4 Indiana Collectibles Falling In Value And 6 Still Rising
Indiana has a rich history of collectibles that once brought big money at auctions and estate sales. But times change, and so do the values of these treasured items.
Some pieces are losing their appeal while others keep climbing in worth, making it essential for collectors to know what’s hot and what’s not in today’s market.
1. Hummel Figurines
These adorable porcelain children once commanded premium prices at antique shops throughout the state. Market interest has cooled dramatically as baby boomers downsize their collections.
I’ve watched dealers struggle to move inventory even at reduced prices. The sentimental value remains high for some families, but financial value continues its downward trend with fewer buyers entering the market each year.
2. Beanie Babies
Remember the 1990s craze when people bought these thinking they’d fund college tuition? Most Beanie Babies are practically worthless now, selling for pocket change online.
Only extremely rare versions hold any significant value today. Indiana attics and basements are packed with these plush toys that families expected would become retirement funds, but the bubble burst long ago.
3. Encyclopedia Sets
Massive encyclopedia collections once symbolized knowledge and prestige in Indiana homes. The internet made these beautifully bound volumes practically obsolete overnight.
Thrift stores often refuse donations of complete sets because they take up too much space. Even rare editions struggle to find buyers willing to pay more than a few dollars, as digital resources dominate modern research needs.
4. Depression Glass
Your grandmother’s colorful glassware collection might not be worth what you think anymore. Once highly sought after, Depression glass has seen prices drop significantly over the past decade.
Younger collectors prefer modern aesthetics over vintage patterns. Many pieces now sell for just a few dollars at estate sales across Indiana, making this a tough time for sellers hoping to cash in.
5. Indianapolis 500 Memorabilia
Racing fans have always treasured items from America’s most famous speedway. Authentic vintage programs, signed photos, and race-worn items continue gaining value as the event approaches its next century milestone.
I’ve noticed collectors paying top dollar for pre-1970 materials and driver-signed pieces. The international appeal of IndyCar racing keeps demand strong, especially for items connected to legendary drivers and historic races.
6. Larry Bird Rookie Cards
Indiana’s basketball legend continues to be a hot commodity in the sports card market. Bird’s rookie cards have skyrocketed in value, with pristine examples selling for thousands of dollars.
The sports card boom of recent years has especially benefited items connected to Hoosier heroes. Collectors view these cards as solid investments, and graded versions in excellent condition keep breaking price records at auctions.
7. Fiesta Ware
Bright, cheerful, and incredibly collectible, this colorful dinnerware has experienced a major resurgence. Original pieces from the 1930s and 1940s fetch impressive prices, especially rare colors like red and cobalt.
Mid-century modern enthusiasts have driven demand upward across Indiana. I’ve watched complete sets sell for hundreds or even thousands, depending on condition and color combinations available in the collection.
8. Redware Pottery
Handcrafted by early Indiana potters, these rustic pieces represent authentic Americana that collectors crave. Genuine 19th-century redware commands premium prices at auctions throughout the Midwest.
Folk art enthusiasts appreciate the historical significance and craftsmanship involved. Signed pieces from known Indiana pottery makers are particularly valuable, with some examples selling for several thousand dollars depending on provenance and condition.
9. Vintage John Deere Toys
Farm toy collecting has become serious business in rural Indiana communities. Original die-cast tractors and implements from the 1950s through 1970s are climbing steadily in value.
Nostalgia plays a huge role as adult collectors seek childhood memories. Mint-condition pieces with original boxes can bring hundreds of dollars each, and rare models command even higher prices at specialized farm toy auctions held throughout the state.
10. Mid-Century Modern Furniture
Collectors once paid top dollar for sleek Danish credenzas and Eames-style chairs that filled Indiana homes during the 1950s and 60s. The market exploded about a decade ago when everyone wanted that retro atomic look.
Today, prices have cooled considerably as younger buyers prefer different styles. Supply has also increased as more baby boomers downsize and flood the market with their furniture. What once sold for thousands now often goes for hundreds.
