Beloved Georgia Restaurants Known For Their Incredible Homemade Pie

When you think of Georgia, sweet tea and peach cobbler might come to mind.

But across this beautiful state, you’ll find restaurants and bakeries crafting some of the most mouthwatering homemade pies you’ve ever tasted.

From flaky fruit pies to rich cream-filled creations, these spots have earned loyal followings for their dedication to quality and flavor.

Get ready to discover where locals go when they’re craving a slice of heaven.

1. Pie Bar (Woodstock)

Fresh ingredients and creative flavors make every visit here feel like a celebration. You’ll find this bakery at 9770 Highway 92, Suite 700, Woodstock, GA 30188, ready to satisfy your pie cravings any day of the week. The menu features everything from classic apple and pecan to more adventurous options like salted caramel chocolate and key lime.

Each pie is handmade daily using recipes that balance tradition with innovation. The crust is always perfectly flaky, and the fillings are generous without being overly sweet. You can order whole pies for special occasions or just grab a slice to enjoy with coffee.

The cozy atmosphere makes it easy to linger over your dessert. Staff members are friendly and happy to help you choose from the rotating selection. Whether you’re a pie purist or love trying new flavors, you’ll leave planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your first slice.

2. Pie Bar (Marietta)

Stepping into this location feels like coming home to grandma’s kitchen. Located at 1380 Canton Road, Suite 102, Marietta, GA 30066, this bakery has become a community favorite since opening its doors. The smell of baking pies greets you the moment you walk in, making it almost impossible to resist ordering more than you planned.

What sets this spot apart is the attention to detail in every single pie. Bakers arrive early each morning to prepare fresh batches, ensuring you get the best possible product. The seasonal offerings change throughout the year, giving you new reasons to return again and again.

Families gather here for celebrations, and solo visitors treat themselves to a well-deserved indulgence. The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable for such high-quality desserts. Don’t skip the bourbon pecan if it’s available—locals consider it a must-try specialty that showcases Georgia flavors at their finest.

3. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Southern comfort comes in pie form at this delightful shop that’s won hearts across Georgia. You’ll discover this gem at 2140 Roswell Road, Suite 140, Marietta, GA 30062, where the focus is on creating pies that taste like they came from your grandmother’s oven. Each recipe uses real butter, fresh eggs, and quality ingredients that you can actually taste in every bite.

The signature buttermilk pie is the star of the show, with its creamy texture and subtle sweetness. But you’ll also find chocolate chess, coconut cream, and fruit pies that change with the seasons. Mini pies are available if you want to try multiple flavors or prefer a smaller portion.

What makes this place special is the commitment to scratch baking. Nothing comes from a mix or a factory. You can watch bakers working in the open kitchen, rolling dough and crimping edges by hand.

It’s this dedication that keeps customers coming back week after week.

4. Crave Pie Studio

Artisan pies with gourmet flair await you at this creative bakery. Located at 1675 Cumberland Parkway SE, Suite 312, Smyrna, GA 30080, this studio takes pie-making to the next level with unique flavor combinations you won’t find anywhere else. Think salted honey chess, brown butter apple, and dark chocolate raspberry—each one a masterpiece of taste and texture.

The bakers here treat pie-making as an art form. Crusts are made with European-style butter for extra richness, and fillings are crafted with locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. You can order by the slice or take home a whole pie for your next gathering.

The modern, clean space feels welcoming and bright. Display cases show off the beautiful pies, each one looking almost too pretty to eat. Almost.

The staff is knowledgeable about ingredients and can guide you toward options that match your taste preferences perfectly.

5. The Pie Hole

Bold flavors and generous portions define this popular pie destination. You’ll find The Pie Hole at 1275 Caroline Street NE, Suite D-120, Atlanta, GA 30307, serving up both sweet and savory options that satisfy any craving. The menu includes traditional favorites alongside creative inventions that push the boundaries of what pie can be.

Sweet tooth calling? Try the Mexican chocolate or the Earl Grey tea pie. Looking for something savory?

The chicken pot pie and shepherd’s pie are hearty enough to count as a full meal. Everything is made in-house using recipes developed through lots of testing and tasting.

The casual vibe makes it perfect for a quick lunch or a leisurely dessert break. You can grab a slice to go or settle in at one of the tables. Prices are fair, and the quality is consistently excellent.

Many customers make this a regular stop in their weekly routine because the pies never disappoint.

6. Doodle Pies

Whimsical names and serious flavor make this bakery a standout. Located at 320 East Clayton Street, Athens, GA 30601, Doodle Pies has been delighting University of Georgia students and locals alike for years. The college town atmosphere adds to the fun, laid-back experience of choosing your perfect slice.

Menu options range from classic pecan and apple to more adventurous choices like peanut butter chocolate and lemon blueberry. Each pie is baked fresh daily, and the rotating specials keep things interesting. You might find pumpkin spice in fall or fresh strawberry in spring, depending on what’s in season.

The small space fills up quickly during peak hours, but the line moves fast. Staff members are enthusiastic about their products and happy to offer samples if you’re torn between flavors. Whether you’re grabbing a quick study break treat or celebrating after a big game, this spot delivers every single time with quality you can count on.

7. Paul’s Pot Pies

Savory comfort food reaches new heights at this specialty shop. You’ll find Paul’s Pot Pies at 1850 Epps Bridge Parkway, Suite 105, Athens, GA 30606, where the focus is on hearty, filling pies that warm you from the inside out. These aren’t desserts—they’re complete meals packed with protein, vegetables, and rich, flavorful gravies.

The chicken pot pie is a customer favorite, loaded with tender meat and vegetables in a creamy sauce. But you’ll also find beef, turkey, and vegetarian options that change regularly. Each pie comes in its own dish, ready to bake at home or enjoy fresh from the oven.

What makes these pies special is the quality of ingredients. Real chicken stock, fresh vegetables, and hand-rolled crusts make all the difference. You can taste the care that goes into each one.

Families love keeping a few in the freezer for busy weeknights when you need something satisfying without spending hours in the kitchen.

8. Heaps Pies

Australian-inspired pies bring international flair to Georgia. Located at 333 Sandy Springs Circle NE, Suite 214, Sandy Springs, GA 30328, Heaps Pies introduces you to the world of handheld meat pies that are wildly popular Down Under. These portable pastries are perfect for lunch on the go or a quick dinner solution.

The menu features options like steak and cheese, chicken curry, and shepherd’s pie, all wrapped in buttery, flaky pastry. Sweet pies are also available, including apple crumble and chocolate varieties. Each pie is individually sized, making portion control easy and sharing unnecessary—you’ll want your own.

The concept might be new to some Americans, but one bite will make you a convert. The fillings are generous and well-seasoned, and the pastry is sturdy enough to hold everything without falling apart. Many customers grab several at once to reheat throughout the week.

It’s convenient, delicious, and different from typical Georgia fare in the best possible way.

9. Southern Sweets Bakery

Traditional Southern baking shines at this beloved local bakery. You’ll find Southern Sweets Bakery at 2225 Roswell Road, Marietta, GA 30062, where generations of pie recipes come to life every single day. The bakery case is always filled with gorgeous pies that look as good as they taste, from towering meringues to lattice-topped fruit creations.

Pecan pie is a standout here, made with Georgia pecans and just the right amount of sweetness. Sweet potato pie appears in fall and winter, offering that classic Southern flavor profile. Fruit pies change with the seasons, featuring peaches in summer and apples in autumn.

The bakers start early each morning, and you can often catch the aroma of baking pies from the parking lot. Everything is made from scratch using tried-and-true methods. Locals know to call ahead for whole pies during holidays, as they sell out quickly.

The reasonable prices and consistent quality have built a loyal customer base that spans generations of families.

10. Dawson’s Kitchen

Farm-to-table philosophy extends to desserts at this charming restaurant. Located at 187 North Main Street, Alpharetta, GA 30009, Dawson’s Kitchen serves meals made with locally sourced ingredients, and their homemade pies are no exception. The seasonal menu means pie offerings change throughout the year based on what’s fresh and available.

During peach season, you’ll find incredible Georgia peach pie that showcases the state’s most famous fruit. Fall brings pumpkin and apple varieties, while winter features rich chocolate and nut-based options. Each pie is made in-house by the pastry team, following recipes that highlight natural flavors without relying on excessive sugar.

The restaurant atmosphere is upscale casual, perfect for a nice dinner that ends with an exceptional dessert. Portions are generous, and presentation is beautiful. You can order pie by the slice after your meal or call ahead to reserve a whole pie for takeout.

The commitment to quality ingredients makes every bite worth savoring slowly.

11. Milltowne Gourmet

Gourmet sandwiches and incredible pies make this deli a local treasure. You’ll find Milltowne Gourmet at 5975 Roswell Road NE, Suite C-228, Sandy Springs, GA 30328, where the focus is on fresh, high-quality food made to order. While many come for the famous sandwiches, those in the know save room for a slice of homemade pie.

The pie selection rotates but always includes at least a few options. Fruit pies feature fresh, seasonal ingredients, and cream pies are silky smooth with real whipped cream on top. The crust is always perfectly baked golden brown and flaky without being greasy or tough.

What sets this place apart is the dedication to doing everything well. The same care that goes into crafting sandwiches extends to the dessert menu. You can grab a slice to enjoy with your lunch or order a whole pie for your next event.

Regular customers have their favorites and often call ahead to make sure their preferred flavor is available that day.

12. Peggy’s Restaurant

Classic diner charm meets homestyle cooking at this longtime favorite. Located at 1955 Cliff Valley Way NE, Atlanta, GA 30329, Peggy’s Restaurant has been serving the community for decades with consistent quality and warm hospitality. The dessert case always features several homemade pies that rotate daily, ensuring variety and freshness.

Coconut cream pie is legendary here, with a mile-high meringue that’s perfectly browned. Chocolate pie satisfies serious chocolate lovers, and the fruit pies showcase whatever’s in season. Each slice is generous, often requiring a to-go box because finishing it in one sitting is a challenge.

The restaurant feels like stepping back in time to when diners were community gathering places. Waitstaff know regular customers by name, and the atmosphere is genuinely welcoming. Prices are incredibly reasonable, especially considering the portion sizes.

Whether you stop by for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, make sure to check out the pie selection before you leave. You won’t regret adding dessert to your order.

13. Company Supply

Modern Southern cuisine includes desserts worth celebrating at this stylish spot. You’ll find Company Supply at 97 Armour Drive NE, Atlanta, GA 30324, where the menu reimagines traditional dishes with contemporary techniques. The dessert menu changes seasonally, but homemade pie is always featured in some form.

Expect creative twists on classics—maybe a bourbon chocolate pecan pie or a buttermilk pie with fresh berries. The pastry team takes pride in presentation, so your dessert will arrive looking Instagram-worthy. But more importantly, it tastes incredible, with balanced flavors and perfect textures.

The restaurant atmosphere is upscale but not stuffy, making it suitable for date nights or celebrations with friends. The bar program is excellent if you want to pair your pie with coffee or a dessert cocktail. Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends.

While the savory menu gets lots of attention, don’t overlook the desserts—they’re crafted with the same level of skill and creativity that makes this restaurant a destination.

14. Southern Sweets Bakery (Avondale Estates)

Neighborhood charm and exceptional pies make this shop an Avondale Estates icon. You’ll find Southern Sweets Pie Shop at 3 North Clarendon Avenue, Avondale Estates, GA 30002, right in the heart of this quaint community. The bakery has become a gathering place where neighbors meet for coffee and a slice of something sweet.

The pie case always offers variety—fruit pies bursting with flavor, cream pies topped with real whipped cream, and nut pies that are rich without being overly sweet. Everything is baked fresh daily in small batches to ensure quality. The recipes balance traditional Southern flavors with just enough creativity to keep things interesting.

What makes this location special is the sense of community it fosters. Staff members remember your preferences and greet you warmly. The small space feels cozy and inviting, perfect for enjoying your pie with a cup of coffee.

Whole pies are available for order, and many locals consider this their go-to source for celebration desserts and holiday gatherings.

15. Sass! Sweets (Thomasville)

Small-town hospitality and big-time flavor define this Thomasville treasure. Located at 118 East Jackson Street, Thomasville, GA 31792, Sass! Sweets brings homemade goodness to South Georgia with pies that have earned devoted fans throughout the region.

The bakery specializes in Southern classics made with recipes that honor tradition while embracing quality ingredients.

Key lime pie is tangy and refreshing, perfect for Georgia’s warm climate. Pecan pie features local nuts and just the right amount of filling. Seasonal offerings include fresh berry pies in summer and pumpkin in fall.

Each one is made by hand with attention to detail that shows in every bite.

The downtown location adds to the charm, making it easy to stop in while exploring Thomasville’s historic district. The friendly staff treats everyone like family, offering samples and recommendations based on your preferences. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this bakery deserves a spot on your must-visit list for authentic Southern sweets done right.