6 Pennsylvania Amish Furniture Stores That Outsell The Chains

Pennsylvania’s Amish craftsmen have built a reputation for creating furniture that stands the test of time. Their dedication to quality woodworking and attention to detail have helped local Amish furniture stores compete with, and often outsell major retail chains. These family-owned businesses combine old-world craftsmanship with personalized service that big-box stores simply can’t match.

1. Peaceful Valley Furniture

Nestled in Lancaster County, this family-owned business has been crafting Amish furniture since 1991. Their oak dining sets, built by local Amish craftsmen, are known for their durability and timeless design — a favorite among both locals and visitors.

2. Country Lane Furniture

This expansive showroom showcases solid wood furniture made by Amish and Mennonite craftsmen. Known for custom bedroom sets, office furniture, and live-edge tables. Their in-house design team helps customers create one-of-a-kind pieces that blend traditional craftsmanship with modern needs.

3. Snyder’s Furniture

A family-run showroom offering handcrafted Amish furniture since 1983. They feature custom dining sets, bedroom suites, and outdoor poly lumber furniture, all made by Amish artisans. Each piece is built to order, allowing customers to choose wood type, stain, and hardware for a truly personalized heirloom.

4. Alegacy Furniture

A spacious gallery featuring handcrafted furniture from Amish woodworkers. Offers everything from gliders and jewelry chests to full bedroom and dining sets in cherry, oak, maple, and hickory. They specialize in small-space solutions and offer white-glove delivery throughout the region.

5. Keystone Collections

Family-owned workshop crafting heirloom-quality furniture with guaranteed completion dates. Each piece is built to order and signed by the craftsman, ensuring authenticity and lasting value. Their finishes go through up to 20 hand-applied steps, creating a durable surface that resists stains and wear.

6. Martin’s Furniture

Second-generation business offering custom Amish furniture for every room in the home. Visitors can tour the workshop and watch their furniture being built from raw lumber to final finish. They use locally sourced hardwoods and offer full customization, from wood species to hardware and stain.