on the menu. Apple pie, blueberry pie, and Boston cream pie are among the flavors, and the bakery has also made individual cherry pies.

Here’s your fun history bit. Burke’s is famous for salt-rising bread, a tricky old Appalachian-style loaf that many bakeries simply don’t make anymore.

Butterflake rolls and gingerbread men are other local legends. Add donuts, cakes, and pastries, and your bakery box fills up fast.

You’ll also find deli items and sandwiches. That makes it easy to grab lunch and dessert in the same stop.

Burke’s was named a top three finalist in the 2023 Kentucky Living Best in Kentucky contest. That’s a nice bragging right for a hometown shop.

Keep in mind that there’s no seating and no restroom. Constitution Square sits right across the street, though, so a park bench picnic is a tasty plan.

The bakery opens early on weekdays and Saturdays. It even opens Sunday afternoons, which is handy for after-church pie runs.

Address: 121 W Main St, Danville, KY 40422

7. Georgia’s Sweet Potato Pie Company & Dessert Lounge

Georgia's Sweet Potato Pie Company & Dessert Lounge
© Georgia’s Sweet Potato Pie Company & Dessert Lounge

A storefront that opens on National Pie Day clearly means business. Georgia’s Sweet Potato Pie Company opened its Bardstown Road shop on January 23, the official holiday for pie lovers.

The story started at farmers markets in the fall of 2017. The bakery is named after the founder’s grandmother, who was known for serving her community.

Sweet potato pie is the whole focus here. The crew roasts real sweet potatoes and uses pure vanilla, real butter, and sugar, sticking with old-school techniques.

Start with the Traditional Sweet Potato Pie, spiced with nutmeg and cinnamon. Sweet Potato Pecan Pie adds crunch, while Caramel Crunch layers on pecans, walnuts, and caramel glaze.

Vegan guests aren’t left out. The vegan version uses pure maple syrup, brown sugar, and coconut cream.

Can’t choose? Mini pies come in sampler trays, which is a peaceful solution for families who argue over flavors.

The menu also includes chess pie, sweet potato cheesecakes, fudge brownies, cupcakes, and even sweet potato pie ice cream. Candles are for sale too.

Every purchase supports children’s literacy through book donations. This Black-owned and woman-owned business calls the effort Pies With A Purpose.

Shipping is available across the contiguous United States. In person, plan an afternoon or evening visit from Wednesday through Saturday.

Address: 1559 Bardstown Rd, Louisville, KY 40205

8. Bluegrass Baking Company

Bluegrass Baking Company
© Bluegrass Baking Company

Free samples are the best kind of sales pitch. Bluegrass Baking Company hands out tastes of pies, cookies, and scones, and that’s a risky move for your willpower.

This long-standing Lexington bakery is famous for hearth-baked artisan breads. Its pies hold their own right next to those crusty loaves, though.

Blueberry pie comes packed with whole blueberries. Fresh peach pie is another fruit favorite, especially when you want something that tastes like summer.

Pumpkin pie shows up when the season turns. It’s the classic you’ll want on the table for fall gatherings.

Not feeding a crowd? Mini pies are a smart pick for small households or anyone who wants to try more than one flavor.

Fruit tarts make another pretty option for brunch or a birthday. You can also grab fresh baguettes and seasonal breads to round out the meal.

Coffee is on hand while you shop. There’s no dine-in seating, so expect to take your treasures home.

The shop opens early Tuesday through Saturday. It closes Sunday and Monday, so a Saturday morning stop works well before the weekend family dinner.

A free parking lot makes the visit easy. Just don’t promise anyone you’ll bring home a whole pie untouched.

Address: 3101 Clays Mill Rd #108, Lexington, KY 40503

9. Riley’s Bakery

Riley's Bakery
© Riley’s Bakery

Strawberry pie at Riley’s is a matter of luck. If you spot one in Bowling Green, grab it before somebody else does.

Riley’s Bakery is a traditional hometown shop with a loyal local following. It’s best known for its signature tea cookies and cream horns.

Still, the pies earn their spot on this list. Pumpkin pie and chess pie are both crowd-pleasers, and chess pie is about as Southern as dessert gets.

Picture the holiday table without a fight over the last slice. Okay, that won’t happen, but you can try buying extra.

Sweet tooth still not satisfied? Chocolate and blonde brownies, sugar cookies, and fresh bread are also on offer.

Here’s a fun local pairing. Riley’s serves Chaney’s ice cream, a scoop that goes nicely with those famous tea cookies.

The bakery handles lunch too, with deli-style sandwiches. That makes it a solid stop when you’re exploring southern Kentucky and need a real meal first.

Prices are friendly, and service has a reputation for being quick and courteous. The clean shop keeps things simple.

Plan for Tuesday through Saturday, since Sundays and Mondays are closed. Saturdays wrap up early in the afternoon, so don’t wait too long for that strawberry pie.

Address: 819 U.S. 31 W Bypass, Bowling Green, KY 42101

More to Explore