10 West Virginia Seafood Shacks Only Locals Know Serving Coastal Flavor In The Mountains

West Virginia might be landlocked, but that hasn’t stopped creative restaurateurs from bringing the ocean’s best flavors straight to Appalachian country.

Hidden throughout the Mountain State are seafood shacks that serve up everything from steamed crabs to fried catfish, making coastal dining accessible without the long drive to the shore.

These local favorites have mastered the art of delivering fresh catches and bold seasonings that rival any beachside joint.

Whether craving a seafood boil or perfectly fried shrimp, these mountain gems prove that great seafood isn’t limited to coastal towns.

1. Mother Shuckers Crab Shack

Bright blue walls and nautical decorations create an instant coastal vibe the moment guests step through the door.

Located at 1014 Winchester Ave, Martinsburg, WV 25401, this energetic spot has built a loyal following with its commitment to fresh shellfish and generous portions.

The crab cakes arrive golden and crispy on the outside while staying tender inside, packed with real crab meat rather than filler.

Steamed crab legs come piled high on platters, served with warm butter and all the tools needed for cracking shells.

The atmosphere feels relaxed and family-friendly, with servers who know the menu inside out and happily guide first-timers through ordering.

Weekend evenings tend to draw crowds, so arriving early or calling ahead helps avoid long waits during peak dinner hours.

2. Fish Frenzy Seafood

Don’t let the strip mall location fool you – this spot delivers serious seafood flavor that keeps locals coming back week after week.

Situated at 411 Beckley Crossing Shopping Ctr, Beckley, WV 25801, Fish Frenzy has earned its reputation through consistently excellent seafood boils and fried fish baskets.

The boils arrive in bags bursting with shrimp, sausage, corn, and potatoes, all coated in flavorful Cajun seasoning that can be adjusted to preferred spice levels.

Fried catfish and whiting baskets come with crispy golden breading that stays crunchy even after the ride home.

Portions run large enough to share or take leftovers, making the modest prices feel even better.

Staff members work efficiently during busy lunch rushes, keeping wait times reasonable even when the small dining area fills up completely.

3. Jewel City Seafood Restaurant & Market

This dual-purpose establishment combines a cozy restaurant with a retail market, letting diners enjoy fresh seafood on-site or take ingredients home for cooking.

Found at 1317 4th Ave, Huntington, WV 25701, Jewel City has become a community staple for anyone seeking quality fish, crab, and oysters.

The restaurant side serves straightforward preparations that let the seafood’s natural flavors shine through without heavy sauces or complicated recipes.

Crab legs come steamed to perfection, while fried oysters maintain their plump texture beneath a light, seasoned coating.

The market section stocks fresh catches that change based on availability, with knowledgeable staff offering cooking tips and preparation advice.

Regulars appreciate the no-frills atmosphere that prioritizes food quality over fancy décor, creating an authentic neighborhood gathering spot.

4. Kitzie’s Restaurant & Lounge

Rustic charm meets coastal cuisine at this combination restaurant and lounge that feels like a mountain retreat with an oceanside menu.

Positioned at 1545 Rock Cliff Dr, Martinsburg, WV 25401, Kitzie’s offers seafood platters that showcase multiple preparations on single generous plates.

Fried fish, shrimp, and scallops arrive hot and crispy, accompanied by classic sides like coleslaw and hush puppies that complement the seafood perfectly.

The lounge area provides a comfortable spot for drinks before dinner or casual conversation after the meal ends.

Wood accents and warm lighting create an inviting atmosphere that works equally well for date nights or family gatherings.

Service tends to be attentive without hovering, with servers who check in at just the right moments throughout the meal.

5. Gatsby Restaurant

This spot at 1420 Mountaineer Cir, New Cumberland, WV 26047 proudly blends state pride with seafood passion, decorating walls with both mountain memorabilia and coastal fishing gear.

Lobster rolls arrive on toasted buns with generous chunks of meat dressed in light mayo or warm butter depending on preference.

Fish tacos bring California vibes to Appalachia, with grilled or fried fish tucked into soft tortillas with cabbage slaw and tangy sauce.

The kids’ menu offers simpler preparations like plain fried shrimp or fish strips that appeal to younger palates not ready for bold seasonings.

Beer selections include local West Virginia craft brews alongside coastal favorites, creating beverage pairings that honor both regions.

Takeout orders stay hot and organized in sturdy containers that prevent spills during the drive home to hungry families waiting for dinner.

6. Big Bite Restaurant

Louisiana influences shine through in every dish at 1210 Stafford Dr, Princeton, WV 24740, from the dark roux-based gumbo to the spicy crawfish étouffée ladled over white rice.

Seafood boils get dumped directly onto paper-covered tables, encouraging hands-on dining that brings groups together over shared messy meals.

Andouille sausage adds smoky depth to shrimp and crab boils, while corn and potatoes soak up all the flavorful seasoning.

The spice level can be customized from mild to mouth-burning hot, accommodating both timid eaters and heat seekers.

Hush puppies arrive hot and slightly sweet, perfect for soaking up extra sauce or simply enjoying as savory treats between bites.

Weekend evenings sometimes feature live music that adds energy to the dining room, creating a festive atmosphere that extends meals into memorable experiences.

7. Dockside Grille

Even without actual docks nearby, this restaurant creates waterfront ambiance through clever design and authentic coastal menu offerings at its location at 69 Mont Chateau Rd, Morgantown, WV 26508.

Coconut shrimp arrives with a crispy coating studded with shredded coconut, served alongside sweet orange marmalade dipping sauce.

Seafood pasta dishes combine multiple shellfish varieties with garlic, white wine, and fresh herbs over perfectly cooked linguine.

The raw bar offers oysters on the half shell for adventurous diners, though availability varies based on what arrives fresh each week.

Happy hour specials include discounted appetizers like calamari and crab dip, making early evening visits particularly budget-friendly.

Reservations get accepted for larger groups, though walk-ins usually find seating without much wait during weekday dinner hours when crowds thin out considerably.

8. Mother Shuckers Crab Shack

Located at 1014 Winchester Ave, Martinsburg, WV 25401, this place sets a playful tone that carries through the entire dining experience.

Popcorn shrimp lives up to its name with tiny, crispy morsels that disappear quickly once the basket hits the table.

Buffalo shrimp adds spicy wings flavor to seafood, tossed in hot sauce and served with cooling ranch or blue cheese dressing.

The atmosphere leans casual and loud, with families and friend groups creating a lively buzz that peaks during weekend dinner rushes.

Combo meals pair shrimp preparations with sides and drinks at package prices that beat ordering items individually.

Counter staff work with speed and efficiency, calling out order numbers clearly so guests can grab their meals and find tables without confusion or delays.

9. Jewel City Seafood Restaurant & Market

Contemporary design meets traditional seafood preparations in a space that feels both modern and welcoming to all generations at 1317 4th Ave, Huntington, WV 25701.

Grilled mahi-mahi arrives with tropical fruit salsa that adds brightness and color to the flaky white fish.

Seafood towers stack oysters, shrimp cocktail, and crab claws on ice, creating impressive presentations perfect for celebrations or special occasions.

The wine list focuses on whites and rosés that complement seafood, with staff offering pairing suggestions for uncertain guests.

Desserts include key lime pie and other coastal classics that provide sweet endings to savory seafood feasts.

Online ordering systems let guests place takeout orders ahead of time, reducing wait times when picking up meals during busy lunch and dinner rushes throughout the week.

10. Mountain Tide Seafood Kitchen

The location 2226 Market St, Wheeling, WV 26003 combines mountain geography and coastal cuisine that defines this establishment’s unique identity.

Seafood risotto combines arborio rice with shrimp, scallops, and parmesan cheese in a creamy dish that feels both elegant and comforting.

Blackened catfish demonstrates how proper seasoning transforms simple fish into memorable meals worth returning for repeatedly.

Side options extend beyond typical fries to include roasted vegetables, rice pilaf, and fresh salads that provide lighter alternatives.

The open kitchen design lets diners watch cooks at work, adding entertainment value and transparency to the dining experience.

Gift cards make popular presents for locals who want to share their favorite seafood spot with friends and family visiting from out of town or state.