A 1904 Chicago Collegiate Gothic Gem With Coach House, Restored Marble And Historic Charm
Step back in time with the remarkable residence at 5235 South University Avenue, a 1904 Chicago home that showcases the finest elements of Collegiate Gothic architecture. Standing proudly for over a century, this meticulously preserved property combines historic elegance with thoughtful modern updates.
From its striking coach house to the carefully restored marble features, this architectural treasure offers a glimpse into Chicago’s gilded past while providing all the comforts of contemporary living.
1. Architectural Background
Designed by a visionary who shaped America’s academic landscape, this residence exemplifies the Collegiate Gothic style that dominated university campuses of the era.
The renowned architect behind this 1904 gem, James Gamble Rogers, was known for blending medieval European influences with American craftsmanship. His distinctive touch appears in the pointed arches, decorative stonework, and dramatic vertical lines that define the home’s character.
2. Historical Context
Built during America’s industrial revolution, this grand residence reflects the prosperity and social ambitions of its original owner. Hunter Woodis Finch, the coal magnate who commissioned this Gothic-style home, sought to establish his family among Chicago’s elite through architectural prestige.
During this period, wealthy businessmen often displayed their success through homes that borrowed from European architectural traditions, particularly Gothic and Romanesque styles.
3. Exterior Features
Impressive stonework creates a commanding street presence that has turned heads for over a century. This Gothic masterpiece features a steeply pitched roof, ornate limestone detailing, and leaded glass windows that filter sunlight into spectacular patterns.
Behind the main structure stands the original coach house, once home to horses and carriages but now transformed while preserving its historic character.
4. Interior Highlights
Walking through the grand entryway reveals a world where craftsmanship reigned supreme. Hand-carved woodwork adorns the formal dining room and library, while multiple fireplaces feature unique marble surrounds that have been meticulously preserved.
The sunlit breakfast room opens to a private terrace, offering a perfect blend of indoor and outdoor living unusual for homes of this era.
5. Restoration Efforts
Painstaking work by skilled artisans has brought this century-old beauty back to its original glory. Every marble surface has been carefully cleaned and restored using traditional methods, while damaged woodwork received attention from craftspeople specializing in historic preservation.
The original stained glass windows underwent professional conservation, ensuring these irreplaceable works of art will continue to cast their colorful glow for generations.
6. Modern Amenities
Seamlessly integrated contemporary features provide comfort without compromising historic integrity. The kitchen combines period-appropriate cabinetry with professional-grade appliances hidden behind custom panels.
This Chicago treasure now boasts updated plumbing, electrical systems, and climate control that operate invisibly within the historic framework. Smart home technology allows for convenient control of lighting, security, and entertainment systems.
7. Neighborhood Appeal
Tree-lined streets create an enclave of architectural history just minutes from urban amenities. The surrounding neighborhood boasts other significant homes from the same era, creating a cohesive historic district that has maintained its character for generations.
Residents enjoy proximity to cultural institutions, renowned universities, and lakefront recreation while living in a community that values its architectural heritage.
8. Market Details
Listed at $3,100,000, this historic home offers around 7,000 square feet, seven bedrooms, and elegant details that appeal to luxury buyers and architecture enthusiasts. Its blend of original craftsmanship and modern updates makes it a standout option for those seeking a one-of-a-kind residence.
The listing is handled by Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Chicago, attracting interest from serious buyers ready for an upscale investment. Monthly costs reflect the home’s high-end status, making it ideal for those prepared for both the purchase price and ongoing expenses.
