We Ranked The 5 Best Idaho Pizza Buffets And Here Is Who Made The Final Cut
One Idaho pizza buffet sits right next to bowling lanes, so you can grab a slice between frames. Another serves dessert pizza on the buffet line, and nobody blinks.
I love that detail. Pizza buffets here are not one-note affairs.
Some pair the pies with pasta bars, others with arcades, and a few with salad bars big enough to make you feel responsible.
Idaho has plenty of pizza, but a great buffet is its own art form. The pies need to keep coming.
The salad needs to stay fresh. The price needs to feel like a small win.
So I went looking for the spots that pull it off across the state, from the Snake River Plain to the Magic Valley. Five made the final cut.
One of them even sits on the road to an Air Force base. Which one would get your lunch break?
1. Homestead Pizza & Bowling
Strikes and slices share the same roof here, which feels like a very efficient use of a Saturday. You can bowl a frame, then wander back for another plate without changing buildings.
The buffet setup is straightforward and generous. You get all-you-can-eat pizza, a salad bar, and bottomless drinks in one deal.
The pizza menu covers classics and specialty pies, and the crust leans crispy. Toppings don’t get skimped on, which matters when you’re stacking three slices on one plate.
Lunch is when the buffet special shines. Mornings and midday tend to run quieter than the busy evening crowds, so an early visit could mean more elbow room.
Gluten-free options help mixed groups, and the menu also includes vegan choices. That makes it easier to bring along the friend with a long list of dietary notes.
Kids get plenty to do beyond eating. There’s an arcade, cosmic bowling, a kids’ menu, and high chairs for the littlest crew members.
A fireplace adds a homey touch for those long eastern Idaho winters. Birthday parties fit right in, and reservations are accepted if you’re planning ahead.
Honestly, few places let you burn off lunch while still technically being at lunch. Check before driving for buffet timing.
Address: 1770 W Broadway St, Idaho Falls, ID 83402
2. Pizza Pie Cafe
Dessert pizza on a buffet line is a bold life choice, and Rexburg fully supports it. This laid-back spot treats sweet pies as a real course, not an afterthought.
Before you get there, though, you’ve got options. The all-you-can-eat spread includes pizza, a pasta bar, and a salad bar.
Fresh pies show up fast when a tray empties. That keeps the line moving and saves you from staring sadly at the last lonely slice.
Rexburg is a college town, and the crowd reflects it. Students, families, and travelers passing through eastern Idaho all fit comfortably in the casual room.
Wi-fi is available if you want to linger with a laptop and a third plate. A private dining room also helps when your group outgrows a regular table.
Kids’ birthdays work well here too. There’s a kids’ menu, and the place accepts reservations for bigger plans.
Friday and Saturday evenings get the busiest. Weekday mornings toward lunch run calmer, so timing your visit could pay off.
Plan around Sundays, since the restaurant closes that day. Otherwise, save some room, because skipping dessert pizza would feel like leaving a movie before the ending.
Address: 240 N 2nd E, Rexburg, ID 83440
3. Idaho Pizza Company
With Idaho right there in the name, this Meridian spot has some state pride to live up to. Its pizzas lean on locally sourced ingredients, which feels fitting.
The lunch buffet is the big draw. You get unlimited pizza, a salad bar, and a soft drink with refills.
Variety keeps the trays interesting. The menu includes pepperoni, the Idaho Supreme, specialty pies, and gluten-free pizza.
Vegetarians aren’t stuck picking at croutons either. The restaurant offers a full vegetarian menu, so meat-free diners have real choices.
An arcade area gives younger guests something to do between plates. High chairs, a kids’ menu, and birthday-friendly space round things out for families.
Sports fans get covered too, since the room works well for watching games. A private dining room helps when the whole team shows up hungry.
Meridian keeps growing fast in the Treasure Valley, and plenty of chains have moved in. A local pizza company holding its own feels like a small hometown win.
Afternoons from Thursday through Saturday tend to be busiest. Go a little earlier, and you might snag a quieter booth for the buffet.
Address: 405 E Fairview Ave, Meridian, ID 83642
4. Pizza Pie Cafe | Twin Falls
Yes, the same pie-loving brand made the list twice, and the Magic Valley earned its own spot. Twin Falls gets a version worth the drive from Burley or Jerome.
Space is part of the appeal. The dining room is clean and roomy, which helps when the buffet gets bustling.
Pizza is only the opening act. A pasta bar, a fresh salad bar, and appetizers widen the spread considerably.
Then there’s dessert, the real headliner for many. You’ll find a wide variety of dessert pizzas, and you can go back as often as you like.
A full vegetarian menu keeps options open for meat-free eaters. High chairs and a kids’ menu make it easy for families with toddlers.
College students and families both show up here. Wi-fi helps if somebody needs to finish homework between bites.
Craving dessert after hiking near the Snake River Canyon? This spot makes a handy refuel stop on the way home.
Friday and Saturday evenings run busiest. Mid-week mornings into lunch tend to stay quieter, which is good news for patient grazers.
Remember the Sunday closure before you load up the car. Otherwise, call it a delicious excuse to plan a weekday treat instead.
Address: 1826 Canyon Crest Dr, Twin Falls, ID 83301
5. Pizza Hut
Sure, you know the name, but a dine-in buffet from this chain has become rarer than a cool day in an Idaho August. Mountain Home still keeps one going.
The location sits right on Airbase Road. That makes it a natural lunch stop for anyone heading toward Mountain Home Air Force Base.
The buffet line covers the familiar favorites. Expect a selection of pizzas, fresh breadsticks, and a plentiful salad bar.
Cheese and pepperoni pies anchor the menu. Fried mozzarella sticks are also on offer if you want something extra crunchy.
For many folks, this buffet carries a big dose of nostalgia. Lots of Idahoans grew up on a Pizza Hut lunch buffet after church or school events.
The value is a big part of the draw. Lunch here usually lands in the range of a few dollars per slice-filled plate, depending on how hungry you are.
Quick service helps on a tight lunch hour. Free parking out front makes the stop even easier.
Buffet availability can vary, so check before driving. Still, finding one of these classic setups alive and well feels like spotting an old friend downtown.
Address: 605 Airbase Rd, Mountain Home, ID 83647
