7 Florida Pizza Joints That Blow The Chains Out Of The Oven
Florida might be known for seafood and key lime pie, but the Sunshine State is hiding some serious pizza gems. Local pizza spots are serving up slices that make the big chains look like frozen supermarket pies.
These family-owned pizzerias put love and authentic ingredients into every bite, creating loyal followings across the state.
1. Big Mike’s Massive Masterpieces
Imagine a slice so big it requires two paper plates. That’s the reality at this beloved Cape Coral institution where New York-style pizza gets a Florida twist.
Locals line up daily for their famous crispy-yet-chewy crust and generous toppings. Each bite delivers that perfect balance of tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and golden-edge crunch that keeps regulars coming back.
2. Madison Avenue’s Pizza Challenge Champions
Would you attempt to eat a 32-inch pizza by yourself? Brave souls try this famous challenge weekly, though few succeed. Beyond the novelty, this Dunedin hotspot crafts outstanding hand-tossed pies.
The dough ferments for three days before hitting the oven, creating exceptional flavor depth.
3. Pie95’s Culinary Wood-Fired Wonders
From food truck sensation to brick-and-mortar success story, this Jacksonville gem represents pizza evolution at its finest.
Every Neapolitan-style pie emerges from a blazing wood-fired oven with that characteristic leopard-spotted crust. The marinara sauce simmers for hours, creating a depth of flavor that makes taste buds dance.
4. Dave’s Garage Where Flavor Gets Tuned Up
Vintage car parts and automotive memorabilia line the walls of this quirky Tallahassee institution.
But don’t let the gimmick fool you; this place takes pizza seriously. Their signature garlic butter crust has created a cult following among Florida State students and locals alike.
5. Nick’s Authentic Brooklyn Experience
The owner transplanted authentic Brooklyn pizza techniques to Panama City Beach, bringing a taste of New York to the Gulf Coast. His two-pound slices have become legendary among tourists and locals.
Coupled with imported Italian tomatoes and Wisconsin cheese, these pies deliver an authentic northeastern experience under the Florida sun.
6. Pienezza’s Hidden Strip Mall Treasure
Don’t judge this Orlando pizzeria by its unassuming strip mall location. Inside, you’ll discover Italian-style magic happening with imported flour and house-made mozzarella.
Each bite offers that perfect balance of chewy and crisp textures. Their margherita pizza; simple yet sublime, converts chain pizza loyalists with just one taste.
7. Bronx House’s Florida-Born Thin Crust Revolution
Despite the New York-inspired name, this homegrown Florida chain started right here in the Sunshine State. Their signature thin crust achieves the impossible: sturdy enough to hold generous toppings yet delicate enough to fold.
What began as a single location has expanded across South Florida, proving that authentic pizza can grow without sacrificing quality.
