Rediscover The Magic Of Wisconsin Supper Clubs

Wisconsin supper clubs aren’t just restaurants, they’re time machines to a bygone era of hospitality and hearty comfort food.

These iconic establishments have been serving up old-fashioned cocktails, relish trays, and prime rib to hungry Wisconsinites since the Prohibition era.

Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through the Badger State, these legendary supper clubs deserve your immediate attention.

1. The Packing House: Milwaukee’s Mid-Century Marvel

Holy smoked meat heaven, this place hasn’t changed since your grandparents had their first date! The Packing House serves up nostalgia with a side of the crispiest hash browns this side of the Mississippi.

You’ll find this Milwaukee institution holding court on Layton Avenue, where the relish trays arrive before you’ve even settled into your red leather booth.

Brandy Old Fashioneds flow like water here, sweet or sour depending on your mood. The prime rib practically falls apart when you look at it, and don’t get me started on their Friday fish fry. It’s the stuff of Wisconsin legend.

2. The Fireside: Fort Atkinson’s Theatrical Dining Experience

Where else can you catch dinner AND a Broadway-caliber show without mortgaging your cheese farm? The Fireside in Fort Atkinson combines theatrical performances with classic supper club fare in a way that’ll make you forget you’re in small-town Wisconsin.

This family-owned beauty has been dazzling diners since 1964 with its unique dinner-theater concept. Inside this sprawling complex, massive stone fireplaces (hence the name, genius) warm the various dining rooms.

Their chicken cordon bleu could make a French chef weep with joy, and the chocolate lava cake finale will have you plotting your return before you’ve even paid the check.

3. Mader’s Restaurant: Milwaukee’s German-Inspired Time Capsule

Lederhosen not required but strongly encouraged at this Milwaukee institution that’s been slinging schnitzel since 1902! Mader’s Restaurant blends traditional German cuisine with Wisconsin supper club vibes in a building that looks like it was plucked straight from a Bavarian village.

The interior feels like a medieval castle, with suits of armor, antiques, and enough dark wood to make a lumberjack blush.

Their sauerbraten will transport you straight to the old country without the pricey plane ticket. Don’t you dare skip the potato pancakes or their famous apple strudel. The German beer selection is longer than my last relationship, and twice as satisfying.

4. The Blue Roadhouse: Elkhorn’s Rural Retreat

Though it sits unassumingly on a country road, this place packs more flavor and character than spots twice its size.

The Blue Roadhouse in Elkhorn represents everything a true Wisconsin supper club should be, unpretentious, welcoming, and absolutely delicious. Locals have been keeping this place humming since the 1970s, and one bite of their hand-cut steaks explains why.

The bar area buzzes with conversation while patrons wait for their tables. Their relish tray game is strong, think pickled everything and cheese spreads that would make your cardiologist nervous.

Friday fish fry features lake perch so fresh you’ll swear it jumped from Geneva Lake to your plate.

5. The Old Fashioned: Madison’s Retro Escape

Stepping into The Old Fashioned in Madison is like opening a portal to the past, where culinary traditions meet modern flair. This supper club is renowned for its Wisconsin-centric menu, emphasizing local produce and classic dishes like bratwurst and cheese curds.

With a warm, inviting atmosphere, The Old Fashioned captures the essence of what makes Wisconsin supper clubs special. The decor, reminiscent of the 1960s, pairs perfectly with the hearty meals, making every visit a nostalgic journey.

Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the blend of tradition, flavor, and hospitality at The Old Fashioned offers a unique dining experience. This retro escape invites diners to reminisce and enjoy the simple pleasures of Midwestern cuisine.

6. Ishnala Supper Club

Perched on the scenic Mirror Lake, Ishnala Supper Club offers an enchanting dining experience. Its rustic setting amidst lush woods makes it feel like a secret retreat.

Inside, the ambiance is warm and inviting, with vintage decor and soft lighting setting a nostalgic mood. The menu features classic Wisconsin fare, with prime rib and fresh fish as highlights.

For over 60 years, Ishnala has captivated guests with its charm and culinary excellence. It’s a place where nature and tradition create a memorable evening.

7. The Del-Bar

Established in 1943, The Del-Bar is a testament to timeless elegance and culinary prowess. Located in Lake Delton, it showcases mid-century modern design.

The interior is sophisticated, with plush seating and dim lighting that exudes romance. The menu is a fusion of traditional and contemporary, with a focus on steak and seafood.

Patrons can enjoy expertly crafted cocktails at the stylish bar, making every visit a special occasion. The Del-Bar remains a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike.

8. Buckhorn Supper Club

Nestled on Lake Koshkonong’s shores, Buckhorn Supper Club is a delightful fusion of nature and comfort. The outdoor seating offers breathtaking lakeside views.

Diners can savor meals on the wooden deck, enjoying the open air. The club’s menu brims with seafood specialties, including its famous Friday fish fry.

The Buckhorn is known for its laid-back atmosphere and friendly service, ensuring guests feel right at home. It’s the perfect spot for a relaxing evening by the water.

9. Little Bohemia Lodge

Little Bohemia Lodge is steeped in history, famously known for the 1934 shootout involving John Dillinger. The lodge’s rustic cabin charm invites guests to step back in time.

Surrounded by dense woods, its cozy dining area with a stone fireplace offers a warm retreat. The menu combines hearty fare with a touch of nostalgia.

Visitors can explore memorabilia and immerse themselves in the lodge’s storied past. It’s a unique blend of history and hospitality that captivates everyone who visits.

10. Gib’s on the Lake

Gib’s on the Lake offers a contemporary twist on the traditional supper club. Located in Kewaunee, it boasts stunning panoramic views of Lake Michigan.

The club’s elegant interior, with modern touches, creates an upscale dining experience. The menu features gourmet dishes that cater to discerning palates.

Large windows allow natural light to flood in, enhancing the serene lake backdrop. Gib’s is perfect for those seeking sophistication and scenic beauty in one venue.

11. Silvercryst Supper Club

Silvercryst Supper Club, nestled by Pearl Lake, offers a charming escape with vintage allure. Its iconic sign welcomes guests to a world of nostalgia.

The spacious dining area features classic decor, with windows offering serene lake views. The menu is filled with comforting classics, from steaks to fish.

Guests can unwind in this cozy atmosphere where time seems to stand still. Silvercryst’s blend of history and heart makes it a treasured destination.